The Supreme Court Requires Deference to Plan Administrator’s Interpretation of ERISA Plan Notwithstanding Administrator’s Prior Invalid Interpretation





Jonathan K. Youngwood Jonathan K. Youngwood
George S. Wang George S. Wang

In Conkright v. Frommert, No. 08-810, issued on March 21, the United States Supreme Court addressed the proper standard of review that applies to a plan administrator’s interpretation of a plan covered by the Employee Retirement Income Security Act.  The Court held 5-3 that the district court should have deferred to the plan administrator’s interpretation of the plan at issue notwithstanding the fact that a prior related interpretation by the administrator was found to be invalid.  In its decision, authored by Chief Justice Roberts, the Court rejected a “one-strike-and-you’re out” approach under which administrators would only be entitled to deference in connection with their initial interpretations of ERISA plans.

Team and Contacts