Corban v. USAA: Reinterpreting the Anti-Concurrent Causation Clause





Lynn K. Neuner Lynn K. Neuner
Bryce L. Friedman Bryce L. Friedman

On October 8, 2009, the Mississippi Supreme Court, in a unanimous decision, held that a homeowner’s insurer may be liable for a portion of the plaintiffs’ more than $1 million estimated cost for storm damages to their home from Hurricane Katrina. The decision addressed two important issues regarding post-Katrina claims. In favor of insurers, the decision approved a lower court and prior federal decisions that held that a “water damage” exclusion precludes coverage for hurricane-driven water (also known as “storm surge”). However, the Supreme Court, contrary to two decisions of the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, determined that the “anti-concurrent causation” clause in the policy in question was ambiguous and did not preclude coverage for hurricane losses due to wind damage that happened in sequence with water damage.

Team and Contacts