Article Type: Publications

  • More Flexibility on Form S-8: Key Takeaways From Recent SEC Staff Guidance

    On October 15, 2026, the staff (the “Staff”) of the Division of Corporation Finance of the Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”) released new and revised Corporation Finance Interpretations (“CFIs”) addressing the ability of public companies to register compensatory equity awards under the Securities Act of 1933, as amended (the “Securities Act”).[1]


    The CFIs reflect the Staff’s practical approach to SEC reporting and compliance. The CFIs enhance flexibility, reduce costs and broaden the range of securities that may be registered on Form S-8.[2] Notably, the Staff’s guidance supports the registration of already-granted but not yet vested restricted stock and restricted stock units (“RSUs”) on Form S-8 and reverses the Staff’s 2009 position that Form S-8 was unavailable for registering awards assumed in M&A transactions and held by former employees of an acquired company.


    The New and Revised CFIs


    Timing of Registration Extended

    • Registration of outstanding pre-IPO awards (New Question 271.28). A company that granted awards under an exemption from registration (such as Rule 701) before going public may, once it becomes eligible to use Form S-8, register on Form S-8, the shares underlying then-outstanding options, RSUs and restricted stock prior to vesting (or exercise, in the case of options, and settlement, in the case of RSUs) of the outstanding equity award.
    • Registration by the vesting date (New Question 126.47). The Staff will not object if a reporting company under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended, registers on Form S-8 the offer and sale of common stock issued upon settlement of restricted stock or RSUs before the award vested, rather than before the award was granted, if the company was eligible to use Form S-8 on the date of grant.


    Eligibility of Former Employees of Acquired Companies Expanded

    • Form S-8 eligibility (Revised Question 126.14). A public acquirer may use Form S-8 to register the shares underlying compensatory awards, including stock options, restricted stock and RSUs, that it assumes in an acquisition and that are held by former employees of the target company (meaning those who ceased providing services to the target company prior to the closing of the transaction). Previously, the Staff took the view that Form S-8 was unavailable for such former employees because General Instruction A.1(a)(3) to Form S-8 indicates that former employees are only considered “employees” for purposes of Form S‑8 eligibility if the applicable award (specifically options in the instruction) was granted while the former employee was employed by (or providing services to) the issuer.[3]
    • Rule 701 eligibility (New Question 271.29). An acquiring company eligible to use Rule 701 may rely on Rule 701 to exempt the registration of awards assumed in an acquisition and held by persons whose service with the target company ended before the applicable acquisition closed.


    Additional Registration Fee Recycling

    • Recycling fees for forfeited awards (New Question 126.46). If an issuer paid fees to register on Form S-8 securities underlying awards with vesting conditions (such as RSUs) that are later forfeited and become available for reissuance under the applicable plan, the Staff will not object if the issuer applies those fees to future registrations on Form S-8.
    • Fees for 401(k) plan contributions (Revised Question 126.19). No fee is required for the registration of automatic company contributions to a 401(k) plan offering employer securities. The Staff also reiterated that no fee is required for the registration of an indeterminate amount of plan interests. A fee is required for employee contributions and employer matching contributions, but only to the extent those contributions are invested in employer securities.
    • Calculation of fees for defined contribution plans (New Question 240.19). Companies may rely on Rule 457(o) under the Securities Act, which bases the registration fee on the maximum aggregate offering price rather than the number of shares, to calculate the registration fees for offerings under a defined contribution plan, such as a 401(k) plan.


    Practical Considerations for Companies


    The CFIs reflect a pragmatic, issuer-friendly approach that should reduce the cost and administrative burden of registering securities granted as part of compensation programs.


    IPO Readiness

    • The Staff has now confirmed its acceptance of the registration on Form S‑8 of outstanding pre-IPO equity awards, including unvested restricted stock and unsettled RSUs. Note that the CFI does not allow the registration on Form S-8 of shares with respect to already-vested restricted stock, already-settled RSUs or already-exercised options, which will still require resale planning under Rule 144 or Rule 701(g).


    Less Urgency for Reporting Companies Granting Restricted Stock and RSUs

    • The CFIs put restricted stock and RSUs on similar footing to options by allowing reporting companies to register the underlying shares before the applicable award vests rather than requiring registration in advance of grant, easing timing pressure and costs, particularly for inducement or transaction-related awards that require off-cycle consents and a plan prospectus. Companies should nevertheless (i) confirm Form S-8 eligibility at grant, and (ii) ensure the Form S-8 is on file before vesting (which may precede settlement), taking into account provisions that could accelerate vesting, such as retirement eligibility, death or disability, or certain terminations or transactions. As with options, companies should register shares underlying awards promptly, even though registration now need not occur prior to grant.

    More M&A Optionality

    • Public company acquirers: The Staff’s guidance makes it easier to assume awards held by former target company employees, which public acquirers previously tended to cash out or register on Form S‑4, or, where available, Form S-3. Acquirers may now include these awards on Form S-8, broadening the acquisition structures available, preserving cash and simplifying compliance. The CFI is limited, however, to awards held by former employees that are assumed in the transaction, and careful attention is needed to ensure that the awards were originally granted under a valid registration statement or exemption from registration.
    • Private company acquirers: The Staff’s guidance also expands the alternatives available to private acquirers by enabling them to assume, under Rule 701, awards held by individuals whose employment or service with the target ended before the applicable acquisition closed rather than cashing them out or finding another registration exemption. Private acquirers should, however, monitor the volume limitations of Rule 701, against which the assumed awards count, and the enhanced disclosure required if offers under Rule 701 in a 12-month period exceed $10 million.

    Fewer Filing Fees

    • Consistent with the Staff’s practical approach, the CFIs reduce registration costs and ease compliance burdens by allowing companies to apply fees previously paid for forfeited RSUs and restricted stock that can be recycled under the applicable plans to future registration statements on Form S-8.
    • Companies now have assurance that they need not pay fees on automatic company contributions under 401(k) plans. Fees are still owed, however, on the employee contributions and employer matching contributions invested in employer stock. The Staff also reiterated that companies need not pay fees for plan interests registered for a 401(k) plan. Calculating fees based on the maximum aggregate offering price under Rule 457(o) may also simplify compliance, because employer stock funds generally lack a finite share pool and share usage can be difficult to track.


    [1] SEC Staff, Corporation Finance Interpretations Update: October 15, 2026, available here.
    [2] As a general matter, the offering of compensatory equity awards must be registered under the Securities Act on a registration statement filed with the SEC, such as Form S-8, or issued in reliance upon an exemption from registration, such as Rule 701 under the Securities Act (“Rule 701”). In the absence of registration, the resale of securities received pursuant to equity awards is subject to restrictions under the federal securities laws.
     
    [3] SEC Staff, Securities Act Forms Question 126.14 (Feb. 27, 2009) (superseded), available here.

  • Simpson Thacher Sustainability and ESG: Regulatory Update – November 2026

    Practice News:

    • An Alert discussing the Ninth Circuit’s ruling on California’s climate laws was published on November 9.

    Americas

    Ninth Circuit Enjoins California SB 253 Scope 3 Reporting and SB 261


    On November 9, the Ninth Circuit granted a preliminary injunction as to SB 253’s Scope 3 requirement and the entirety of SB 261, which requires climate-based financial risk disclosure. The court denied the injunction as to Scope 1 and 2 reporting under SB 253, which were due to the California Air Resources Board (CARB) on November 10. The court concluded that Scope 1 and 2 disclosures are commercial speech that survive intermediate scrutiny. By contrast, the court held that Scope 3 and SB 261 disclosures compel noncommercial speech and fail strict scrutiny. For more information, see our recent memo on the Ninth Circuit’s decision here and on SB 253 reporting guidance here.


    DOJ and EEOC Announce $29.5 Million Settlement With Defense Contractor Over DEI-Related Discrimination Allegations


    On November 3, the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) announced a two-part settlement with a major federal defense contractor totaling approximately $29.5 million, resolving allegations that the company discriminated based on race and sex in employment decisions. While not admitting any wrongdoing, the company agreed to pay $22 million, including $10 million in restitution, to settle claims under the False Claims Act alleging that the company certified compliance with anti-discrimination requirements in its federal contracts while knowingly maintaining discriminatory practices. The company will also pay $4.4 million to a former company executive under the settlement, and approximately $7.5 million will go to more than 1,000 company employees who were allegedly impacted by the practices. The DOJ called this the largest class of workers to publicly recover under an EEOC settlement relating to a DEI program.


    Oklahoma Court Grants Preliminary Injunction in Favor of Glass Lewis and ISS


    On October 31, a federal judge in the Western District of Oklahoma entered a preliminary injunction in favor of proxy advisors Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS) and Glass Lewis in their suit challenging Oklahoma House Bill 4429 (HB 4429), the Proxy Advisor Transparency Act, for alleged First Amendment violations. The order blocks the Oklahoma Attorney General from enforcing the law’s disclosure, publication and production requirements against the two firms before the law was to take effect on November 1. The law would require proxy advisors recommending votes against management to provide additional disclosures, including whether recommendations are based on written financial analysis evaluating the short-term and long-term financial benefits and costs of its recommendation. The ruling follows similar preliminary injunctions against proxy advisor laws in Kansas, Indiana and Texas. On October 29, a group of investors sued Kentucky Attorney General Russell Coleman challenging Senate Bill 183, which imposes disclosure, notification and economic analysis requirements on organizations that provide research, analysis and guidance on shareholder voting. The plaintiffs allege that the law violates the First and Fourteenth Amendments because it discriminates by viewpoint and content, it compels organizations to make statements they do not believe, and it is unconstitutionally vague.


    Florida Attorney General Sues First Street Over Home Risk Scores


    On October 23, Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier sued First Street Technology (First Street), a climate risk modeling company, alleging violations of the Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act (FDUTPA). The lawsuit focuses on First Street’s “Risk Factor” product, which scores individual properties from 1 to 10 for flood, fire, wind, heat and air quality risk, and appears on major real estate listing platforms. The complaint alleges that First Street relies on faulty models to issue exaggerated and inaccurate Risk Factors that cause Florida homes to take longer to sell and/or negatively impact the price. The Attorney General seeks an injunction preventing First Street from making certain representations about the accuracy of its Risk Factor score. The complaint also seeks consumer redress, disgorgement and civil penalties of up to $15,000 per violation.


    EPA Further Extends Reporting Deadline Under the GHG Reporting Program


    On October 14, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) issued an interim final rule extending the deadline for reporting year 2025 data under the Greenhouse Gas Reporting Program (GHGRP) from October 30, 2026, to March 10, 2027. The GHGRP applies to ~8,200 high-emitting facilities and requires that they report their emissions data to the EPA each year. The interim rule, which took effect when it was published, seeks to give the EPA more time to consider over 50,000 comments on its September 2025 proposal to eliminate most GHGRP reporting obligations. The EPA characterized the rule as an action called for by Executive Order 14192: Unleashing Prosperity Through Deregulation, citing the burden reduction from the extended deadline. Comments on the interim final rule are due November 30.

    EU/U.K.

    European Commission Publishes 2027 Work Programme


    On November 4, the European Commission adopted its 2027 Work Programme, entitled “European Union – standing up for one another,” which it describes as a strategic, targeted and streamlined program focused on competitiveness, energy prices, and implementing and enforcing existing legislation. The SFDR 2.0 proposal and the EU Emissions Trading System review are listed among the priority pending proposals, along with the Omnibus VIII environmental simplification measures. Significantly, Annex III of the Work Programme confirms that the Commission intends to withdraw the proposed Green Claims Directive (a legislative initiative designed to regulate voluntary environmental marketing) within six months.


    U.K. Government Announces Mandatory Human Rights Due Diligence Regime


    On November 4, the U.K. government announced plans to introduce mandatory human rights due diligence requirements for large U.K. and non-U.K. businesses, marking a significant shift from its current reliance on voluntary measures and reporting obligations. The proposed regime will apply to U.K. businesses with global turnover exceeding £350 million and non-U.K. businesses generating more than £350 million in U.K. turnover. Covered businesses will be required to identify, assess and address human rights and labor exploitation risks across their operations and supply chains, using a risk-based approach aligned with OECD Guidelines and UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights. The legislation will also introduce new enforcement powers targeting goods produced with forced labor. A regulator will be authorized to investigate suspected forced labor and order the withdrawal of affected goods from the Great Britain market where businesses have failed to meet their due diligence obligations. The announcement follows a government review that found the U.K.’s existing framework fragmented, overly dependent on voluntary action and increasingly out of step with other major economies. The new requirements will apply across the U.K. for services and in Great Britain for goods.


    FCA Publishes Final Rules for ESG Rating Providers (PS26/22)


    On November 3, the U.K. Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) published Policy Statement PS26/22, setting out final rules and perimeter guidance for the regulation of ESG rating providers. This follows its consultation in CP25/34 and the ESG Ratings Order made by HM Treasury, the U.K. government’s economic and finance ministry, in 2025. The main changes to the initial consultation version are to the transparency and stakeholder engagement requirements, which aim to improve clarity, proportionality and practical implementation. From June 29, 2028, firms providing ESG ratings in the U.K. will need FCA authorization. The authorization gateway opens on June 24, 2027, and firms with projected ESG ratings revenue of £500,000 or more must apply between June 24 and July 29, 2027; all other firms must apply between July 30 and August 31, 2027.


    Ireland Makes Gender Pay Gap Portal Reporting Mandatory


    On October 24, the Employment Equality and Institutional Burials (Amendment) Act 2026 was signed into law, legally requiring Irish employers with 50 or more employees to publish data about the gender pay gaps in their workforce annually to the Minister for Children, Disability and Equality via the Government’s Gender Pay Gap Portal (the “Portal”). This law builds upon an existing requirement on in-scope employers to publish their gender pay gap reports on their own website, or ensure their reports are accessible to the public in another format. The Portal was originally launched in November 2025 on a voluntary basis.


    Information provided by contributing law firm: Matheson


    Swedish FSA Issues Guidance on Financial Institutions’ Use of AI to Manage ESG Data


    On October 15, the Swedish Financial Supervisory Authority (the “SFSA”) published guidance for financial institutions on the use of artificial intelligence (AI) to manage ESG data. The guidance is the first output of the SFSA’s new Innovation Compass initiative, through which the authority engages in dialogue with financial institutions to provide greater clarity on innovation-related issues. The guidance emphasizes that using AI to collect, structure, analyze and use ESG data does not alter a financial institution’s responsibility to ensure that the data complies with applicable regulatory requirements. The SFSA also highlights that AI can make it more difficult to understand and verify how ESG data has been produced, as the underlying processing steps, methods and assumptions are not always apparent from the results. Financial institutions should therefore consider, at an early stage, how to ensure the traceability of the data’s origin and processing and assess the quality of the results.


    Information provided by contributing law firm: Gernandt & Danielsson


    Kosovo Adopts New Energy Performance Regulations for Buildings


    On October 15, Kosovo adopted two regulations under Law No. 08/L-242 on the Energy Performance of Buildings to strengthen energy efficiency requirements in the construction sector. Regulation (MMPH) No. 01/2026 sets minimum energy performance requirements for new buildings and for existing buildings undergoing major renovations. These include heat transmission limits for walls, roofs, floors and windows, and efficiency standards for heating, cooling and ventilation systems. Regulation (MMPH) No. 02/2026 sets a standardized methodology for calculating energy performance, covering energy consumption, technical building systems and renewable energy sources. Both regulations are now in force and replace the corresponding 2018 frameworks, with updated compliance requirements for developers, construction professionals and renovation projects.


    Information provided by contributing law firm: Kinstellar

    APAC

    Vietnam’s Green Project Criteria and ESG Framework Take Effect


    On November 1, Decision No. 46/2026/QD-TT entered into force, establishing Vietnam’s first official criteria for identifying green and circular projects. It also sets a framework for applying ESG standards to private enterprises, household businesses and individual businesses, combining mandatory legal compliance with voluntary criteria that vary by business size. Commercial banks and state financial funds operating outside the state budget may now rely on these criteria to identify projects eligible for preferential credit and interest-rate support.


    Information provided by contributing law firm: Le & Tran


    Australia Proposes Electricity Rule Changes to Address Data Center Growth


    On October 28, the Federal Minister for Climate Change and Energy announced proposed amendments to the National Electricity Rules. The first is intended to ensure data centers can demonstrate that their electricity demand is backed by new, firm supply in the same region. The second would provide clearer, faster ways for data centers to connect to the grid when collocated with renewable generation or storage, or when they agree to operate flexibly. The proposed amendments form part of broader reforms responding to accelerating data center growth and its impact on energy demand. The Australian Energy Market Commission (AEMC) will publish a consultation paper when it initiates the rule change process.


    Information provided by contributing law firm: Mallesons


    ACCC Releases Guidance on Emissions Claims


    On October 20, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) released new guidance for businesses making greenhouse gas emissions claims to consumers. The guidance encourages businesses to consider, as a “golden rule,” the overall impression conveyed to consumers to ensure clarity and accuracy. It reinforces that false or misleading environmental claims may breach the Australian Consumer Law. Businesses are encouraged to base claims on complete, reputable and clear emissions accounting, and to avoid broad, selective or non-specific claims. Transparency about the use of carbon credits or other certificates, avoiding double counting emissions benefits, and supporting future reductions or targets with reasonable grounds are also encouraged. Examples highlight the types of claims the ACCC may scrutinize, including those that are “broad and vague.” Businesses are prompted to refine messaging, obtain stronger supporting evidence or reconsider claims that raise concerns.


    Information provided by contributing law firm: Mallesons


    South Korea Proposes Amendments to Capital Markets Act


    On October 27, lawmakers introduced a bill to establish mandatory sustainability disclosure requirements and enhance transparency in investment decision-making. The bill would require companies subject to annual business-report filing obligations to disclose sustainability information affecting corporate value, based on standards established by the Financial Services Commission (FSC) with consideration of international standards and domestic circumstances. It would also mandate third-party assurance by FSC-registered providers, subject to registration, quality-control and supervisory requirements. The requirements would apply progressively to companies with total assets of KRW10 trillion or more from FY2028, KRW5 trillion or more from FY2030, and below KRW5 trillion from FY2032. To facilitate implementation, the bill proposes exemptions from civil liability for the first three reporting years and administrative surcharges for the first five, except in cases of intentional misconduct.


    Information provided by contributing law firm: Yoon & Yang LLC


    Thailand Launches Mandatory ISSB-Aligned Sustainability Reporting for Listed Companies


    On October 26, Thailand’s Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) issued rules to align sustainability disclosures with ISSB standards (IFRS S1 and IFRS S2), with reporting obligations phased in from the 2027 financial year. The requirements will initially apply to the largest companies listed on the Stock Exchange of Thailand, with phase-in for smaller listed companies. Transitional relief includes temporary exemptions from comparative information and Scope 3 GHG emissions disclosures, alongside flexibility in reporting timelines and emissions calculation standards. GHG emissions disclosures must also be verified by assurance providers using internationally accepted standards. These developments aim to enhance transparency, comparability and investor confidence in Thailand’s capital markets.


    Information provided by contributing law firm: Chandler Mori Hamada

    Standards and Associations

    ISSB Publishes Nature-related Disclosure Proposal


    On October 22, the International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB) published an exposure draft of the IFRS Nature-related Disclosures. The proposals would require companies to disclose material information about nature-related risks and opportunities, including how their dependencies and impacts on nature give rise to those risks and opportunities. Companies applying IFRS S1 already have to disclose material nature-related information; however, the proposal seeks to provide more detail on how companies can provide this information and improve the quality and comparability of nature-related financial information globally. In developing the proposal, ISSB has drawn heavily on the Taskforce on Nature-related Financial Disclosures (TNFD) framework and follows IFRS S1’s four core content areas: governance, strategy, risk management, and metrics and targets. Comments are due February 19, 2027.


    Contributing Law Firm Information

    Matheson | Gernandt & Danielsson | Kinstellar | Le & Tran | Chandler Mori Hamada | Mallesons | Yoon & Yang LLC

  • The EU Securitisation Deal: What Was Fixed, What’s Been Deferred

    A Political Agreement, Not Yet a Finished Rulebook

    On 21 October 2026, the European Parliament and the Council reached a provisional political agreement on the most substantial reform to date of the EU securitisation framework enacted in 2019. The agreement covers both the EU Securitisation Regulation[1] and the prudential treatment of securitisation exposures under the Capital Requirements Regulation[2]. The agreement’s objectives are familiar: to reduce unnecessary operational burdens, make capital requirements more sensitive to actual risk and encourage a broader range of investors to participate in the European market.

    The package will introduce a new category of “resilient” securitisations, recalibrate the capital treatment of lower-risk positions, simplify aspects of due diligence and reporting, increase the relevant UCITS investment limit and permit qualifying insurers and reinsurers to provide unfunded protection within the synthetic STS framework. It also makes targeted changes to the STS criteria and places third-party STS verifiers under supervision by the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA)[3].

    The precise route by which several of these outcomes will be achieved is not yet clear. The legal texts have not been published and must still undergo technical finalisation before formal approval by the Parliament and Council. The Commission has indicated that, once adopted, the amendments will be published in the Official Journal and enter into force immediately[4]. Entry into force will not, however, mean that every detail is settled: commentators expect some elements, including CLO-related technical standards, not to be finalised until at least six months later. Until the final drafting is available, market participants are working from the institutions’ high-level announcements, the Commission’s original proposals, the respective negotiating mandates of the Parliament and Council, and post-trilogue accounts from industry bodies and practitioners.

    Political agreement on an objective does not itself provide clarity on every operational detail. For example, the intention to accommodate third-country securitisations does not tell investors how “substantially equivalent” disclosure will be assessed. Agreement that sanctions should be proportionate does not reveal which Article 5 failures will be sanctionable, how negligence will be treated or how duplication with sectoral enforcement will be avoided. Similarly, an EBA review of the sole purpose test is materially different from an amendment of the same that would resolve the treatment of specialist lending platforms.

    The appropriate response to the current developments is therefore neither to disregard the agreement nor to treat reported outcomes as settled law. Transactions must continue to comply with the existing framework. Documents for deals expected to remain outstanding after the reforms take effect should, however, preserve sufficient flexibility to accommodate revised reporting templates, due-diligence standards and regulatory classifications without requiring unnecessary consent procedures or wholesale amendments.

    The political agreement reached shows that the EU intends to make securitisations easier to issue, invest in and use for capital management. Its technical implementation will determine whether the reforms achieve that objective in practice or merely replace familiar obstacles with new interpretative questions.

    The Core Policy Question: Simplification or Genuine Market Revival

    The political ambition behind the reforms is to reverse the stagnation of a market that the EU increasingly regards as essential to financing its strategic priorities. Securitisation is expected to help banks release balance-sheet capacity, diversify funding and transfer risk to non-bank investors, thereby supporting additional lending to households, businesses and infrastructure projects.

    The reforms address two distinct barriers to that ambition: operational friction and, more importantly, prudential economics.

    In respect of the former, the existing framework requires institutional investors to verify matters that are already direct regulatory obligations of EU originators, sponsors and original lenders. It imposes detailed disclosure requirements that can be disproportionate for private transactions and can make third-country securitisations particularly difficult for EU investors to access. These requirements create fixed costs that weigh most heavily on smaller investors, new issuers and transactions that do not benefit from an established programme. Reducing that friction could have real value. More proportionate due diligence, streamlined treatment for repeat transactions, simplified reporting templates and a workable approach to third-country disclosure could lower the cost of participation and make securitisation accessible to a broader range of investors. Increasing the UCITS investment limit may also remove a formal impediment to investment. But administrative simplification alone will not revive the market. An investor does not allocate capital to a securitisation merely because the compliance checklist has shortened. The investment must still offer an attractive return after capital charges, liquidity treatment, governance costs, valuation requirements and internal approval processes. Similarly, an originator will securitise only where the resulting funding or capital benefit justifies the execution cost, structural constraints and continuing obligations associated with the transaction.

    In respect of the latter, the introduction of the “resilient” category and the reported reduction in risk-weight floors should improve the treatment of the safest STS positions. This change could support senior investor demand and improve the economics of certain traditional and synthetic transactions. The reforms also recognise that insurers and reinsurers may represent an additional source of unfunded protection in synthetic SRT.

    However, the reported calibration is uneven. The most favourable treatment is concentrated in resilient STS and other lower-risk positions. The Association for Financial Markets in Europe (AFME) has warned that the treatment of non-STS securitisations, particularly under the Standardised Approach, remains overly conservative, noting that the agreement appears not to provide risk-weight floor caps for non-STS transactions and that the p-factor calibrations most relevant to those transactions remain largely unchanged. This matters because many transactions financing corporate loans, specialist credit, infrastructure and other real-economy assets will not qualify for the most favourable categories[5]. Some prudential questions have also been deferred rather than resolved: the calibration of the credit conversion factor (CCF) and the interaction with the output floor are expected to be addressed in the Commission’s forthcoming Banking Competitiveness Package, which AFME expects in the first quarter of 2027.

    There is also a risk of circularity. If the new benefits are available principally to transactions that already attract strong demand, the reforms may reduce the cost of established products without materially expanding the perimeter of the market. A genuine revival would require capital and operational improvements to support new issuers, new asset classes and a deeper mezzanine investor base, not merely cheaper holdings of already liquid senior STS paper.

    The success of the reforms should therefore be assessed against practical outcomes rather than legislative activity. Do more investors enter the market? Do repeat and first-time issuers face lower execution costs? Can non-bank lenders use securitisation more readily? Does insurer capital expand synthetic risk-transfer capacity? And do the reforms improve the economics of transactions outside the safest STS segment?

    The political agreement reached is a meaningful step towards a more usable framework. Whether it produces a larger and more diverse market will depend on whether the final text changes transaction economics—not simply the amount of regulation surrounding them.

    Article 5 Due Diligence: Less Duplication but Responsibility Remains

    The reported reforms should remove some of Article 5’s least defensible duplication. Where EU originators, sponsors and original lenders are themselves directly subject to the Securitisation Regulation, investors should no longer have to re-perform prescribed checks merely to verify that those parties have complied with their own obligations.

    This change represents a simplification, but the regulatory burden remains. Investors will still need to understand the securitisation positions and their underlying exposures, undertake a pre-investment risk assessment and monitor the investment on an ongoing basis. Due diligence may become more proportionate to the risk and seniority of the position, with streamlined treatment for repeat transactions. Secondary-market investors may also receive 15 calendar days after an acquisition to complete the written record of their assessment (the assessment itself must still precede the investment).

    One unresolved point is delegation. The final text must identify who bears regulatory responsibility where an asset manager, adviser or other delegate performs such tasks. Delegation can reduce duplication within investment groups; it should not create uncertainty over which entity is liable when the process fails.

    Investor Sanctions: Proportionality Prevails, but the Devil Will Be in the Detail

    The proposed sanctions regime became one of the most contested parts of the negotiations. AFME and the European Fund and Asset Management Association (EFAMA) argued that imposing a separate securitisation-specific regime on institutional investors would duplicate existing sectoral sanctions and deter precisely the investors the reforms are intended to attract[6].

    The reported compromise does not remove sanctions for Article 5 failures. Instead of the rigid, prescriptive regime originally proposed, it requires national competent authorities to put in place appropriate enforcement arrangements, promotes greater convergence and cooperation across Member States, and takes account of existing national and sectoral sanctions regimes (such as those applying under AIFMD, the UCITS Directive and Solvency II) with a view to avoiding duplication and preserving proportionality. It is therefore a recalibration rather than a complete turnaround.

    The practical consequences of this agreement will turn on the drafting. Are sanctions limited to material or negligent failures? How will authorities avoid double punishment? Does an investor breach Article 5 whenever an originator representation proves inaccurate, or only where the investor’s own processes were deficient?

    Until those questions are answered, Article 5 compliance will remain a heavily negotiated closing condition. Investors are likely to seek clear undertakings, access to supporting information and express remediation rights rather than relying solely on representations that compliance has occurred.

    Third-Country Securitisations: A Move Away from Strict EU-Template Equivalence

    The existing regime makes EU investment in U.S., UK and other third-country transactions unnecessarily difficult. The problem is typically not an absence of information, but the expectation that information should be delivered in the precise form prescribed by EU templates.

    The political compromise reportedly permits greater flexibility where substantially equivalent information is available in another format. If the drafting is workable, this change could remove a major practical barrier to EU participation in global securitisations.

    “Substantially equivalent” will require definition. It could mean equivalence of substantive information, equivalence assessed field by field, or merely sufficient information to discharge Article 5. The answer will determine whether investors can rely on standard U.S. or UK reporting, require a contractual gap analysis or continue commissioning shadow EU templates.

    This is an area in which a seemingly small difference in drafting could have a meaningful effect on investor access.

    Public and Private Securitisations

    The agreement reportedly preserves the prospectus-based distinction between public and private securitisations. Public reporting templates should be streamlined, with a targeted reduction of at least 35% in mandatory fields and greater use of aggregated reporting for highly granular pools.

    Private securitisations should receive a new, simplified template focused on information relevant to supervisory oversight. However, such private securitisations are also expected to become subject to reporting through securitisation repositories. This is a material change from the current position, under which private transactions remain subject to the applicable Article 7 disclosure obligations but are generally exempt from reporting through a securitisation repository.

    A shorter template does not automatically mean a lighter regime. Repository submission brings validation, data-formatting and operational requirements of its own. The reform will succeed only if the private template is genuinely tailored to the regulator’s supervisory needs rather than becoming a compressed version of public reporting.

    No new definition of public securitisation has been introduced, but CLOs are expected to be subject to ad hoc reporting requirements and a CLO definition and template are likely to be set out in the technical standards. Some commentators, thus, suggest that the impact on CLOs may remain unclear for up to six months after the agreement is enacted in the Official Journal. The revised templates are expected to be developed by the Joint Committee of the European Supervisory Authorities under EBA leadership. As such, the technical standards will likely be as important as the legislative principle.

    The Sole Purpose Test: A Review, Not Yet a Solution

    The sole purpose test has become a serious impediment to the use of specialist lending platforms as risk retainers. The current framework prevents an entity from qualifying as an originator where it was established or operates for the sole purpose of securitising exposures. The risk retention regulatory technical standards (Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2023/2175, the EU Risk Retention RTS) then apply qualitative factors, including whether the entity has a broader business model and whether the securitised assets and retained interests are its sole or predominant source of revenue[7].

    Parliament proposed a more direct means of assessing sole purpose. Specialist SME, consumer and mortgage lenders could be treated as satisfying the test where the securitisation finances a genuine lending business. The reported final compromise is less decisive: the existing sole purpose test is retained, and the agreement provides for an EBA-led review of the test and its application to specialist SME, consumer and non-bank mortgage lenders. Some commentators report that the EBA may also be tasked with developing technical standards setting criteria for when such lenders satisfy the test.

    This development is still significant. It acknowledges that a rule intended to prevent artificial retention vehicles may in fact be catching substantive origination businesses. However, the current agreement does not alter the existing sole purpose test, disapply the EU Risk Retention RTS or validate any particular platform.

    The key question for the EBA should now be whether the sole purpose analysis has become too dependent on a mechanical revenue threshold. Capital support, origination capability, employees, decision-making, exposure to business risk and a continuing economic interest may provide better evidence of a genuine lending business than the proportion of a particular year’s accounting revenue.

    For transactions closing in the near future, the existing rules continue to bite. An announced review is not a safe harbour.

    STS and Resilient Securitisations: Where the Prudential Benefits Sit

    The reforms introduce “resilient” securitisations as a new prudential category layered upon the existing STS framework. Reported terms include an ultimate risk-weight floor of 5% for resilient STS positions (rather than the 6% previously proposed) and 7% for non-resilient STS positions (rather than 8%), a reduction of the non-resilient STS scalar under SEC-IRBA to 8%, preservation of the existing hierarchy of carve-outs with a 5% floor, and a return to a formula-based approach under SEC-ERBA[8].

    These changes should improve the economics of the safest transactions, particularly for senior bank investors. It may also strengthen demand for structures designed from inception to satisfy both STS and resilient criteria.

    The limitation of such changes is their scope. Non-STS securitisations appear to receive much less benefit, particularly under the Standardised Approach. That matters for corporate, specialist-credit, infrastructure and more bespoke private transactions that may be economically sound but do not satisfy the relevant formal criteria.

    The reforms therefore risk creating a divide: increasingly efficient capital treatment for the safest standardised products, with limited change for the transactions where additional capital may be most valuable.

    The STS supervisory architecture is also changing. The Commission’s proposed “lead supervisor” model for cross-border transactions will reportedly not be taken forward. Instead, ESMA will take direct responsibility for authorising, and withdrawing the authorisation of, third-party verifiers, while the EBA-led Joint Committee will conduct risk-based annual sample reviews of transactions to assess STS compliance.

    Insurers and Synthetic SRT: New Capacity, New Conditions

    One of the most important changes is the proposed admission of qualifying insurers and reinsurers as providers of unfunded protection in synthetic STS transactions. The Council presents this as a means of widening participation in the synthetic markets[9].

    This change could unlock a substantial additional pool of SRT capacity. Insurers may prefer unfunded guarantees to funded credit-linked notes because the structure does not require them to supply cash at inception. Banks gain access to highly rated protection providers without depending exclusively on specialist SRT funds.

    But insurer eligibility is not unconditional. Reported safeguards concern a protection provider’s regulatory status, financial strength and creditworthiness. The final framework will need to address downgrade triggers, termination rights, claims-payment mechanics, maturity mismatch and concentration.

    There is also a wider supervisory question. A straightforward guarantee from a well-capitalised insurer is different from a structure in which insurer risk capacity is combined with bank financing, a repack vehicle or collateralised notes. Regulators will need to look through the legal protection seller to the entire economic chain.

    UCITS: Raising the Limit Is Helpful, Will It Create Demand?

    The agreement reportedly increases the limit in Article 56(2)(b) of the UCITS Directive, which generally prevents a UCITS from acquiring more than 10% of the debt securities of a single issuing body, to 25% for debt securities issued in securitisations, subject to a review clause. This is below the 50% supported in the Council’s negotiating position, although AFME regards it as sufficiently ambitious. Such change removes a formal constraint and may make larger positions viable for funds that previously found the applicable limit uneconomic.

    It does not follow from this change, however, that UCITS will use the full capacity. Portfolio liquidity, valuation, credit expertise, internal governance and investor expectations remain important constraints. The ability to acquire 25% of an issuance is not the same as an investment mandate or risk appetite to do so.

    The agreed change is nevertheless directionally important. It recognises that securitisation should not automatically be treated as an unusually concentrated asset class merely because the securities are issued by a single SSPE.

    What the Agreement Means for Deals Already in the Pipeline

    The political agreement does not displace current law. Transactions closing before the reforms take effect must continue to satisfy the existing framework.

    Documentation should nevertheless anticipate change where a transaction will remain outstanding after implementation. Relevant points include:

    • flexibility to adopt revised public or private reporting templates;
    • cooperation obligations for repository reporting;
    • regulatory-change provisions that do not require unanimous investor consent;
    • third-country information covenants framed around substantive sufficiency rather than a permanently fixed template;
    • Article 5 representations that distinguish sell-side compliance from the investor’s independent duties;
    • optionality between funded CLNs and qualifying insurer guarantees in synthetic SRT;
    • downgrade, replacement and collateral mechanics for protection providers; and
    • preservation of current retention analysis pending the EBA sole purpose review.

    Parties should also examine any transition mechanisms included in the final enactment of the agreement carefully. The reported agreement does not include general grandfathering[10]. The final provisions will need to be checked transaction-by-transaction. Transaction parties should not assume that legacy deals are either fully protected or automatically brought into the new regime.

    The Real Work Now Moves to Level 2

    The political agreement between the Parliament and Council sets the direction for the proposed reforms to the EU securitisation rules. Much of its commercial effect will be determined below the level of the primary legislation.

    The key workstreams are likely to include:

    • the EBA review of the sole purpose test;
    • revised public and private reporting templates;
    • the meaning of substantially equivalent third-country information;
    • detailed resilient-securitisation criteria;
    • the eligibility conditions for insurer and reinsurer protection;
    • supervisory standards for synthetic SRT;
    • STS supervisory convergence;
    • the definition of CLOs and any CLO-specific reporting requirements; and
    • the allocation of responsibility where due diligence is delegated.

    Poorly calibrated technical standards could reintroduce through Level 2 requirements much of the complexity removed from Level 1. Conversely, carefully targeted standards could deliver meaningful simplification without weakening the core safeguards of risk retention, transparency and investor understanding.

    Conclusion: A Better Framework, Not Yet a Bigger Market

    The agreement tackles duplicative due diligence, third-country access, private reporting, UCITS capacity, prudential calibration and insurer participation in synthetic SRT.

    But the benefits appear concentrated in the areas of STS and resilient positions. Problems with the current sole purpose test have been referred for further review rather than resolved. The treatment of non-STS securitisations remains comparatively conservative, and the credit conversion factor and output-floor questions have been deferred to the Banking Competitiveness Package. Many of the operational consequences of these reforms will depend on technical standards that do not yet exist.

    The reform should therefore be judged by what happens next: whether new investors enter the market, new originators gain access, insurer capital expands SRT capacity and execution costs fall across a broader range of transactions.


     

    [1] Regulation – 2017/2402 – EN – securitisation regulation – EUR-Lex

    [2] Regulation – 575/2013 – EN – Capital Requirements Regulation – EUR-Lex

    [3] Council, European Union – Consilium

    [4] Finance – Finance – European Commission

    [5] EU securitisation agreement delivers progress, but prudential shortcomings remain

    [6] https://www.afme.eu/media/rtofzmei/joint-association-letter-secr.pdf

    [7] https://www.esma.europa.eu/sites/default/files/2025-03/JC_2025_14_Joint_Committee_report_on_the_functionning_of_the_securitisation_regulation.pdf

    [8] EU securitisation review: provisional agreement improves the framework, but implementation will be key | ABBL

    [9] Savings and investments union: Council and Parliament strike deal to revitalise the EU’s securitisation market – Consilium

    [10] EU securitisation review: provisional agreement improves the framework, but implementation will be key | ABBL

  • Third Circuit: Weighing “Novel Argument” That Violating 401(k) Plan Policy Statements Is a Breach of Fiduciary Duty, Concludes Statements Not Violated

    On June 22, 2026, the Third Circuit affirmed a district court’s grant of summary judgment in favor of a company and its 401(k) plan administrators that were alleged to have violated their fiduciary duty under ERISA by failing to remove two underperforming funds from the plan’s investment options. In re Quest Diags. ERISA Litig., 179 F.4th 217 (3d Cir. 2026) (Bibas, J.). As to plaintiffs’ “novel argument” that violating a policy statement breaches a fiduciary duty under ERISA, the Third Circuit stated that it has never held this. The Third Circuit concluded that even if the policy statements were covered by § 1104(a)(1)(D) of ERISA, they were “full of permissive language” so the committee had the discretion to deviate from them and, therefore, the statements were never violated.

    Background and Procedural History

    Plaintiffs alleged that the plan and its managers breached their fiduciary duty by imprudently continuing to offer an actively managed mutual fund and actively managed target-date funds as investment options because the mutual fund underperformed comparable funds and the target-date funds performed worse than passively managed alternatives. Plaintiffs alleged that continuing to offer the funds, violated the company’s fiduciary duty under 29 U.S.C. § 1104(a), and also violated the fiduciaries’ duty to monitor the plan adequately under §§ 1105(a) and 1109(a). The district court denied the company’s motion to dismiss but, after discovery, granted it summary judgment finding no breach of fiduciary duty.

    The Company’s Process Was Prudent

    Noting that under Renfro v. Unisys Corp., 671 F.3d 314 (3d Cir. 2011), “if the fiduciary’s process was prudent, that ends the inquiry and plaintiffs lose,” the Third Circuit held that plaintiffs’ breach-of-duty claim failed at this step because the company’s process was prudent, noting that “ERISA is mostly concerned with process, not outcomes.” Referring to In re Unisys Savings Plan Litigation, 74 F.3d 420 (3d Cir. 1996) to rate the company’s performance in this case, the Third Circuit concluded that the company reviewed its financial advisor’s data and sought more where needed, understood its financial advisor’s methodology and the bases underlying its opinions, and that the company otherwise followed generally accepted practices of plan management. The Third Circuit further noted that the investment committee regularly met with its investment advisor, met with fund sponsors, had its advisor review specific investments, including the challenged funds, repeatedly revised the plan’s menu, and during the years at issue replaced certain funds and put funds on a watch list, including one of the challenged funds.

    Policy Statements “Full of Permissive Language” Were Never Violated

    As to plaintiffs’ argument that a plan’s investment policy statements are binding under § 1104(a)(1)(D)[1], the Third Circuit labeled this a novel argument in this circuit and stated that it has never held that violating a policy statement breaches a fiduciary duty. The Third Circuit then stated that it need not decide the question because even assuming that the policy statements were covered by § 1104(a)(1)(D), the statements gave the committee discretion to deviate from them, so they were never violated. The court pointed out that the policy statements “were full of permissive language.” For example, they provided that the investment committee “may” place an investment on a watch list or remove it from the menu, and while they listed “common factors that may cause the Investment Committee to lose confidence in a fund,” they also noted that “no single factor” is dispositive.

    Acknowledging that there is no law directly on point, the Third Circuit stated that background principles of trust law favor deferring to trustees’ judgment such that the exercise of a trustee’s discretion is subject to the deferential abuse of discretion standard of review. Concluding that there was no abuse of discretion in this case, the Third Circuit pointed out that the investment committee considered the target-date funds’ increased stock allocation and through-retirement glide path, as well as the target-date funds’ underperformance and alternatives, investigating active versus passive index funds as well as funds with various glide paths. The committee also considered alternatives to the mutual fund “but had a good reason to keep it on the menu because of the protection it offered during bear markets.”


    [1] Under § 1104(a)(1)(D), ERISA fiduciaries must discharge their duties “in accordance with the documents and instruments governing the plan insofar as such documents and instruments are consistent with” ERISA.

  • Ninth Circuit Upholds SB 253 Scope 1 and 2 Reporting, Enjoins Scope 3 Reporting and SB 261

    On November 9, a divided panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit issued its decision in U.S. Chamber of Commerce v. Sanchez, the First Amendment challenge to California’s Climate Corporate Data Accountability Act (“SB 253”) and Climate-Related Financial Risk Act (“SB 261”). In effect, the court’s decision upholds Scope 1 and 2 reporting requirements under SB 253, while enjoining both (i) SB 253’s Scope 3 reporting requirements, which were scheduled to begin in 2027, and (ii) SB 261’s requirement for in-scope entities to publish climate-based financial risk reports.

    Background

    SB 253 requires annual disclosure of greenhouse gas (“GHG”) emissions (Scopes 1, 2 and 3) by U.S.-organized companies doing business in California with total annual revenues exceeding $1 billion (based on the lesser of the two prior fiscal years), in line with the Greenhouse Gas Protocol standards and related guidance. Non-compliance can result in fines of up to $500,000 a year. SB 261 requires biennial disclosure of climate-related financial risks by U.S.-organized companies doing business in California with total annual revenues exceeding $500 million (based on the lesser of the two prior fiscal years), in line with the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures framework and recommendations (or an equivalent reporting requirement). Non-compliance can result in fines of up to $50,000 a year.

    Both SB 253 and SB 261 have been subject to ongoing legal challenge, originally brought in 2024 in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California by various plaintiffs. The plaintiffs allege that the laws violate their First Amendment rights by infringing on their right to remain silent and compelling them to speak on the controversial issue of climate change. On August 13, a California federal judge had denied the plaintiffs’ motion for preliminary injunction of both laws, but on November 18, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit granted the motion as to enforcement of SB 261 against the plaintiffs, resulting in a pause of reporting under that law. At the time, the motion was denied as to reporting under SB 253. On January 9, 2026, the Ninth Circuit heard oral arguments to determine whether to uphold the district court’s August 13th ruling denying plaintiffs’ motion for preliminary injunction of SB 253 and SB 261. The arguments focused chiefly on whether the compelled disclosures required under the statutes can be considered commercial speech.

    The Ninth Circuit’s Decision

    • Scope 1 and Scope 2 Disclosures under SB 253: The majority concluded that the requirement to disclose Scope 1 and 2 emissions qualifies as commercial speech: it concerns factual information, calculated using standard methodologies, about emissions from a company’s own operations, which information may be pertinent to actual or potential commercial transactions. The court reasoned that the requirements are likely to survive intermediate scrutiny because the State’s interests in mitigating information asymmetries for investors and reducing emissions are substantial, that the requirements directly advance those interests, and that they are no more extensive than necessary. The court relied on, among other things, record evidence that investors rely on Scope 1 and 2 data, that the underlying data resides in company records, and that mandatory Scope 1 and 2 reporting has been associated with emissions reductions of approximately 7 to 8%. Therefore, the court affirmed the lower court’s denial of a preliminary injunction as to this portion of the law.
    • SB 253 Scope 3 Disclosure: Because Scope 3 emissions arise from “diffuse third-party conduct in the value chain,” unlike Scope 1 and 2 emissions, the court found that these disclosures are insufficiently tethered to the reporting entity’s own operations to qualify as commercial speech, which is generally subject to intermediate scrutiny. Instead, applying strict scrutiny, a challenged restriction must further a compelling interest and be narrowly tailored to achieve that interest. The court held that the state failed to demonstrate a compelling interest in Scope 3 reporting, and that even if such an interest had been shown, that the requirement was not narrowly tailored. The court pointed to the facts that (i) companies do not possess Scope 3 data in the way they possess Scope 1 and 2 data, (ii) permitted estimates based on industry averages or proxy data are no more reliable than estimates the State could generate itself, (iii) the link to investment decisions is too attenuated, and (iv) no study in the record examined or linked mandatory Scope 3 reporting to mandatory disclosure. Given that SB 253’s Scope 3 disclosure provisions are therefore likely unconstitutional, the court remanded for the district court to determine in the first instance whether Scope 3 provisions are severable from the other requirements of SB 253.
    • SB 261 Climate-Based Financial Risk Disclosure: The court held that SB 261, by incorporating the TCFD framework, requires companies to make predictive and normative judgments about climate-related risks and opportunities, governance, strategy and scenario impacts—effectively answering “[h]ow should climate change shape the company’s future operations and economic planning?” Relying on X Corp. v. Bonta and NetChoice v. Bonta, the court held that such value-laden judgments on a “politically fraught subject” fall outside the commercial speech doctrine. Even assuming compelling interests, the court states that SB 261 fails narrow tailoring because less restrictive alternatives were available, such as disseminating existing voluntary disclosures, incentivizing disclosure, or directly regulating emissions.
    • Partial concurrence and dissent. Judge Bennett concurred in the majority’s decision as to SB 261 and Scope 3 reporting, but emphasized that he would have enjoined both statutes in full, reasoning that both compel noncommercial speech subject to strict scrutiny, which California “all but concede[d]” it could not satisfy. In his view, all of SB 253’s and SB 261’s disclosures are noncommercial in nature because the information the law is aiming to disclose lacks a close tether to commercial transactions. Further, he believes that a compelled disclosure should generally qualify as commercial speech only where it informs market participants about a specific product or service. He warned that the majority’s approach, which he reads as equating investors’ interest in companies with consumers’ interest in products, could leave “no end” to the information states may compel.

    Key Takeaways

    • SB 253 Scope 1 and 2 reporting proceeds. In-scope entities should submit Scope 1 and 2 emissions under SB 253 by November 10, 2026.
    • SB 253 Scope 3 reporting is uncertain. Scope 3 reporting is scheduled to begin in 2027 and likely cannot be enforced as currently drafted; its fate, including whether the remainder of SB 253 survives absent Scope 3, turns on the district court’s severability determination. Companies should monitor the court’s decision and any CARB response.
    • SB 261 remains enjoined. Companies need not publish SB 261 reports while the injunction is in place. Litigation will proceed on the merits.

    We will continue to monitor developments and will provide further updates as the litigation and CARB rulemaking progress. For more information on SB 253 reporting guidance, see our prior Alert here.

  • SEC’s 2027 Examination Priorities: Notable Developments, Emerging Themes, and Recent Examination Insights

    The SEC’s Division of Examinations (the “Division”) recently released its 2027 Examination Priorities, outlining the Division’s stated focus areas for its new fiscal year. Like last year’s priorities, the 2027 priorities cover many long-standing, core examination topics. Additionally, the release reflects several notable shifts from the 2026 priorities, including expanded attention to private credit (and associated touchpoints), the return of private fund-specific focus areas, a move from readiness to implementation steps for complying with the still-recent amendments to Regulation S-P (“Reg S-P”), a sharper focus on artificial intelligence (“AI,” which the release refers to as “super intelligence” or “SI”) and AI-related cyber risks, continued attention to economic conflicts of interest, and a new focus on advisers’ reliance on proxy advisory firms.

    Below we highlight certain notable differences between the 2027 and 2026 priorities, and we assess the Division’s recent release alongside what we have continued to see in examinations and expect in future examinations in the near term.

    1. Private credit remains a focus area, with added attention to valuation and exemptive relief.

    Private credit is mentioned throughout this year’s priorities, highlighting its importance to the SEC Staff and indicating that it will remain a focus in 2027. For registered investment companies and business development companies (“BDCs” and, together with registered investment companies, “Regulated Funds”), the Division noted that it will continue to monitor funds holding less liquid or illiquid investments, including private credit, flagging the associated risks of valuation, redemptions and liquidity, and disclosure of conflicts and risks. The Division will also focus on leveraged vehicles, including BDCs, and on funds that operate under exemptive orders, including how they implement and comply with those orders.

    The Staff will also continue to focus on advisers that recommend products that are difficult to trade, have unusual features, or are illiquid, including loans provided by private funds or BDCs and investments in private companies through special purpose vehicles (which could signal a focus on adviser-sponsored pooled capital arrangements through which retail investors invest in private companies). The Division noted that adviser examinations will assess the reasonableness of valuation processes and methodologies, and broker-dealer examinations will separately review the pricing and valuation of illiquid instruments such as private credit and private equity.[1]

    Application to examinations.

    The release’s focus on private credit is consistent with the Division’s activity in 2026, which included a continued focus on Regulated Funds that invest in private credit and other illiquid assets. Numerous interval funds, BDCs, and their advisers have received similar examination letters from the Staff, requesting detailed information regarding valuation, including service provider details, policies and procedures, process by security type, and records supporting fair valuation determinations and valuation testing. These examinations have also focused on liquidity, investment allocation, and co-investment transactions, testing whether funds and their advisers were following the conditions of their existing co-investment exemptive relief orders. The discussion of private credit throughout the 2027 priorities indicates that we should expect to see similar examinations next year.[2]

    1. Private fund specifics are back.

    While last year’s priorities did not explicitly include a set of private fund-specific focus areas (which may have just reflected the incorporation of private funds as a routine component of the Division’s examination program), this year’s release highlights certain private fund-specific priorities for 2027. Specifically, the Division will test whether investment-related risk disclosures are consistent with fiduciary standards, in addition to whether compliance policies, procedures, and controls are designed to address both fund-level and investment-level risks. Notably, the priorities call out investment allocations, use of debt and fund-level lines of credit, use of affiliated service providers, and the accuracy of fee and expense calculations at both the fund and investment levels as topics where the Staff will look for adequate disclosure and practices consistent with that disclosure.

    Application to examinations.

    The focus areas that the Staff highlights, including investment allocations, use of affiliated service providers, and fee and expense calculations and practices, are core topics typically covered in private fund adviser examinations and are bread-and-butter topics for examiners looking to identify conflicted practices. Despite SEC enforcement activity being down an estimated 57% for fiscal year 2026,[3] private fund examinations remain active, and we expect private fund advisers to continue to be an area of focus for the Division over the next year.

    These topics, particularly given they can involve financial conflicts, remain attractive in examinations and potential enforcement, as they could provide the Staff with a clear hook for alleging potential monetary harm. In addition, while some of the financial conflicts addressed in the 2027 priorities have a retail bend (e.g., focus on fee rebates), such topics also have private fund corollaries (e.g., management fee offsets for offsetable fees or calculation of investor management fee discounts or waivers) that will continue to receive attention in examinations. The focus on debt and credit facilities usage also has continued to play out in examinations, with the Staff continuing to look at the interplay of leverage with a number of fund mechanics and operations, including performance calculations and fee and expense matters.

    Although not identified in the release as private fund-specific focus areas, many of the Division’s general investment adviser and compliance program priorities are also relevant to private fund adviser examinations, including testing of topics such as the effectiveness of compliance policies and procedures (including that they are evolving with business changes, such as new product lines or organizational or merger activity), fiduciary obligations relating to economic conflicts of interest (e.g., recent cases involving undisclosed adviser compensation arrangements), full and fair disclosure of all material facts relating to advisory relationships to clients, and the reasonableness, and consistent application, of valuation processes and methodologies. Examinations will also typically analyze an adviser’s annual compliance review, which was the subject of a recent risk alert from the Division.[4]

    1. The artificial intelligence focus matures.

    While last year’s priorities focused on recent advancements in AI and reviewing registrant representations for accuracy regarding their AI capabilities or use, this year’s priorities recognize that registrants are increasingly using AI in core business operations and systems, including investment analysis, customer management, and code development. The Division will focus on registrants’ assessment of and preparation for potential AI-driven cyberattacks that may affect their businesses or customers, including AI-generated phishing and deepfake voice and video. Similar to last year’s priorities, the Division will also prioritize examining how firms monitor AI use for fraud prevention and detection, back-office operations, and trading functions, and this year’s priorities add compliance with anti-money laundering and Regulation Best Interest obligations to that list. The Division will also continue to review whether representations regarding the use of automated AI tools are fair and accurate.

    Application to examinations.

    In examinations, we have recently seen the Staff ask for details regarding advisers’ use of AI in their day-to-day business activities, in addition to requests for AI-related policies and procedures and training. AI-related requests are becoming more frequent, with recent request lists seeking information on AI-related disclosures in marketing documents, data sources used by AI systems, data source providers used by the registrant, AI data security measures, AI-related governance and controls, and the personnel and training supporting AI use. The granularity of these requests continues to deepen as the Staff’s expertise and interest in this area grows, and the Division is also using AI to enhance its own examination capabilities, which we have seen in recent examinations.

    For any advisers that use AI models in their investment process, recent requests have been detailed, seeking items such as descriptions of all distinct AI-based models and techniques used to manage client portfolios or make investment decisions, lists and descriptions of all algorithmic trading signals generated by AI models, reports on the AI models’ performance over time and under various market conditions, and samples of reports detailing the validation process and performance of AI algorithms. In addition to ensuring their policies, procedures, and training are keeping abreast of their firm’s (and its personnel’s) use of AI and associated risks, compliance personnel should be in communication with their information technology and operations counterparts to assess their readiness to respond to these increasingly sophisticated requests around AI usage.

    1. Regulation S-P moves from readiness to implementation.

    When the 2026 priorities were published, the amended Reg S-P compliance dates were still ahead, and the Division’s priorities discussed readiness, specifically noting that it would engage firms about their progress in preparing incident response programs reasonably designed to detect, respond to, and recover from unauthorized access to or use of customer information.[5] With the Reg S-P compliance dates now past for all covered institutions, the 2027 priorities drop the readiness approach, with the Division noting that it will focus on whether firms’ policies and procedures are reasonably designed to address administrative, technical, and physical safeguards to protect customer information, as required by Reg S-P. The priorities note that the Staff will evaluate response program policies and procedures for addressing unauthorized access to or use of customer information, including customer notification procedures and oversight of service providers, as well as how firms address operational and technology risks as part of safeguarding customer information.

    Application to examinations.

    We have not yet seen industry-wide examinations focused on Reg S-P, but we have seen examination request lists include privacy and Reg S-P-related requests, alongside broader cybersecurity requests that have been part of the examination request lists for years. For example, recent request lists have asked for policies and procedures addressing the administrative, technical, and physical safeguards for the protection of customer and client records and information. The Staff has also requested records of any non-compliance by employees, contractors, vendors, or other third parties with an adviser’s policies and procedures relating to all applicable federal securities laws or cybersecurity policies and procedures. As we have seen an increasing number of sponsors and other firms experience cyberattacks, the Staff’s focus on Reg S-P serves as a good reminder that advisers should be activating their incident response programs, as applicable, following situations in which suspected unauthorized access to or use of customer information has occurred.

    Like the AI requests discussed above, the Staff’s sophistication in, and focus on, cybersecurity and privacy matters continue to grow, and this attention aligns with the continued focus on investor protection animating many of the 2027 priorities. In 2027, we expect more examination requests that test Reg S-P implementation. Additionally, as part of its Compliance Outreach Program, the Staff has also posted materials summarizing examination testing relating to Reg S-P, and the SEC’s upcoming national seminar for investment advisers may provide additional insights on this topic, particularly its panel on Information Security and Operational Resiliency.[6]

    1. Economic conflicts of interest receive their own spotlight.

    As noted above, this year’s release highlights reviewing advisers’ fiduciary obligations relating to economic conflicts, specifically assessing whether financial conflicts may affect the impartiality of advice in areas such as fee rebates, fee and expense calculations, cash management, quid pro quo arrangements, deposits, and withdrawals. The release points to the Division’s risk alert published earlier this year, which describes economic conflicts of interest observed by the Staff that were undisclosed or incompletely disclosed to investors.[7] Regarding conflicts more broadly, the Division will continue to prioritize whether policies and procedures are reasonably designed to address conflicts of interest, and as in the 2026 priorities, examinations will focus on whether disclosures address fee-related conflicts of interest, particularly those arising from account and product compensation structures.

    Application to examinations.

    Although many of the economic conflicts of interest themes included in the release are framed around products offered to retail investors, these concepts are readily portable to private fund advisers. As noted above, we continue to see the Staff focus on the accuracy of fee and expense calculations in examinations of private fund advisers, including management fee base calculations and calculations of any fee offsets, waivers, and discounts. In examinations, the Staff also typically scrutinizes the adviser’s existing fee-related disclosures and tests whether the adviser’s practices are consistent with those disclosures. As noted above, this topic may also interact with other fund mechanics and operations that the Division identified as examination priorities, such as use of borrowing or sub-line facilities, that impact fees and expenses payable by clients.

    1. Proxy advisers are a new topic.

    Proxy advisers are a new topic in the 2027 priorities. In the same discussion as advisers’ use of third-party service providers to access clients’ accounts, the Division states that it will also examine advisers that rely on proxy advisory firms, assessing how those advisers evaluate such firms’ recommendations, examine their bases, identify potential conflicts of interest, and determine whether that reliance satisfies applicable legal obligations.

    Application to examinations.

    This new focus on proxy advisory firms as an examination priority mirrors other recent SEC statements, including remarks earlier this year by Brian Daly, Director of the SEC’s Division of Investment Management, questioning the industry’s “vote all proxies” approach.[8] While Director Daly noted that there is “nothing inherently wrong” with using a proxy advisor under a tailored mandate and subject to periodic review, he questioned whether advisers whose votes on non-routine matters are “nearly identical” to a proxy advisor’s standard policies are acting in clients’ best interests. Advisers should therefore expect examiners to test whether their proxy voting practices and related documentation reflect independent judgment, including how they evaluate proxy advisory firm recommendations and the bases for them, identify potential conflicts of interest (including on the part of such firms), and determine whether their reliance on those firms satisfies their fiduciary obligations. Given these statements, advisers’ proxy policies and practices (and any associated testing and documentation) may warrant a review and refresh, and the Staff will likely be skeptical of a set-it-and-forget-it approach to relying on proxy firms.

    Looking Ahead

    As is typical, the 2027 priorities present a good opportunity for registrants to take stock of their compliance programs. The 2027 priorities underscore core topics, including a focus on fiduciary duties, compliance program effectiveness, and appropriately addressing (including through disclosure) conflicts of interest; these priorities also highlight, consistent with recent examinations, certain priorities directly relevant to private fund and Regulated Fund advisers. The 2027 priorities also underscore the Division’s new theme of operating in a way that is both accessible and integrated,[9] and we will see how the Division delivers on its goals to operate in a more transparent and approachable manner. In the meantime, examinations remain active, and registrants are advised to review the 2027 priorities against their own compliance programs to confirm they remain prepared for a possible examination.


    [1] For additional discussion of the SEC’s recent statements regarding fair value measurements and disclosure considerations for private assets held by Regulated Funds and Exchange Act-reporting private funds, please see our alert, SEC Joint Statement on Valuation of Private Assets (Oct. 2, 2026), available here.

    [2] For additional discussion of these examinations, please see our article, Recent SEC Examinations Target Interval Funds and Business Development Companies, The Investment Lawyer (October 2026), available here.

    [3] See Is the ‘Cop Off the Beat’? SEC Enforcement Activity Is Down 57%, Report Finds, Barron’s (Oct. 27, 2026), available here.

    [4] See Risk Alert, Examination Observations Regarding Investment Adviser Annual Compliance Reviews (Sept. 14, 2026), available here. We have seen many advisers review or update their annual compliance review policies and procedures to address the Staff’s observations in the risk alert. The publication of the 2027 examination priorities creates an opportune time for advisers who have not yet reviewed their annual compliance review policies and procedures to do so.

    [5] Larger covered institutions (including registered investment advisers with over $1.5 billion in AUM and investment companies with over $1 billion in AUM) were required to comply with the 2024 Reg S-P amendments by December 3, 2025, and smaller covered institutions were required to comply by June 3, 2026.

    [6] See SEC, Compliance Outreach Program, Regulation S-P, available here; SEC Meetings and Other Events, 2026 Compliance Outreach Program National Seminar for Investment Advisers, available here.

    [7] See Risk Alert, Examinations Observations of Investment Adviser Obligations Related to Economic Conflicts of Interest (June 9, 2026), available here.

    [8] See Brian Daly, Director, Division of Investment Management, (Re)empowering Fiduciaries in Proxy Voting (Jan. 8, 2026), available here.

    [9] See Keith Cassidy, Director, Division of Examinations, EXAMS accessible and integrated (Sept. 16, 2026), available here; SEC’s Division of Examinations Announces New Exam Handbook (Oct. 1, 2026), available here.

  • The Ad Standard: Monthly Update – November 2026

    It was a busy month at the FTC. In addition to continuing its enforcement push on price transparency, the agency ordered major retailers to provide information on the use of personal data to set prices, a practice known as “algorithmic,” “personalized” or “surveillance” pricing. Whatever you call it, the practice is drawing increasing scrutiny at both the federal and state levels. For more on this, see What marketers should know about the legal risks of algorithmic pricing, by The Ad Standard: Monthly Update co-author Laura Brett, including practical steps companies can take to avoid crossing the line.

    Advertising class action litigation shows no signs of slowing, and California’s federal courts remained a favored venue. So it is no surprise that California courts are providing much of the guidance on whether front-of-label claims can be clarified by a disclosure. In a recent decision, a court granted summary judgment, finding that an ambiguous claim on the front of a label could be clarified by a disclosure on the side panel.

    Meanwhile, NAD is not leaving price transparency entirely to the FTC and the Courts. This month, it closed two monitoring cases involving price transparency in the cruise industry.

    FTC Focus 

    FTC Enforcement

    1. A federal court recently entered a $106.8 million default judgment against the operators of an alleged debt relief scheme that targeted seniors and veterans by impersonating banks, credit card companies, and government agencies; falsely claimed that they could reduce consumers’ debt by as much as 75% or more; and collected illegal advance fees. The FTC alleged that the operators, including Accelerated Debt Settlement Inc., contacted consumers through telemarketing calls or in response to calls that resulted from their direct-mail and online ads. Among other things, the order bans the corporate and individual defendants from the debt relief industry and from impersonating any government entity, business, or person.

      Court Permanently Shuts Down Illegal Debt Relief Operation Following FTC Allegation That Scheme’s Operators Impersonated Government and Business Entities | Federal Trade Commission
    1. The FTC sued GovAssist LLC, Entry LLC and Scott Zuckerman, for their alleged involvement in a government impersonation scheme that deceived consumers seeking passport services by purporting to be the federal government or affiliated with the federal government, in violation of the FTC Act, the Impersonation Rule and the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act. The FTC alleges that defendants use deceptive paid search ads to lure travelers to their websites, made them false service promises to obtain their financial and personal information, and concealed their scheme from consumers with fake positive consumer reviews.

      FTC Sues Perpetrators of Government Impersonation Scheme Over Deceptive Ads, Misleading Promises and Fake Reviews | Federal Trade Commission
    1. Greenway Auto Group has agreed to prominently include the actual price a consumer must pay for a vehicle in its price advertisements, excluding only charges the government requires consumers to pay, to settle an FTC lawsuit alleging that it advertised prices that were thousands of dollars below what it actually charged. According to the FTC, in over 92% of transactions Greenway inflated the amount it charged consumers by tacking on to the advertised price mandatory fees, packages, and penalties. The proposed order prohibits Greenway from sending deceptive prize mailers that lured customers with nonexistent cash prizes, and bans specific misrepresentations, including whether charges, fees, taxes, products or services are optional or required.

      FTC Secures Settlement with Auto Dealership Group in Price Transparency Win for Consumers | Federal Trade Commission
    1. Under a proposed settlement, Premier Franchising Group LLC (PFG) and its former franchise sales organization, Franchise Fastlane LLC (FFL), will pay $1.85 million to settle FTC allegations that they made misleading representations about the Premier Martial Arts (PMA) franchise opportunity and violated the Franchise Rule. PFG and FFL allegedly deceptively claimed that non-martial artists could profitably operate one or multiple franchises on a semi-absentee basis working less than 15 hours a week. According to the FTC, more than 200 consumers, including veterans, paid PFG an initial franchise fee of $49,500 or more to purchase a franchise opportunity and incurred hundreds of thousands of dollars in additional expenses to build out and operate their studios, with many assuming significant debt. The complaint further alleged that PFG also deceived prospective franchisees by reporting in its Franchise Disclosure Documents that its existing studios earned significant income but lacked a reasonable basis to know whether those earnings were representative of what new PMA franchisee studios could earn due to material differences between existing studios and prospective studios. For example, many existing franchisees had studios larger than what PFG recommended and existing franchisees had significant martial arts experience compared to most new franchisees with no martial arts experience.

      Premier Martial Arts Franchisor and its Former Franchise Sales Organization Settle FTC Charges that the Companies Made Deceptive Claims and Violated the Franchise Rule | Federal Trade Commission
    1. A federal court has granted a TRO to stop Digital Forensics Corporation LLC and its CEO from allegedly defrauding consumers out of at least $60 million by falsely and deceptively claiming that they would help victims of sextortion. Sextortion often involves foreign scammers who threaten to publish a nude or sexual image of the victim unless the victim pays. The FTC alleged that Digital Forensics used ads on search, video sharing and social media platforms to target victims looking for help and pushed them to purchase its services, which supposedly included tracking the sextortionist’s location, communicating with the sextortionist, producing a detailed investigative report, communicating with law enforcement, and ongoing monitoring. Despite charging consumers between $1,499 and $20,000, Digital Forensics allegedly did not perform the promised services, suppressed negative customer reviews, and generated thousands of fake positive online reviews to hide its false promises.

      FTC Sues Operator of Sextortion Relief Scheme for Misleading Consumers into Believing it Would Identify Criminals and End Sextortion Attacks | Federal Trade Commission
    1. The FTC, joined by a number of states and local municipalities, sued Toast Inc. and affiliated entities, alleging the restaurant software and fintech company violated the FTC Act, ROSCA, and related state laws by charging restaurants hidden fees, unauthorized fees, and unwanted add-ons; failing to deliver on its “24/7/365” customer support promises; and utilizing a multi-step cancellation process. Toast’s cloud-based products and services help restaurants take and manage orders, accept payments and track inventory, among other related services. The fintech company sells its software as an annual or biennial subscription service, billed monthly. 

      FTC and States Take Action Against Toast Inc. over Hidden and Unauthorized Fees, Deceptive Subscription and Cancellation Practices and Other Unlawful Conduct | Federal Trade Commission

    FTC Inquiries and Warning Letters

    1. Pursuant to Section 6(b) of the FTC Act, the FTC ordered Delta, United, JetBlue, Lyft, Uber, DoorDash, Instacart, Target, and Walmart to provide information on their use of personal data to set prices and compensation. Specifically, the FTC is seeking information that will allow it to assess whether prices for tickets, ride shares, food deliveries or other products or services vary from one person to the next based on factors such as participation in loyalty programs or algorithmic analysis of personal data. The companies have 45 days from the date they receive the orders to respond. In August, the FTC sought public comment on a proposed enforcement policy statement describing how the undisclosed use of personal information to set unique prices could violate the FTC Act. 

      FTC Launches Personalized Pricing and Compensation Inquiry | Federal Trade Commission
    1. The FTC sent warning letters to 24 of the nation’s largest healthcare services companies, reminding them to provide patients with timely, accurate, and complete pricing information for healthcare services, including routine and non-emergency medical care, and that failing to do so may violate the FTC Act. The letters emphasized that the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services’ (CMS) price transparency rules establish a baseline for ensuring that healthcare facilities provide pricing information. However, compliance with the CMS rules does not mean that a healthcare facility has complied with Section 5 of the FTC Act and the CMS rules do not create a safe harbor from FTC Act liability. 

      FTC Issues Letters Warning Hospitals Against Deceptive Pricing Practices | Federal Trade Commission
    1. The FTC sent warning letters to 25 companies that market or generate sales leads for healthcare plans to put them on notice about deceptive or unfair claims and to urge them to review their advertising to ensure compliance with applicable laws and rules. Activities that may violate the law include misrepresenting the benefits or limitations of a healthcare plan, including any insurance benefits, misrepresenting a plan’s costs or that a healthcare plan is major or comprehensive medical health insurance or its equivalent when in fact it is not, and falsely offering free offers, cash rewards, rebates, or other incentives to spur enrollment. Christopher Mufarrige, Director of the FTC’s Bureau of Consumer Protection, commented that “The FTC will remain focused on monitoring this market and will not hesitate to hold accountable companies that unlawfully market or advertise healthcare plans to consumers.”

      FTC Staff Warn Marketers of Healthcare Plans and Lead Generators Not to Deceive Consumers about the Terms of the Advertised Plans | Federal Trade Commission

    Annual Reports

    1. The FTC issued its latest report to Congress on protecting older adults, which highlights key trends based on fraud reports submitted by older adults, details the FTC’s efforts to stop unfair or deceptive acts or practices that impact older Americans, and includes estimates that the overall cost of fraud to older adults in 2025 could be as high as $119.5 billion.

      FTC Issues Annual Report to Congress on Agency’s Actions to Protect Older Adults | Federal Trade Commission

    Class Actions

    Allulose Class Actions

    Target Corp. has been sued in a putative class action alleging that it falsely and misleadingly markets its store brand Up & Up Sugar-Free Hydration Supplement Powder products because they contain allulose, which the complaints assert qualifies as a sugar under federal labeling standards. Plaintiff asserts violations of various state consumer protection statutes, including Illinois and New York, and the Illinois Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Business Practices Act.

    Williams v. Target Corp., No. 1:26-cv-12870 (N.D. Ill. Oct. 20, 2026)

    Dunkin’ Brands, Inc. and Inspire Brands, Inc. were sued in a putative class action alleging that they falsely market and advertise their Dunkin’ Zero beverages as containing “0g of sugar” and “zero grams of sugar” because they, in fact, contain allulose. Plaintiff asserts violations of the Illinois Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Business Practices Act.

    Wells v. Dunkin’ Brands, Inc., No. 1:26-cv-14463 (D. Mass. Sept. 30, 2026)

    The Kroger Co. was sued in a putative class action alleging that it falsely and misleadingly markets its maple-flavored sugar product, Simple Truth Syrup, as “Zero Sugar,” as well as containing “0g Added Sugar” because it, in fact, contains allulose. Plaintiff asserts violations of state consumer protection statutes, including Illinois and New York, and the Illinois Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Business Practices Act.

    Newton v. The Kroger Co., No. 1:26-cv-12573 (N.D. Ill. Oct. 14, 2026)

    Costco Wholesale Corp. was sued in a putative class action alleging that it falsely and misleadingly markets and advertises its Kirkland Signature Hydration Electrolyte Drink Mix as being “Sugar-Free” because it, in fact, contains allulose. Plaintiff asserts violations of the Illinois Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Business Practices Act and the Washington Consumer Protection Act.

    Maldonado v. Costco Wholesale Corp., No. 2:26-cv-03702 (W.D. Wash. Sept. 30, 2026)


    “Sugar-Free” Claims

    Starbucks Corp. was sued in a putative class action alleging that its use of the term “Sugar-Free” in the product names of its “Protein Beverages” product line is false and misleading because the products contain lactose, which is a naturally occurring sugar, resulting in the products containing approximately 13–21 grams of sugar per venti serving. Plaintiffs assert violations of California’s Consumer Legal Remedies Act, False Advertising Law, and Unfair Competition Law, New York General Business Law Sections 349 and 350, and Washington’s Consumer Protection Act.

    Walsh v. Starbucks Corp., No. 2:26-cv-03745 (W.D. Wash. Oct. 2, 2026)


    “Made With Avocado Oil” Claims

    Garza Food Ventures, LLC d/b/a Siete Family Foods and PepsiCo, Inc. were sued in a putative class action alleging that they falsely and deceptively label, advertise and market their “Maiz Sea Salt Corn Tortilla Chips Made with Avocado Oil” and “Kettle Cooked Sea Salt Potato Chips Made with Avocado Oil” as “MADE WITH AVOCADO OIL,” which is, in fact, false because the products contain undisclosed seed oils. Plaintiff asserts violations of the Illinois Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Business Practices Act and the Illinois Uniform Deceptive Trade Practices Act.

    Wilson v. Garza Food Ventures, LLC, No. 1:26-cv-13028 (N.D. Ill. Oct. 22, 2026)


    Children’s Supplement Claims

    Mom Enterprises, LLC was sued in a putative class action alleging that it falsely and misleadingly markets its Mommy’s Bliss Kids Sleep melatonin supplement as being able to “promote restful sleep and bring bliss back to bedtime” and “support your child’s natural sleep process,” that it is “designed for kids 3 years and above,” and is “a safe supplement for children” because melatonin, the product’s primary active ingredient, is unsafe for children. Plaintiffs assert violations of California’s Consumer Legal Remedies Act and Unfair Competition Law and, for the Wisconsin subclass, Section 100.18 of the Wisconsin Statutes, which prohibits false, deceptive, or misleading advertisements.

    Martinez v. Mom Enterprises, LLC, No. 3:26-cv-05834 (S.D. Cal. Oct. 12, 2026)


    Amount of Product Ingredient

    Walmart, Inc. was sued in a putative class action alleging that its Great Value brand pre-packaged frozen cooked and raw shrimp products “contain materially less frozen shrimp by weight than stated on the label and packaging; in some cases, as much as 11% less than advertised.” Plaintiffs assert violations of the Illinois Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Business Practices Act.

    Baptist v. Walmart, Inc., No. 2026CH09745 (Ill. Cir. Ct. Cook Cnty. Oct. 8, 2026)


    Dermatologically Tested Claims

    ZURU Consumer Brands LLC and ZURU LLC were sued in a putative class action alleging that they advertise their Millie Moon Luxury Diapers as absorbent with claims including “12 HOUR ABSORBENCY” and a “DOUBLE LEAK GUARD” and as safe with claims including “Dermatologically Tested” and containing a “pH BALANCE LINER,” but that the diapers in fact fail to absorb adequately and infants using them have experienced skin reactions. Plaintiffs assert violations of California’s Consumer Legal Remedies Act, False Advertising Law, and Unfair Competition Law.

    McGee v. ZURU Consumer Brands LLC, No. 5:26-cv-05823 (C.D. Cal. Oct. 1, 2026)


    Metabolism and Body Fat Claims

    Celsius Holdings, Inc. and Celsius, Inc. were sued in a putative class action alleging that they misleadingly and falsely claim on the front labels of their energy drinks that it “accelerates metabolism” and “burns body fat,” because drinking the products will not “accelerate” a person’s metabolism nor will they “burn” one’s body fat. Plaintiff asserts violations of the Washington Consumer Protection Act.

    Nielsen v. Celsius Holdings, Inc., No. 2:26-cv-04113 (W.D. Wash. Oct. 26, 2026)


    Fee Class Actions

    Optum Financial, Inc. and ConnectYourCare, LLC, (collectively, “Optum”), which administers FSAs and HSAs for individuals who have also enrolled in COBRA, were sued in a putative class action alleging that when consumers make their monthly COBRA, FSA or HSA premium payments through Optum’s online portal, Optum tacks on a $20 processing fee to all one-time monthly premium payments, regardless of the form of payment or its amount. Plaintiff further alleges that Optum tacks on the fee only after consumers have completed a comprehensive sign-up process, as well as fails to reasonably or adequately inform consumers that the fee will be charged or disclose reasonable alternatives to paying it. Plaintiff asserts violations of California’s Consumer Legal Remedies Act and Unfair Competition Law, and the Minnesota Prevention of Consumer Fraud Act.

    Delkhaste v. Optum Fin., Inc., No. 3:26-cv-11895 (N.D. Cal. Oct. 14, 2026)

    The Stop & Shop Supermarket Company, LLC was sued in a putative class action alleging that it is charging unfair and deceptive fees by quoting customers a fee-less price when they begin an Online Pickup Order through either www.stopandshop.com or its mobile app, but tacks on a $3.95 “Pick Up Fee” at checkout. Plaintiff alleges violations of the Massachusetts Unfair and Deceptive Businesses Act, which prohibits misrepresenting or failing to disclose a product’s total price prior to requiring any personal information, including customer billing information, as well as prohibits misrepresenting or failing to disclose the nature, purpose, and amount of any fees, charges, or other expenses—excluding shipping charges and government charges—when the product’s total price is initially presented.

    Douglas v. The Stop & Shop Supermarket Co., No. 3:26-cv-30170 (D. Mass. Oct. 15, 2026)


    Dismissal Reversed

    The Fifth Circuit reversed a district court’s dismissal under Rule 12(b)(1) for lack of Article III injury in a class action alleging that a Mississippi-based seafood restaurant and others violated the Mississippi Consumer Protection Act by marketing and selling inexpensive foreign fish as high-priced premium local fish. The Fifth Circuit held that the plaintiff customer “plausibly suffered an injury in fact cognizable under Article III.” As to plaintiff’s fraudulent-inducement theory, the court determined that plaintiff’s injury is “sufficiently concrete” to support Article III standing where he claims that he suffered an economic injury because he purchased inexpensive frozen fish he would not have purchased but for defendants’ misrepresentation. The court drew a distinction between decisions that rejected the application of the fraudulent-inducement theory where a plaintiff suffered no physical injury but based his economic injury on the product’s risk of physical harm (e.g., a medication that allegedly carried a risk of liver harm but plaintiffs suffered no physical injury) with decisions where a product seller promised a high-quality product, charged the buyer for that high-quality product, and delivered an inferior version of that product (e.g., health insurance plan purchasers alleged that the plan’s provider directories were materially inaccurate and represented out-of-network providers as in-network).

    McCain v. Mary Mahoney’s, Inc., No. 5-60663, 2026 U.S. App. LEXIS 31515 (5th Cir. Oct. 16, 2026)


    Dismissal Denied

    A federal district court denied dismissal of claims in a putative class action alleging that Mitra-9 Brands, LLC violated New York General Business Law (NY GBL) Sections 349 and 350 by falsely, misleadingly, and deceptively advertising its seltzers, powders, and shots with kratom as having various benefits that can help consumers “sail through their workday or support their post-workout routine,” and “support overall vitality and well-being,” without disclosing the health hazards and addictive risks associated with its products. Explaining that a plaintiff may show a material omission by alleging that a consumer could not reasonably obtain the relevant information that a defendant failed to provide, the court concluded that plaintiff plausibly pleaded a viable claim that defendant’s omission regarding kratom’s addictiveness constituted a deceptive practice under NY GBL. The court noted that plaintiff asserts that the general public knows little about kratom, accurate information about its risks is difficult to access, and kratom is largely unregulated yet widely available. The court further pointed out that a reasonable consumer would have no reason to suspect or inquire whether the products contained an opioid-like substance with serious addictive risks, which plaintiff alleges defendant advertises and packages with no health warnings while promoting “kratom’s potential benefits” and that the packaging mimics well-known supplements and caffeinated energy drinks.

    Cheswick v. Mitra-9 Brands, LLC, No. 1:25-CV-6795, 2026 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 225375 (S.D.N.Y. Sept. 30, 2026)

    A federal district court denied HanesBrands, Inc.’s motion for judgment on the pleadings in a class action alleging that its email promotions lure consumers with urgent email subject lines that misrepresent the timing of the deals and harm consumers by creating a false sense of urgency to act that is in violation of Washington’s Commercial Electronic Mail Act (CEMA) and Consumer Protection Act (CPA). The court denied Hanes’ request to reconsider its prior decision denying dismissal, where the court concluded that plaintiff alleged sufficient facts to establish a CEMA claim so her CPA claim was also sufficient because a violation of CEMA is a per se violation of the CPA. The court stated that Hanes failed to cite to any intervening or controlling authority. The court explained that the holding in Meade v. Profusion Cosmetics Corp., 2026 WL 2098093, at *2 (W.D. Wash. July 16, 2026) (that a successful CEMA claim does not establish a per se CPA claim as the CPA also requires injury) is not binding and directly contradicts the Supreme Court of Washington’s holding in Wright v. Lyft, 189 Wash. 2d 718 (Wash. 2017) that a CEMA violation automatically establishes a CPA violation. The court stated that Hanes “further misconstrues the holding in Wright to only apply to text messages, when the court expressly contemplates the congressional intent for CEMA to apply to text messages and emails equally.” Noting that this is an actively developing area of state law, the court stated that it will defer to the Washington courts’ interpretation of Washington statutes.

     Jackson v. HanesBrands, Inc., No. 2:25-CV-00440, 2026 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 234948 (E.D. Wash. Oct. 14, 2026)


    Summary Judgment Granted

    A district court granted summary judgment in favor of Barilla America, Inc. with respect to plaintiffs’ California statutory claims in a class action alleging that it falsely advertised its pasta by labeling its boxes with “Italy’s #1 Brand of Pasta,” with three teardrops of green, white, and red positioned on either side of the text, because it misled consumers to believe it was manufactured in Italy from Italian ingredients when it in fact was made in the U.S. from non-Italian ingredients. As to plaintiffs’ California statutory claims, the court concluded that Barilla’s labeling is not misleading as a matter of law. The court rejected plaintiffs’ proposed reading of the ambiguity standard in Whiteside v. Kimberly Clark Corp., 108 F.4th 771 (9th Cir. 2024) stating that it could only be satisfied by labels that “make no representation at all or . . . are so devoid of any concrete meaning that there is nothing from which any inference could be drawn or on which any reasonable belief could be based” warning that this could mean that any label susceptible to at least one concrete false meaning would be actionable. The court stated that instead it “reads Whiteside to mean what it says: that ‘a front label is ambiguous when reasonable consumers would necessarily require more information before reasonably concluding that the label is making a particular representation.’” After finding the presence of ambiguity—based on a consumer survey showing around 80% of respondents interpreted the challenged representation to mean something about brand popularity, while around 30% interpreted it to mean something about ingredient sourcing—the court considered “what additional information other than the front label was available to consumers of the Barilla products.” The court stated that this includes the side label statement “Made in the U.S.A. with U.S.A. and imported ingredients.” The court concluded that the challenged representation is not misleading as a matter of law because upon seeing the side label, it would be clear to a reasonable consumer that the pasta was not made in Italy with Italian ingredients.

    Sinatro v. Barilla Am., Inc., No. 22-cv-03460, 2026 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 224853 (N.D. Cal. Sept. 30, 2026)

    NAD Focus

    “30 Minutes to Whiter Teeth” Claims

    Following a reopened inquiry, NAD recommended that Oral Essentials, Inc. (OEI) continue to discontinue its “30 minutes to whiter teeth” claim for its Lumineux Whitening Strips. In the underlying challenge brought by competitor the Procter & Gamble Company, NAD recommended that OEI discontinue the claim “30 minutes to whiter teeth” or modify it to avoid conveying that consumers will experience whiter teeth after using the Lumineux product once for 30 minutes. Subsequently, OEI petitioned to reopen the proceeding and provided three new studies to support its claims. However, NAD determined that all three studies were fatally flawed. Two of the studies did not include a negative control, making it impossible for NAD to determine whether the whitening could be attributed to OEI’s product or another variable, and the third study’s data discrepancies called its reliability into question, noting tooth color measurements that should have been impossible and standard deviations that were unusually high.

    Oral Essentials, Inc. (Lumineux Whitening Strips), Report #7235RO, NAD/CARU Case Reports (Oct. 2026)


    Hair and Skin Claims

    As part of its routine monitoring program, NAD determined that Blissy, LLC supported its “Less Frizz” claim for its Blissy Silk Pillowcases, but recommended that Blissy modify or discontinue certain claims concerning hair breakage and tangles, anti-aging and wrinkle prevention, acne, clinical study results, and dermatologist endorsements. NAD determined that the evidence Blissy submitted (lab testing on prepared hair samples and studies where users report their perceptions) supported the general “Less Frizz” claim. NAD further found that consumers could understand Blissy’s express “Breakage-Free” and “Tangle-Free” claims to convey the unsupported message that use of Blissy pillowcases completely prevents hair breakage and tangles while sleeping, and recommended that Blissy discontinue both claims or modify its advertising to avoid conveying the message that use of its pillowcases completely prevents hair breakage or tangles while sleeping. NAD also determined that the challenged dermatologist endorsements conveyed that they used their expertise to evaluate Blissy’s clinical testing and found it reliable but recommended that Blissy discontinue or modify the endorsements because Blissy’s studies did not support the specific outcomes, percentages, and timeframes stated. NAD also recommended that Blissy discontinue the claims “Anti-aging” and “Prevents Signs of Aging … preventing the formation of new fine lines and wrinkles as you sleep,” and modify its advertising to avoid conveying that using Blissy pillowcases prevents additional facial wrinkles after concluding that the studies submitted were not a good fit for the broad unqualified claims. NAD also determined that a study testing whether its silk material clogs pores was not a good fit for the unqualified “acne-fighting” claims and recommended that Blissy discontinue or modify its advertising to avoid conveying that using Blissy pillowcases help prevent or reduce acne breakouts. During the inquiry, Blissy voluntarily agreed to discontinue the express claims “90% of people had … fewer blocked pores after using these pillowcases” and “90% had … fewer blocked pores.”

    Blissy, LLC (Blissy Silk Pillowcases), Report #7578, NAD/CARU Case Reports (Sept. 2026)


    Cruise Price and Gratuity Disclosures

    As part of its routine monitoring program, NAD recommended that Virgin Cruises Intermediate Ltd. Inc. modify its Virgin Voyages advertising to clearly and conspicuously disclose service gratuities throughout the checkout process. At issue was whether Virgin Cruises highlighted a lead price without prominently disclosing the additional, mandatory per-night service gratuity. NAD determined that consumers are not sufficiently apprised about the discretionary nature of gratuities in Virgin’s checkout process, how they are applied, and how they can remove them if they pay onboard. Additionally, in the final step of checkout the gratuities are referenced as a “service charge,” which creates further confusion about whether they are optional. Therefore, NAD recommended that Virgin modify its booking flow to clearly and conspicuously disclose throughout the checkout process that: (1) gratuities are optional but not refundable if pre-paid; (2) the gratuities are higher if paid onboard; and (3) if not prepaid, gratuities can be modified or removed prior to disembarkation.

    Virgin Cruises Intermediate Limited Inc. (Virgin Voyages), Report #7560, NAD/CARU Case Reports (Oct. 2026)

    As part of its routine monitoring program, Royal Caribbean Group voluntarily modified certain advertising claims but NAD recommended further changes to disclosures regarding optional pre-payment of gratuities. At issue was whether Royal Caribbean’s advertising disclosed adequate information about gratuity fees. During the inquiry, Royal Caribbean modified its online booking to clearly and conspicuously disclose that gratuities are optional, that customers may choose to prepay them, and that they may modify or remove gratuities at any time prior to disembarkation. However, NAD recommended that Royal Caribbean modify certain gratuities information in the “learn more” tab and on the final checkout page to make clear that gratuities are optional.

    Royal Caribbean Group (Advertising for Royal Caribbean), Report #7561, NAD/CARU Case Reports (Oct. 2026)


    NAD to Refer HigherDOSE for Red Light Product Claims

    As part of its marketplace monitoring program, NAD will refer HigherDOSE, LLC’s express and implied claims about its Red Light Hat and Red Light Face Mask to the appropriate regulatory authorities for failure to participate in two separate NAD inquiries. NAD inquired about claims that the Red Light Hat could support hair growth, increase blood flow, rejuvenate hair follicles, reduce shedding, and strengthen roots and that the Red Light Face Mask could reduce fine lines and wrinkles, improve the skin barrier and firmness, and increase skin hydration, among other claims. 

    HigherDOSE, LLC (HigherDOSE Red Light Hat), Report #7599, NAD/CARU Case Reports (Oct. 2026)

    HigherDOSE, LLC (HigherDOSE Red Light Face Mask), Report #7598, NAD/CARU Case Reports (Oct. 2026)


    Visit Our False Advertising Litigation Practice Page» 

    Subscribe to receive The Ad Standard»

    Read previous editions of The Ad Standard»

  • Simpson Thacher Attorneys Author Law360 Article on SCOTUS 401(k) Alternative Investments Case

    Partners Erica Rozow and Rajib Chanda and Associate Christopher Torikoglu authored an article published by Law360, which examined the potential implications of a U.S. Supreme Court decision in Anderson v. Intel Corp. Investment Policy Committee for the use of alternative assets in 401(k) plans. The article provided background on the pleading standards at the center of the case and outlined the Court’s consideration of whether, and in what cases, a “meaningful benchmark” should be required in ERISA imprudence claims. The article further discussed how a ruling in Intel’s favor, together with recent Department of Labor actions, could reduce litigation risk for plan sponsors and help facilitate broader access to alternative investments through defined contribution plans.

    To read the full article, please click here (subscription required).