Article Type: Publications

  • Responsible Retailization, Round One: Key Takeaways from the SEC’s Proposals to Expand Regulated Fund Access to Private Markets

    On September 30, 2026, the Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”) published a series of proposals and related notices designed to expand access for individual investors to private markets. If adopted, the proposals would: (i) relax restrictions on performance-based compensation in regulated funds (including business development companies (“BDCs”)) and certain private funds; (ii) modernize interval fund rules; (iii) enhance multiple share class flexibility for unlisted regulated closed-end funds (including BDCs); and (iv) introduce additional credential-based pathways to accredited investor status.[1] The proposals are not final rules; they remain subject to public comment and potential revision before adoption.

    These proposals advance what SEC Chair Paul Atkins has called the “responsible retailization” of private markets by expanding investment choices for individuals across distribution channels while also preserving core investor protections. Taken together, the proposals are a thoughtful, constructive advancement within the larger, ongoing effort to expand access to private markets through regulated vehicles. The SEC and its staff (the “Staff”) should be commended for their efforts and consideration on this topic. We believe it is important, however, that these proposals be the beginning of—and not the endpoint for—the SEC’s agenda on this topic. There remains significant opportunity to comment on and strengthen the newly released proposals and to help the SEC develop a roadmap toward true “responsible retailization,” especially with respect to the accredited investor proposals, which largely overlook the fact that most individual investors access private markets through funds.

    This memorandum summarizes the proposals and highlights key takeaways.

    I. Investment Adviser Performance-Based Compensation Expansion

    Proposed Amendments

    The SEC proposes to amend Rule 205-3 under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, as amended (the “Advisers Act”), to expand the circumstances in which advisers may receive performance-based compensation on capital gains and/or capital appreciation. The proposal includes two main components. First, the proposal would allow advisers to receive compensation from regulated funds (including BDCs) based on net realized and unrealized capital gains and/or capital appreciation (which is otherwise prohibited by the Advisers Act for regulated funds that do not limit their investors to qualified clients) regardless of investor wealth, provided that the following conditions are met:

    • Performance fees limited to 20% of the regulated fund’s net capital gains or net capital appreciation over a specified period or as of definite dates;
    • Satisfaction by the regulated fund of the governance standards in Rule 0-1(a)(7) under the Investment Company Act of 1940, as amended (the “1940 Act”); and
    • Determination by the board, including a majority of independent directors, that the performance-based compensation arrangement is in the best interest of the fund and its shareholders, which must be supported by written findings regarding, among other matters, the fund’s strategy and valuation practices, the fee calculation methodology and measurement period, the treatment of realized and unrealized gains, and investor protections such as hurdles, high-water marks, or loss carryforwards.

    Second, the proposal would amend Rule 205-3 to expand the “qualified client” definition by (i) replacing the net worth and assets-under-management tests with the “accredited investor” (as defined in Regulation D) test for natural persons and companies; (ii) including regulated funds that satisfy the three conditions discussed above; and (iii) removing the existing look-through provision and embedding a similar provision directly into the definition. As a result, the expanded definition of “qualified client” would include:

    1. Natural persons or companies that are accredited investors;
    2. Regulated funds whose equity owners are accredited investors;
    3. Regulated funds that satisfy the conditions discussed above; and
    4. Section 3(c)(1) private funds, provided that each equity owner that is charged performance-based compensation based on capital gains and/or capital appreciation is an accredited investor.

    The proposal also would require applicable funds to provide more particularized prospectus disclosure in their fee tables and management discussions about any performance-based compensation paid to the investment adviser.

    Takeaways and Potential Impact

    The proposed amendments represent a necessary and helpful step by the SEC toward allowing fund sponsors to expand their investor base to individual investors while aligning the incentives typically seen in hedge funds and other private funds with the guardrails provided by the 1940 Act. The extent to which these changes will impact investment products depends on the type of product. Taken together with the interval fund and multi-class proposals discussed below, the performance fee and qualified client proposals could materially expand the range of regulated closed-end fund products that sponsors can offer to a broader investor base. The immediate practical benefit is not limited to fully “point-and-click” distribution of interval funds that calculate net asset value (“NAV”) daily. Funds that conduct monthly NAV calculations could become more attractive access vehicles for individual investors if sponsors can take advantage of more flexible repurchase mechanics, multi-class distribution structures, and performance fee economics. For funds that are also able to calculate NAV daily and satisfy the proposed conditions, the opportunity could extend further by supporting more platform-friendly distribution through broker-dealers, investment advisers, and other intermediary channels. These changes would allow advisers to pursue performance fee strategies for a broader investor base without limiting eligible investors to the current rule’s qualified client wealth thresholds.

    For BDCs, the ability to calculate performance-based compensation on net realized and unrealized capital gains and/or capital appreciation also would represent a meaningful expansion of the current statutory exception, which generally permits performance fees only on realized capital gains, net of realized capital losses and unrealized capital depreciation. This would be particularly impactful for BDCs that invest in venture capital or other equity-type investments, where unrealized gains can be substantial. Allowing performance-based compensation to include unrealized gains may better align the adviser’s compensation with the actual economic experience of BDC shareholders. For Section 3(c)(1) private funds, the proposed amendments would permit an adviser to charge performance fees to investors who qualify as accredited investors, rather than limiting eligibility to investors who satisfy the higher qualified client thresholds.

    On the other hand, Section 3(c)(7) private funds generally would be unaffected because qualified purchasers can already enter into these performance fee arrangements under the Advisers Act. For real estate investment trusts (“REITs”), operating companies, and other non-traded, non-Section 3(c)(7) products that sell shares to accredited investors, the proposed qualified client amendments generally would have no impact because these vehicles are treated as the adviser’s “client” under the Advisers Act, without looking through to the qualified client status of their investors. Any accredited investor limitations on these vehicles derive from their private offering exemptions under Regulation D, which the proposal would not change.

    A regulated fund that does not currently pay an incentive fee would need shareholder approval to amend its advisory agreement to include such a fee before relying on the proposed relief. As such, this proposal may be difficult to implement for existing funds whose advisers do not currently receive performance-based compensation, given the challenging nature of regulated fund proxy solicitations (itself an important area for the SEC and the Staff to take on, in our view). For funds that currently pay performance-based compensation by limiting their investors to qualified clients, no shareholder vote would be required to continue paying performance fees while relying on the amended rule to broaden the fund’s investor base. We expect most existing performance-based compensation arrangements to meet the 20% cap without necessitating any revisions. Such an existing fund would be able to take advantage of the broader investor channel created by the proposal, assuming it can meet the conditions under the amended rule, including the best interest board finding. In contrast, fund sponsors looking to launch a new regulated fund may wish to consider adopting a performance-based fee that would come into effect if the amendments are adopted largely as proposed.

    The board approval condition is best understood as a targeted addition within the existing Section 15(c) advisory contract review process under the 1940 Act, rather than a material overhaul of that process. The practical change is that the board would be required to make specific written findings regarding the performance fee arrangement, in addition to considering the adviser’s overall compensation. Those findings would address, among other matters, the fund’s strategy and valuation practices, the fee calculation methodology and measurement period, the treatment of realized and unrealized gains, and investor protection features such as hurdles, high-water marks, and loss carryforwards. Essentially, there would need to be an additional process around board approval of such performance fees and explicit documentation of the board’s findings.

    II. Interval Fund Modernization

    Proposed Amendments

    The SEC is proposing amendments to Rule 23c-3 under the 1940 Act that would give interval funds greater flexibility in the repurchase offer process and replace certain prescriptive liquidity requirements with a principles-based framework. The proposal would also expand distribution financing options and permit greater flexibility around investor liquidity. Together, these changes could make the interval fund structure more useful for private market exposure, including funds that seek exposure to asset classes such as venture and growth, while preserving periodic liquidity. The chart below summarizes the key proposed changes.

     

    Current Requirement

    Proposed Amendment

     

    Liquidity Requirement for Repurchase Offers

    Interval funds must hold, between the repurchase notification and pricing date, at least 100% of the repurchase offer amount in assets that can be sold or disposed of in the ordinary course at approximately their stated value.

    Principles-based requirement that the fund manage portfolio liquidity so it can satisfy repurchase requests without selling investments at a price that deviates significantly from value. A fund could use layered sources of liquidity, including investor inflows, portfolio cash flows, cash or short-term investments, and a credit facility as a backup, as appropriate.

     

    Initial Repurchase Offer

    Interval funds may defer an initial repurchase offer by two periodic intervals after the later of the effective date of the fund’s registration statement or the date of the shareholder vote adopting the fund’s fundamental policy that specifies the periodic interval.

    Interval funds could defer an initial repurchase offer for up to two years after the later of the effective date of the fund’s registration statement or the date of the first shareholder vote adopting the fund’s fundamental policy that specifies the periodic interval.

     

    Frequency of Repurchase Offers

    Interval funds are permitted to repurchase shares of common stock at intervals of three, six, or twelve months, or, with exemptive relief, on a monthly basis.

    Interval funds would be permitted to repurchase shares of common stock at intervals of one, three, six, or twelve months (without the need to obtain exemptive relief).

     

    Discretionary Repurchases

    Regulated closed-end funds may only offer a discretionary repurchase once every two years.

    Regulated closed-end funds would be able to offer a discretionary repurchase once every year.

     

    Deferred Sales Loads

    Interval funds may deduct from repurchase proceeds only a repurchase fee of up to 2%, payable to the fund to cover repurchase-related expenses. Deferred sales loads (including early withdrawal charges) are permitted only under individual exemptive orders.

    In addition to a repurchase fee of up to 2%, any interval fund, including single-class funds, may deduct a deferred sales load from repurchase proceeds, subject to the same conditions that apply to open-end funds. This would put interval funds on the same footing as open-end funds, allowing them to use deferred sales loads to finance distribution without exemptive relief.

     

    Notification of Repurchase Offer

    Interval funds must send notification to shareholders no less than twenty-one days and no more than forty-two days before the repurchase request deadline.

    Interval funds would be permitted to send notification to shareholders no less than fourteen days and no more than forty-two days before the repurchase request deadline.

     


    Takeaways and Potential Impact

    Liquidity Requirements: Less Cash Drag, More Usable Liquidity

    We view this as the most meaningful part of the interval fund modernization proposal, as this change would address a significant impediment to broader adoption of the interval fund wrapper. Currently, fund sponsors must navigate the rigid requirement to maintain liquid assets equal to 100% of the repurchase offer amount during the repurchase offer period. For example, the current rule does not allow an interval fund to count amounts that can be readily drawn from a credit facility toward meeting this requirement. That restriction pushes funds to invest in ways that may not be the most beneficial from a portfolio management perspective solely to meet this overly prescriptive requirement. This existing requirement creates a barrier to entry for funds that wish to operate as interval funds but may be concerned about complying with this strict requirement given their substantial exposure to private, illiquid assets.

    The proposal would replace that prescriptive test with a principles-based standard focused on whether the fund can meet repurchase requests without selling portfolio investments at a price that deviates significantly from value. The proposed framework would permit a multi-faceted liquidity strategy using, for example, investor inflows, portfolio cash flows, targeted asset sales, and (most notably) a committed bank facility to bridge remaining cash flow needs. This flexibility supports strategies based on less-liquid holdings (although any borrowing would remain subject to the applicable asset coverage and leverage limits under Section 18 of the 1940 Act). This is a welcome development that could support innovative strategies within the interval fund wrapper.

    Initial Repurchase Offer: Longer Runway to Ramp Up the Portfolio

    Allowing a fund to defer its initial repurchase offer for up to two years would give managers more time and flexibility to build durable portfolios whose liquidity characteristics match the fund’s periodic repurchase obligations once those obligations begin. This reflects a more commercially grounded understanding of a fund’s ramp-up needs toward its investment objective(s) and strategies and could better align portfolio construction and portfolio seasoning with the fund’s intended liquidity profile. Otherwise, funds may need to forgo potentially beneficial investment opportunities in order to maintain cash to meet periodic repurchases that must begin within the current two-period timeframe. Additional time before the periodic repurchase process begins could encourage fund sponsors with alternative investment strategies to consider an interval fund as a potential wrapper for product development. Retail investors in interval funds receive disclosure about the timing of repurchase offers, so they are already on notice that such an investment is not readily redeemable and should be considered illiquid.

    Frequency of Repurchase Offers: Increased Options for Sponsors

    The proposal would permit monthly repurchase intervals without individual exemptive relief, giving funds whose strategies support more frequent liquidity an additional product design and distribution option. Related changes to notice and payment timing would facilitate more frequent repurchase cycles, while additional disclosure would inform investors about prior oversubscribed offers. If the proposal is adopted, an existing fund with a quarterly repurchase interval would need to obtain shareholder approval before changing from a quarterly to a monthly frequency. While more evolutionary than transformative, these changes would have the effect of expediting the fund launch process, as a fund that wishes to conduct monthly repurchases would no longer need to go through the time-intensive exemptive relief application process.

    Missed Opportunity: Failure to Encourage Greater Long-Term Investment

    The proposal would not change the repurchase fee cap under the rule, which would remain at 2% of an investor’s repurchase proceeds. Other global jurisdictions permit repurchase fees that commonly exceed 2% in order to incentivize long-term investment in the fund, which benefits all shareholders. We believe retail investors would benefit if interval funds had greater flexibility to charge repurchase fees in excess of 2% to encourage long-term investment.

    III. Expansion of Multiple Share Class Offerings to Unlisted Regulated Closed‑End Funds

    Proposed Amendments

    The SEC is proposing amendments to Rule 18f-3 and Rule 17d-3 under the 1940 Act that would permit regulated closed-end funds (including interval funds, tender offer funds, and BDCs) to issue multiple share classes without first obtaining individual exemptive relief, subject to specified conditions. The proposal would codify conditions reflected in now-routine exemptive orders and provide related relief for certain distribution arrangements involving affiliates or underwriters. This could reduce the cost and delay associated with the exemptive application process while allowing funds to tailor distribution and servicing arrangements to different intermediary channels. The proposal would be limited to unlisted, continuously offered regulated closed-end funds; other types of funds would still need to seek individual exemptive relief.

    The proposed multi-class framework would not retain a condition found in existing exemptive orders that requires sales and service charges to comply with Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, Inc. (“FINRA”) Rule 2341 for registered closed-end funds or FINRA Rule 2310 for BDCs. Accordingly, a privately offered, multi-class BDC that is not independently subject to Rule 2310 may no longer need to comply with the rule’s sales load limitations solely as a condition of relying on the proposed amendments. The change would affect only that exemptive relief condition; other applicable FINRA rules and federal or state securities law requirements would continue to apply depending on the fund’s offering, activities, and distribution arrangements.

    The SEC is also proposing updates to Forms N-2 and N-CEN to provide more tailored disclosure regarding multiple share classes, sales loads, and distribution or service fees. These disclosure requirements would complement the proposed structural flexibility and help investors compare class-level economics.

    Takeaways and Potential Impact

    The proposed multi-class framework could allow a single unlisted closed-end fund to tailor distribution financing and fee structures to different intermediary platforms, rather than limiting the fund to channels compatible with a single class. That flexibility could broaden distribution, expand investor choice, and permit fixed costs to be spread across a larger asset base. It could also make unlisted closed-end funds more adaptable to platforms that use different compensation models. Previously, this could be accomplished only with the added time and expense of applying for individual exemptive relief. Additionally, the SEC’s decision to eliminate the condition in existing exemptive orders that requires sales and service charges to comply with FINRA Rule 2341 or FINRA Rule 2310, as applicable, even where the fund would not otherwise be subject to those FINRA rules, would increase a privately offered regulated fund’s ability to tailor its share classes and reduce ongoing, burdensome administrative monitoring. Similar to the monthly repurchase offer proposal, this proposal reflects a logical development in this space rather than a transformative approach to fund formation. Nevertheless, codifying this relief would provide more certainty as to the ability of regulated closed-end funds to issue multiple classes in the future, as a rule would be more difficult to reverse than a change in the Staff’s position on individual exemptive relief. Moving away from individual exemptive relief also would reduce costs for the SEC and fund sponsors and allow the Staff to devote its resources to other priorities, thereby eliminating a deadweight loss to the economy.

    The proposed multi-class framework would continue to require that a closed-end fund’s common stock not be listed, offered, or traded on a secondary market. This represents a significant gap in the SEC’s proposal, and the SEC has specifically requested comment on this point. To the extent a closed-end fund seeks to offer a multiple share class arrangement in which some share classes are listed on an exchange or otherwise traded on a secondary market, such fund would still need to request relief through the exemptive application process. The proposal specifically notes that it would not rescind exemptive relief recently provided to ARK Venture Fund (“ARK”),[2] which permits, under certain conditions, a multiple-class regulated closed-end fund to list classes of its common stock on an exchange and trade on a secondary market using distributed ledger technology. The proposal notes that under the amended rules, other sponsors seeking listed or tokenized classes would still need individual relief. If these rules are adopted as proposed, the issuance of class-based exemptive relief to tokenized funds to align the conditions of those exemptive orders with the provisions of the new rule could be a mechanism to ensure that tokenized share class structures are not disadvantaged.

    IV. Potential Expansion of “Accredited Investor” Designations

    Proposed Amendments

    In addition to the proposed rulemakings, the SEC issued notices seeking public comment on whether to recognize additional professional credentials as a basis for more natural persons to qualify as “accredited investors,” including U.S. Certified Public Accountant licenses, Chartered Financial Analyst designations, Certified Financial Planner certifications, FINRA Investment Banking Representative licenses (Series 79), and FINRA Research Analyst licenses (Series 86 and Series 87). The SEC is also considering whether passage of a multiple-choice exam developed by FINRA should qualify an individual as an accredited investor for ten years (after which the individual would need to retake and pass the exam).

    Takeaways and Potential Impact

    In our view, the notices represent a missed opportunity insofar as they only contemplate direct investments in private securities. They overlook the fact that an increasing number of individuals access private markets through regulated funds selected with assistance from a registered investment adviser or broker-dealer. Although some credential holders may benefit, the notices do little to advance “responsible retailization” for the large population of investors who work with financial advisers.

    We believe the SEC should establish an additional accredited investor category for a natural person whose fund investment is recommended, directed, or approved by a registered investment adviser acting under its fiduciary duty or a registered broker-dealer acting under the Regulation Best Interest standard (“Reg BI”) where the investment is made in a fund that has filed a registration statement under the 1940 Act or the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended (the “Exchange Act”). An adviser’s fiduciary duty of care and a broker-dealer’s Reg BI care obligation require an intermediary to understand an investment’s risks, assess the investor’s financial circumstances, liquidity needs, and risk tolerance, and reasonably conclude that the investment is in the investor’s best interest. Investing through a fund also provides structural protections not present in a direct investment in a single private issuer. A direct investment may involve concentrated risk, indefinite illiquidity, and limited information. By contrast, a fund offers a managed, diversified pool; redemption rights or periodic repurchases at NAV; and public SEC filings describing fees, holdings, performance, and risks. These features do not eliminate risk, but they materially reduce concerns about concentration, illiquidity, and information asymmetry.

    The SEC could adopt this additional category without limiting anti-fraud remedies or intermediary conduct obligations. It would complement the qualified client, interval fund, and multi-class proposals discussed above, all of which seek to make funds more effective vehicles for private-market exposure. We encourage market participants to use the comment process to urge the SEC to look beyond individual credentials and recognize the professional advice and fund structures through which most individuals access private markets.

    V. Private Equity Buyouts: On the Outside Looking In

    We believe that this work needs to continue to achieve true democratized access to all areas of the private markets, and we expect to participate in the broader consideration of other steps that may further the worthy goals of these recent SEC actions. At the top of the list of steps that need to be considered to further the goal of “responsible retailization” across asset classes and investment strategies is a reassessment and modernization of the current restrictions on affiliated transactions with regulated funds. While the 1940 Act guardrails on affiliated transactions play an important investor protection role, modernizing the prohibitions on joint transactions, and on principal transactions with affiliated persons, including the treatment of portfolio companies controlled by a sponsor’s private funds as affiliated persons of the sponsor’s regulated funds, is a necessary component of responsible retailization. Because a private equity buyout strategy typically involves acquiring control positions alongside the sponsor’s private funds and engaging in follow-on, add-on, and exit transactions involving those controlled companies, these restrictions, even as joint transaction restrictions were relaxed by co-investment exemptive relief, make it difficult for a regulated fund to pursue a private equity buyout strategy on the same terms as the sponsor’s private funds, leaving retail investors, who generally can access private markets only through regulated funds, on the outside looking in. We applaud the SEC’s recognition of the positive role that exposure to private markets can play in a retail investor’s portfolio, especially with respect to the proposals issued by the Division of Investment Management, and look forward to further developments in furtherance of true democratized access to private markets.

    VI. Next Steps

    Each proposal and related notice has been published in the Federal Register, and the comment periods are now open.[3] The SEC has requested comment on the full range of proposed approaches, and the proposals may be revised before any final rules are adopted. Based on the pace of recent SEC rulemaking initiatives under Chair Atkins, final rules could be adopted as early as the second quarter of 2027, though the ultimate timeline will depend on the volume and nature of public comments received, competing SEC priorities, and other rulemaking variables. We welcome the opportunity to participate in the comment process and to work with industry participants toward the goal of expanding individual access to private markets.


     

    [1] See Investment Adviser Performance-Based Compensation Modernization, Release Nos. 33-11443, 34-106533, IA-7022, IC-36350 (Sept. 30, 2026) [91 FR 63676 (October 6, 2026)], available here; Interval Fund Modernization; Expansion of Multiple Share Class to Registered Closed-End Management Investment Companies and Business Development Companies, Release Nos. 33-11444, 34-106534, IC-36351 (September  30, 2026) [91 FR 63388 (October 5, 2026)], available here; Potential Designation of Chartered Financial Analyst Designation as Qualifying Natural Persons for Accredited Investor Status, Release No. 33-11447 (September 30, 2026) [91 FR 63314 (October 5, 2026)], available here; Potential Designation of Passage of an Accredited Investor Exam To Be Developed by FINRA as Qualifying Natural Persons for Accredited Investor Status, Release No. 33-11445 (September 30, 2026) [91 FR 63335 (October 5, 2026)], available here; Potential Designation of Certified Financial Planner Certification as Qualifying Natural Persons for Accredited Investor Status, Release No. 33-11448 (September 30, 2026) [91 FR 63345 (October 5, 2026)], available here; Potential Designation of U.S. Certified Public Accountant License as Qualifying Natural Persons for Accredited Investor Status, Release No. 33-11446 (September 30, 2026) [91 FR 63368 (October 5, 2026)], available here; Potential Designations of the Investment Banking Representative License (Series 79) and the Research Analyst License (Series 86 and Series 87) as Qualifying Natural Persons for Accredited Investor Status, Release No. 33-11449 (Sept. 30, 2026) [91 FR 63357 (October 5, 2026)], available here.

    [2] See In the Matter of ARK Venture Fund and ARK Investment Management LLC, Investment Company Act Release No. 36308 (Aug. 24, 2026) (notice); Investment Company Act Release No. 36333 (Sept. 21, 2026) (order).

    [3] See supra note 1. The comment period for the “Interval Fund Modernization; Expansion of Multiple Share Class to Registered Closed-End Management Investment Companies and Business Development Companies” proposal and the expansion of “accredited investor” designations notices will close on December 4, 2026. The comment period for the “Investment Adviser Performance-Based Compensation Modernization” proposal will close on December 7, 2026.

  • Simpson Thacher Attorneys Author Article on SEC Examinations Targeting Interval Funds and BDCs

    Partners Justin Browder and Anne Choe, and Associate Anna Goodnight authored an article titled, “Recent SEC Examinations Target Interval Funds and Business Development Companies,” which was published by The Investment Lawyer. The article discussed a recent SEC examination initiative focused on interval funds and BDCs. The article outlined the primary topics included in SEC examination requests and provided an analysis of key substantive themes that have emerged, in addition to discussing how regulated fund sponsors should treat the themes as a roadmap for self-assessment and take proactive steps to enhance compliance structures accordingly.

    To read the full article, please click here.

  • Treasury Announces First Enforcement Penalty for Violation of the Outbound Investment Security Program

    On October 7, 2026, the U.S. Department of the Treasury (“Treasury”) announced that it had, in July 2026, issued its first civil enforcement penalty under the Outbound Investment Security Program, often referred to as the Outbound Investment Rule (the “OIR”). Treasury levied a $200,000 penalty against Amidi, LLC (“Amidi”) for failing to submit a required notification of an investment by its controlled foreign entity into a “Chinese embodied artificial intelligence company.” Specifically, on April 19, 2025, Amidi’s subsidiary—a Chinese fund—invested approximately $92,478 into Shanghai Qiongche Intelligent Technology Company Limited (“Noematrix”), a private Chinese company that develops “artificial intelligence, robotics, and embodied intelligence.” Treasury noted in its press release that it identified the transaction as part of its regular and ongoing compliance and market-monitoring efforts.

    The OIR became effective on January 2, 2025, and provides for a targeted national security regulatory framework directed at regulating outbound investment by U.S. persons and, indirectly, entities controlled by U.S. persons, into entities from the People’s Republic of China, Hong Kong, and Macau engaged in certain activities in the semiconductors and microelectronics, quantum information technologies, and artificial intelligence sectors. Codified at 31 C.F.R. § 850.101 et seq., the OIR imposes notification requirements for certain categories of transactions involving such entities and prohibits certain other categories of transactions involving such entities.

    Secretary of the Treasury Scott Bessent stated, “[t]oday’s penalty announcement under the Outbound Investment Security Program underscores Treasury’s commitment to safeguarding U.S. national security through robust investment security measures that preserve America’s technological leadership and advance President Trump’s America First Investment Policy.” Assistant Secretary of the Treasury for Investment Security Christopher Pilkerton further stated that the OIR is “an important tool aimed at addressing the advancement of key technologies by countries of concern that could pose risks to U.S. national security” and that Treasury “will continue to ensure that investors comply with the requirements established under the program.”

    In assessing compliance and determining whether to bring an enforcement action, Treasury has stated that it will evaluate the factual circumstances surrounding the conduct, including the aggravating and mitigating factors outlined in the Outbound Program Enforcement Overview and Guidance (“Guidance”). These factors include the extent to which enforcement action would hold violators accountable and encourage future compliance; the extent to which the offending conduct impaired or threatened to impair U.S. national security; the negligence, intent, or willfulness of any violation, including any efforts to conceal or delay sharing relevant information with Treasury and the seniority of employees who knew or should have known about the conduct; the persistence and timing of the violation; the violator’s response and cooperation with Treasury, any internal reviews conducted, and remediation efforts; and the sophistication and record of compliance, surveyed through company procedures, policies, and training, a culture of and variations in compliance efforts across all levels of the company, company resources dedicated to internal and external legal obligations, and the knowledge of other governmental authorities (foreign, federal, state, local, etc.) on the violator’s compliance efforts with applicable legal regulations. As explained in the Guidance, Treasury considers information from various sources, including requests for information and self-disclosures by potential violators, and encourages the public to submit tips, referrals, or other relevant information on its Outbound Program tips line. Treasury is authorized to pursue the civil penalties for violations available under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (50 U.S.C. 1701 et seq.) (“IEEPA”), with the maximum civil penalty being the greater of $377,700 or twice the value of the transaction that is the basis for the violation. Treasury may also refer criminal violations to the U.S. Attorney General and take action authorized under IEEPA to nullify, void, or otherwise compel the divestment of any prohibited transaction.

    Looking Ahead

    Treasury’s first OIR penalty demonstrates that the agency is actively monitoring the market and is prepared to pursue enforcement even where the underlying investment is modest. For private equity sponsors and other asset managers, this means that OIR diligence should be considered from the earliest stages of deal sourcing and fund structuring, including assessing portfolio company ties to covered jurisdictions and sectors before signing. For M&A practitioners more broadly, the OIR should be viewed as an important regulatory consideration that can materially affect transaction certainty and value. Parties that integrate OIR considerations into the earlier stages of deals and funds work will be best positioned to navigate this evolving landscape.

    Furthermore, investors should continue to remain alert for future expansion of the OIR to avoid inadvertent violations of the program. On December 18, 2025, Congress passed the Comprehensive Outbound Investment National Security Act of 2025 (“COINS Act”), which is poised to expand the OIR’s jurisdiction to additional countries and technology sectors in coming months or years. Until and unless the Treasury issues new regulations, parties should continue to act in full compliance with the OIR.

    Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP is experienced in navigating international regulatory and compliance issues, including with respect to sanctions, export controls, and foreign investment, and continues to follow developments of the OIR closely. We are available to discuss further questions on request.



    To read Treasury’s Press Release, please click here.

  • SEC Watch: Monthly Takeaways for Asset Managers – October 2026

    New Exam Handbook from the Division of Examinations

    Summary: On October 1, the Division of Examinations announced a new handbook, “The SEC Exam Handbook: A Practical Guide on Process and Engagement.” The Handbook replaced the existing EXAMS Brochure, and in a speech on September 16, Director of Examinations Keith Cassidy described the then-impending Handbook as a “modern and expanded replacement.” The new Handbook largely aligns with the Brochure that it replaces, but adds additional content that aligns with the Director’s goal to ensure the Division is “accessible and integrated” and guided by the “Golden Rule”: “we should treat others as we would like to be treated.” For example, the new Handbook includes a chart titled “Working Together” that outlines “[w]hat registrants can expect from EXAMS” and “[w]hat EXAMS expects from registrants.” The chart calls on both parties to be “courteous” and “professional.” 

    • In his speech, the Director pointed to publishing annual priorities and risk alerts, holding outreach events and gathering feedback from industry groups, and ensuring that Division staff participate in “regular knowledge exchange sessions” with other SEC divisions like Trading and Markets and Investment Management as ways that the Division was abiding by the Golden Rule. In advice to registrants, the Director encouraged firms to “be responsive, be prepared, and be professional” and put an emphasis on a firm’s ability to “confidently walk us through their procedures and have real familiarity with compliance requirements.” He further encouraged open and courteous communication throughout the exam and noted that “approaching the process with an unnecessary adversarial mindset can make an already complex process more difficult for everyone involved.”

    Takeaway: The theme of the Director’s speech and the release of the new handbook is, in the Director’s words, “answering the call from registrants to provide more clarity to the exam process.” By answering the call, the Division will expect that registrants have reviewed and understood its priorities and processes, and will likely have less patience for complaints aimed at opaque exam procedures. 

    Best Practice Tip: Review and digest the new SEC Exam Handbook and consider calibrating existing policies and procedures relating to exams to align with the Division’s guidance. Just as guidance in the Enforcement Manual can provide a hook for constructive engagement with the Staff in the investigative setting, the updated Exam Handbook can be a similar hook for raising questions or concerns with the Exam Staff.

    Enforcement Director Outlines Updates and Priorities for Enforcement

    Summary: On September 18, Director of Enforcement David Woodcock made a speech outlining the Division’s priorities and providing a message to defense counsel aimed at “Removing Roadblocks to Efficient Enforcement.” The Director emphasized that the Division has been “prioritizing back to basics cases – cases focusing on conduct that harms investors, holding individual wrongdoers accountable, and pursuing opportunities to return money to harmed investors,” and named fraud, insider trading, accounting fraud, compliance failures, and investment adviser conflicts and misrepresentation as priority areas. He touted a “visible” Enforcement Division and highlighted new initiatives like the Financial Reporting and Accounting Unit, Retail Fraud Working Group, new Office of Artificial Intelligence & Analytics, and coordination efforts with the FDA, CFTC, PCAOB, and U.S. Attorneys’ Offices.

    • In remarks directed to defense counsel, the Director warned that the Staff is paying close attention to Form 8-Ks, the news, and other sources and emphasized that “it’s better if you come to us first, because you will get a call from us.” In terms of investigation mechanics, the Director noted that he has directed Staff to take testimony before document productions are complete in appropriate cases, and noted that “[t]his is not a negotiable concept” but rather “a procedural tool we will use.” Underscoring the point on efficiency, the Director noted that “we will move matters forward – with or without delay attempts from counsel,” and noted that the Staff will file subpoena enforcement actions “sooner, rather than waiting years to obtain subpoenaed documents and testimony.”  Finally, the Director clarified that a meeting with a Deputy Director is a meeting with the Front Office, and that “meeting with them satisfies any request to elevate concerns.” 

    Takeaway: The Director’s speech aligns with the increased enforcement activity we have been seeing over the past several months and charts a clear path for the Division moving forward. The emphasis on quickly and efficiently moving cases forward is particularly noteworthy, and the Director’s warning about subpoena enforcement actions should not be considered an empty threat, as we noted last month.

    Best Practice Tip: The Director’s remarks make clear that the Enforcement Division is back to work, including with a list of priorities that include investment adviser conflicts and misrepresentations. As to the stated intent to seek testimony before the production of documents, advisers subject to investigative scrutiny should be cautious about subjecting witnesses to potentially hostile questioning before doing the work necessary to understand the full record that will eventually be produced. 

    New Retailization Proposals Impacting Asset Managers

    Summary: On September 30, the Commission announced proposed rule amendments that would expand the ability of registered investment advisers to receive performance-based compensation from certain clients, including clients that are “accredited investors” as defined under Rule 501(a) of Regulation D, and clients that are regulated funds (e.g., mutual funds, closed-end funds, and business development companies), provided that either (A) all of the investors in the regulated fund are “accredited investors”; or (B) (i) the compensation does not exceed 20% of the fund’s net capital gains or net capital appreciation in a specified period, (ii) the fund’s board satisfies the fund governance standards of Rule 0-1(a)(7) under the Investment Company Act, and (iii) the fund’s board finds the arrangement is in the best interests of the fund and shareholders.

    • The announcement came alongside continued efforts to expand the “accredited investor” definition under Rule 501(a) of Reg D. The Commission now seeks public comment on a proposal to allow individual investors to qualify as accredited investors through a showing of good standing in certain professional certifications, designations, or credentials. Specifically, the proposal would allow those with a CPA license, a CFA charter, a CFP certification, or Series 79, 86, or 87 licenses issued by FINRA, to qualify as accredited investors.

    Takeaway: These proposals have the potential to materially expand retail access to private market strategies historically limited to a narrow group of investors, reflecting Chairman Atkins’ commitment to “facilitate the ability of individual investors to participate in private markets,” as noted in his statement. The proposals are also consistent with the Commission’s stated priorities of deregulation and expansion of private markets for retail investors.  

    Best Practice Tip: The comment period for both proposals is sixty days, and asset managers seeking to submit a comment letter should act quickly. Keep an eye on SEC Watch for any noteworthy developments.

    Additional Things To Know

    Innovation Exemption: On September 17, the Commission issued the long anticipated Innovation Exemption. The SEC’s order provides temporary, conditional exemptive relief to entities known as “Tokenized Securities Venues” (“TSVs”) and permits trading in tokenized interests in NMS stock using permissioned automated market makers and liquidity pools. The exemption is subject to a number of conditions and limitations designed to ensure TSVs are operated in a manner that is consistent with the Commission’s commitment to investor protection. As of this writing, at least one TSV has launched and appears ready to commence trading on or prior to November 1, 2026. Market participants that are interested in transacting via TSVs should closely familiarize themselves with the risks associated with such venues before trading. The Commission is simultaneously soliciting comment on the exemption.

    Valuation of Private Assets: On September 28, the SEC’s Office of the Chief Accountant and the Division of Investment Management jointly released a “reminder” addressing fair value measurements and disclosure considerations for private assets held by registered funds, business development companies, and other similar registrants. The “reminder” focuses on private credit valuation practices. Advisers to regulated funds should consider benchmarking their valuation processes and investor-facing disclosures against this guidance. See the full Simpson Thacher analysis here.

    Proposed Modernization of the Custody Rules
    : On October 1, relying in part on a no-action relief previously obtained by Simpson Thacher, the Commission announced proposed new rules and amendments that would provide a tailored framework for the custody of crypto assets for registered investment advisers and regulated funds. In particular, the framework would allow advisers and regulated funds to self-custody crypto assets in certain circumstances. The proposal also modernizes the custody rules by formalizing certain prior SEC no-action letters and staff guidance, as well as better addressing current industry practices.

    Commissioner Peirce Departs: Effective October 2, Hester Peirce resigned as Commissioner after a tenure of 15+ years at the Commission. This leaves a two-seat, one-party Commission of Chairman Atkins and Commissioner Uyeda, with newly-released guidance allowing for the possibility of Commission action with a quorum of just one Commissioner.

    Prepared by Your Simpson Thacher Asset Management Regulatory and Enforcement Team»

  • The Ad Standard: Monthly Update – October 2026

    Affordability remains front and center at the FTC. This month, the agency turned its attention to healthcare and gas costs. It also issued detailed guidance on price transparency for auto dealers that marketers in any industry might want to heed: the advertised price “must be the actual price that any consumer can walk in and pay,” with only government fees excluded. The FTC continues to consider how to combat scams and is seeking public comment on whether online platforms should help stop scammers who use those platforms to impersonate third parties by, for example, requiring the removal of confirmed impersonation scam ads.

    A wave of class actions has been filed alleging “zero sugar” claims are false, following from a Seventh Circuit decision in which the FDA, at the court’s request, explained that although it had announced it would exercise enforcement discretion on whether allulose must be counted as a sugar on product labels, allulose does in fact meet its definition of a “sugar.” The takeaway: an agency’s promised enforcement discretion is no shield from lawsuits alleging that a claim is, nonetheless, misleading.

    At NAD, “#1” and market-leadership claims remain a magnet for competitor challenges. And with consumers keeping a close eye on their wallets, it is no surprise that NAD is seeing more challenges to pricing claims in industries beyond telecom.

    FTC Focus

    FTC Enforcement Activity

    1. The FTC, joined by Utah and Nevada, sued contact lens retailer Lens.com Inc., its owner, and an affiliated entity, Speed Commerce LLC, alleging the company advertised low prices for contact lenses but then charged consumers higher prices through mandatory “Taxes & fees” charges without clear and conspicuous disclosure to consumers. The joint action alleges that defendants violated the FTC Act, ROSCA, and the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act, among other statutes. Christopher Mufarrige, Director of the FTC’s Bureau of Consumer Protection, noted that the joint action underscores the agency’s commitment to lowering healthcare costs for consumers by stopping deceptive business practices that raise prices and harm Americans. According to the complaint, Lens.com also uses deceptive pricing practices in connection with its “AutoRefill” subscription plan, which is a negative-option plan that obscures the total price, automatically charges consumers for recurring shipments of contact lenses, and prevents comparison shopping. Lens.com also allegedly fails to clearly and conspicuously disclose how to cancel the AutoRefill subscription and the cancellation deadline to avoid incurring charges for a future shipment.

      FTC, States Sue Lens.com for Misrepresenting the Price of Contact Lenses in Search Ads and on Its Website | Federal Trade Commission
    1. Under a proposed order, marking the largest monetary recovery obtained in an FTC action against a multilevel marketing company, Amway Corp. and two of its affiliates will pay $225 million to resolve FTC and state of Washington allegations that they used unfair and deceptive tactics to recruit individuals to its direct selling and multilevel marketing opportunity. The companies allegedly recruit individuals as salespeople to sell consumer products with misrepresentations about likely earnings (e., by replacing their full-time job or retiring early), pressure recruits to buy Amway products that are difficult to sell, and instruct them to falsely report sales that they did not, in fact, make, to create the appearance that the opportunity revolves around selling products rather than attempting to recruit new salespeople to purchase Amway products. The two Amway affiliates allegedly recruit individuals to join Amway and sell them “essential” training materials and services.

      FTC Takes Historic Action Against Multilevel Marketing Operator Amway for Unfair and Deceptive Business Practices | Federal Trade Commission
    1. FleetCor Technologies Inc., now known as Corpay Inc., and its CEO will pay $100 million to settle FTC allegations that the company imposed unauthorized fees on tens of thousands of customers, mainly small businesses, in connection with their use of fuel cards it falsely promised would save them money. FleetCor additionally charged late fees to customers who had either paid on time or were prevented by FleetCor from paying on time and further misrepresented the gas savings, fraud-control features, and fees associated with the fuel cards. According to the complaint, FleetCor waited several billing cycles before charging many fees, making the fees less noticeable to consumers. It also used invoices that did not disclose any fees, requiring customers to proactively view other account management reports, which in turn obscured many fees or did not list them at all.

      FleetCor Agrees to Pay $100 Million to Resolve Administrative Action After Federal Court Finds that It Violated the FTC Act by Charging Unauthorized Fees | Federal Trade Commission

    FTC Activity on Impersonation Scams

    1. The FTC is seeking public comment on whether to update its Rule on Impersonation of Government and Businesses or take other action to prevent online platforms from engaging in ad-optimization practices that may be furthering impersonation scams. The Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking notes that impersonation scams have been amplified by search engines, social media, and other digital marketplace platforms that profit from optimizing online ads for third parties, regardless of whether the third parties are legitimate and asks whether platforms should be required to take steps to prevent impersonation ads from reaching consumers.

      FTC Seeks Public Comment on Whether to Update Rule on Impersonation of Government and Businesses to Address Platforms’ Role in Promoting Impersonation Scams | Federal Trade Commission

    FTC Guidance for Auto Dealers on Price Transparency

    1. The Staff of the FTC has published an FAQ on price transparency to help auto dealers comply with the FTC Act, which underlines the importance of price transparency as an FTC enforcement priority. The guidance reiterates that the advertised price of a vehicle must be the actual price that any consumer can pay, excluding only charges that the government requires. The FAQ provides guidance on several topics, including how to handle document fees, rebates, discounts, price negotiations and how to communicate prices transparently across different media. This development follows warning letters sent earlier this year to nearly 100 auto groups concerning price transparency.

      FTC Publishes Price Transparency FAQs for Auto Dealers | Federal Trade Commission

    Class Actions

    Allulose Class Actions

    Trader Joe’s Co. has been sued in two separate putative class actions alleging that it misleads consumers by labeling its No Sugar Added Dark Chocolate Chips as containing “No Added Sugar,” and its Sweet & Sour Gummy Worms Candies as containing “0g sugar per serving” while both products contain allulose, which the complaints assert qualifies as a sugar under federal labeling standards. Both suits assert violations of various state consumer protection statutes, including New York and Illinois, and the Illinois Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Business Practices Act.

    Alexander v. Trader Joe’s Co., No. 1:26-cv-11329 (N.D. Ill. Sept. 16, 2026)

    Parker v. Trader Joe’s Co., No. 1:26-cv-11360 (N.D. Ill. Sept. 16, 2026)

    Magic Spoon Inc. has been sued in a putative class action alleging that it falsely and misleadingly markets the various flavors of its Magic Spoon Protein Cereal, as containing “0g Total Sugars,” “0g Added Sugar” and “No Added Sugar” because they, in fact, contain allulose. Plaintiff asserts violations of various state consumer protection statutes, including New York and Illinois, and the Illinois Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Business Practices Act.

    Royal v. Magic Spoon Inc., No. 1:26-cv-10993 (N.D. Ill. Sept. 10, 2026)

    Haleon US Holdings LLC was sued in a putative class action alleging that it falsely advertises its Emergen-C Zero Sugar Vitamin C Immune Support Gummies as containing “Zero Sugar” because the dietary supplement product, in fact, contains allulose. Plaintiff asserts violations of California’s Consumer Legal Remedies Act, False Advertising Law, and Unfair Competition Law.

    Albrigo v. Haleon US Holdings LLC, No. 3:26-cv-05279 (S.D. Cal. Sept. 13, 2026)

    Conagra Brands, Inc. was sued in a putative class action alleging that it falsely and misleadingly markets its Duncan Hines Keto Friendly baking mixes as containing “0g ADDED SUGAR PER SERVING” because the products, in fact, contain allulose. Plaintiff asserts violations of New York General Business Law Sections 349 and 350 and dozens of state consumer-protection statutes.

    Sanderson v. Conagra Brands, Inc., No. 1:26-cv-11420 (N.D. Ill. Sept. 19, 2026)

    Nature’s Way Products, LLC was sued in a putative class action alleging that it falsely advertises its Nature’s Way Alive! Zero Sugar Women’s Multivitamin Gummy products as “Sugar Free,” when they, in fact, contain allulose. Plaintiff asserts violations of California’s Consumer Legal Remedies Act, False Advertising Law, and Unfair Competition Law.

    Read v. Nature’s Way Prods., LLC, No. 2:26-cv-10580 (C.D. Cal. Sept. 17, 2026)


    “Naturally Flavored” and “No Artificial Flavors” Claims

    Candy company SmartSweets Inc. was sued in a putative class action alleging that it falsely and misleadingly markets various of its candy products as “Naturally Flavored” and containing “No Artificial Flavors” because the products, in fact, contain citric acid that is synthetically derived. Plaintiff asserts violations of New York General Business Law Sections 349 and 350.

    Decker v. SmartSweets Inc., No. 1:26-cv-06009 (E.D.N.Y. Sept. 28, 2026)


    Immunity Boost Claims

    Vive Organic, Inc. was sued in a putative class action alleging that it falsely and misleadingly markets its “Immunity Boost” wellness shot products as having boosting effects on the immune system. The complaint alleges that this is false and unsubstantiated, because no food or dietary supplement can “boost” one’s immune system and that Vive has no medical evidence to substantiate this representation despite its representation that the products are formulated by doctors. Plaintiff asserts violations of New York General Business Law Sections 349 and 350.

    Briceno v. Vive Organic, Inc., No. 1:26-cv-08431 (S.D.N.Y. Sept. 25, 2026)


    Food Safety and Quality Claims

    Berry producer Driscoll’s, Inc. was sued in a putative class action alleging that it represents that its conventional strawberries are produced “subject to rigorous food safety and quality standards” and ran an environmentally friendly campaign that greenwashed its true farming and manufacturing practices, while failing to disclose the presence, risk of, and/or the use of persistent, fluorinated pesticide compounds associated with so-called “forever chemicals” and PFAS-related compounds. Plaintiff asserts violations of New York General Business Law Sections 349 and 350.

    Farley v. Driscoll’s, Inc., No. 2:26-cv-05950 (E.D.N.Y. Sept. 24, 2026)


    Junk Fee Class Actions

    Aftership Inc., which offers shipping-related services to e-commerce retailers, was sued in a putative class action alleging that e-commerce retailers working with Aftership make false pricing representations to consumers (free or flat rate shipping) because the retailers surreptitiously add junk fees to consumers’ purchases, including Aftership’s so-called “Aftership Protection” fee. The complaint alleges that Aftership’s widget automatically adds the fee, which is made to appear mandatory at a late stage of the checkout and forces consumers to take affirmative action to reject the fee. Plaintiff asserts violations of the Maryland Consumer Protection Act.

    Leonard v. Aftership Inc., No. 8:26-cv-03630 (D. Md. Sept. 14, 2026)

    Element Vape was sued in a putative class action alleging that it falsely advertises the price of its retail items, along with an advertisement for either free or paid shipping dependent on the dollar value of items purchased because Element Vape surreptitiously and automatically adds junk fees to consumer purchases on top of the free or paid shipping in the form of a so-called “Route Package Protection Fee.” Plaintiffs assert violations of California’s Consumer Legal Remedies Act, False Advertising Law, and Unfair Competition Law.

    Eck-London v. Element Vape, No. 26ST-cv-30788 (Cal. Super. Ct. Sept. 29, 2026)


    Home Equity Sharing Agreements Class Action

    Unison Agreement Corp. and its affiliates have been sued in a putative class action alleging that their “home equity sharing agreements,” which appear to operate like reverse mortgages, are, in fact, residential mortgage loans and high-cost home loans that “skirt lending and mortgage laws designed to protect consumers and homeowners from usurious terms.” Among other things, the complaint alleges that defendants misrepresent that the financial product is not a loan or a debt, misrepresent that there is no interest, misrepresent their relationship to homeowners, and hide the magnitude of homeowners’ repayment obligations. Plaintiffs assert violations of North Carolina’s Unfair and Deceptive Trade Practices Act.

    Petty v. Unison Agreement Corp., No. 3:26-cv-00749 (W.D.N.C. Sept. 18, 2026)


    “Mini LED” Television Claims

    Samsung Electronics America, Inc., was sued in a putative class action alleging that it falsely advertises its “M Series” televisions as “Mini LED” televisions in their product name, in product photos, and by stating that “many tiny LEDs” deliver “3X brighter highlights,” “2X deeper blacks,” “Mini LED precision,” “exceptional brightness and contrast,” and “Supreme Mini LED Dimming” while the M Series televisions are not in fact Mini LED televisions, do not contain Mini

    LED technology, and cannot deliver the picture quality advertised. Plaintiff asserts violations of California’s Consumer Legal Remedies Act, False Advertising Law, and Unfair Competition Law.

    Flores v. Samsung Electronics Am., Inc., No. 2:26-cv-12502 (D.N.J. Sept. 22, 2026)


    Sleep Tracking Claims

    Oura Inc. and Oura Health OY d/b/a Ouraring Inc. were sued in a putative class action alleging that they falsely represent that their Oura Ring 5, Oura Ring 4, and Oura Ring 4 Ceramic wearable devices had the ability to accurately track the quality and stages of users’ sleep. The complaint alleges that the devices lack sensors that measure brain waves, eye movements, and muscle activity, which track sleep stages. Plaintiff asserts violations of California’s Consumer Legal Remedies Act and Unfair Competition Law and New York General Business Law Section 349.

    Joseph v. Oura Inc., No. 3:26-cv-10801 (N.D. Cal. Sept. 22, 2026)


    Dismissal Denied

    A federal district court denied dismissal of claims in a putative class action alleging that probiotic soda manufacturer Cove Drinks, Inc. falsely represented that its products have “No Artificial Sweeteners” because they contain the synthetic sweetener erythritol. Noting that claims under California’s Consumer Legal Remedies Act, False Advertising Law, and Unfair Competition Law are governed by the “reasonable consumer” standard, the court denied dismissal finding that plaintiff adequately alleged the claims. The court noted that the complaint alleges that the soda purchased contains 10 grams of erythritol and uses it as a sweetener, and further alleges that the erythritol is commercially manufactured through industrial fermentation and multi-step processing, and, therefore, it is a “synthetic sweetener.” The court further rejected Cove’s request for judicial notice of documents from the FDA and the National Cancer Institute that they do not consider erythritol to be an artificial sweetener, stating that “[w]hether erythritol actually is an artificial sweetener is a question of fact that the Court cannot decide at the motion to dismiss stage.”

    Williams v. Cove Drinks, Inc., No. 26-cv-03374, 2026 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 220973 (S.D. Cal. Sept. 28, 2026)

    A federal district court denied dismissal of claims in a putative class action alleging that Kraft Heinz Foods Co. falsely and deceptively labels its Philadelphia Cheesecake Crumble dessert products as containing “No Artificial Preservatives” when they, in fact, contain artificial lactic acid as a preservative. As to the alleged violations of California, Illinois, and Nevada state consumer protection laws, which all require a plaintiff to allege that the ad misleads a “reasonable consumer,” the court concluded that plaintiffs plausibly alleged that lactic acid is “artificial” and that a reasonable person would be misled by the statement “no artificial preservatives” if lactic acid is artificial when created through a manufactured process. The court pointed out that plaintiffs alleged that the lactic acid is produced through a manufactured process that includes two synthetic reactions. The court noted that whether the lactic acid is “artificial,” is a factual determination that is inappropriate to conclusively determine on a motion to dismiss.

    Daly v. Kraft Heinz Foods Co., No. 25-cv-07185, 2026 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 217377 (N.D. Ill. Sept. 24, 2026)


    Dismissal Granted

    A federal district court dismissed a putative class action alleging violations of California’s Unfair Competition Law and False Advertising Law against Google, LLC and Alphabet, which was brought after the plaintiff lost money from a fraudulent third-party app that he downloaded from the Google Play Store and claimed that he relied on Google’s statements that the third-party apps available are “legitimate, safe, and secure” and “can be downloaded with confidence because of Google’s vetting process and security standards.” The court held that plaintiff’s unfair competition and false advertising claims are barred by Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, which provides that, “No provider or user of an interactive computer service shall be treated as the publisher or speaker of any information provided by another information content provider.” The court explained that even where a litigant seeks to hold an interactive computer service liable for its own statements, a general statement of a company’s content moderation policy is not a specific promise, but a mere description of its moderation policy, and thus protected from liability under § 230. The court explained that this is so because where a litigant relies on general statements of content moderation policy rather than specific, enforceable promises, the duty that the litigant seeks to impose on the defendant involves precisely the kind of content moderation regulation that Section 230 protects from liability, noting that plaintiff merely challenged general statements of Google’s content moderation policy rather than specific promises.

    Hemry v. Google, LLC, No. 26-cv-01611, 2026 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 221086 (N.D. Cal. Sept. 28, 2026)

    A federal district court dismissed a putative class action alleging that Hershey’s seasonal Reese’s Peanut Butter Pumpkins are deceptively and misleadingly marketed because plaintiffs believed the plain chocolates would look like the image shown on the front of the packaging, which shows the chocolates with “cool and beautiful carved-out designs” that look like jack o’ lanterns. The court pointed out that the original complaint was dismissed because plaintiffs failed to sufficiently allege a concrete injury, as they failed to allege that the products were defective, worthless, unfit for consumption, did not taste as expected, or were otherwise so flawed as to render them worthless. As to plaintiffs’ new allegations that they purchased the products “for the novelty/party-display value of the depicted faces, not merely for generic chocolate-and-peanut-butter candy,” the court labeled the allegations conclusory. The court found that despite plaintiffs’ subjective expectations, they still failed to allege that the products were defective, worthless, or that they lost all economic value because of the absence of the decorative carvings. The court further noted that the packaging includes the disclaimer—“DECORATING SUGGESTION”—and the product, although not carved, does have a novel pumpkin shape. Stating that plaintiffs’ “only injury is their subjective disappointment,” the court concluded that the allegations were not enough to plausibly allege a concrete injury for purposes of Article III standing.

    Vidal v. The Hershey Co., No. 24-60831, 2026 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 209372 (S.D. Fla. Sept. 16, 2026)

    A federal district court dismissed a putative class action alleging that liquor company Diageo North America, Inc. violated New York General Business Law Sections 349 and 350 and other state consumer protection statutes by falsely representing that both its Casamigos and Don Julio tequilas are “100% de Agave,” and “100% BLUE WEBER AGAVE” when they are not. As to the threshold issue of standing, plaintiffs argued that they sufficiently pleaded that they were injured by pleading that there were widespread and systemic adulterations in defendant’s tequila. However, the court concluded that plaintiffs failed to allege widespread and systemic adulterations. The court explained that while plaintiffs did plead that news reporting and industry advocates warned that tequila products were adulterated, that plaintiffs did not allege that any of this news reporting pertained to defendant specifically and, therefore, it did not support the allegation that the products’ adulterations were systemic and widespread. The court also disagreed that plaintiffs’ laboratory testing showed widespread and systemic adulterations because the pleadings did not establish either a temporal or geographic link between plaintiffs’ purchased products and the laboratory testing, noting that plaintiffs tested only five samples and did not plead that the samples were taken from a store that plaintiffs frequented. The court concluded that, therefore, plaintiffs failed to establish key facts that would allow the court to extrapolate the testing results broadly to either the products they purchased or all purchasers.

    Pusateri v. Diageo N.A., Inc., No. 25-CV-02482, 2026 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 224425 (E.D.N.Y. Sept. 30, 2026)

    In an unpublished decision, a federal district court dismissed without prejudice a putative class action alleging that Able C&C US, Inc. and Able C&C Co. Ltd. deceptively labeled and advertised four sunscreen products as “waterproof,” “sweatproof,” and that they “block” all “UV rays ‘despite contact with water and sweat’” because all sunscreens eventually wash off in the water. The class action asserted violations of California’s Consumer Legal Remedies Act, False Advertising Law, and Unfair Competition Law and New York General Business Law Sections 349 and 350, among other state consumer protection statutes. The court explained that although the products allegedly did not conform to their waterproof and sun-blocking labeling, they still functioned as sunscreen. As to the allegation that the products were allegedly illegally labeled as “waterproof” and sun-blocking, which allowed defendants “to label and advertise the Products as superior to other sunscreens on the market” and charge more, the court stated that plaintiffs’ examples showing the products’ packaging and websites, however, do not appear to show that defendants marketed or labeled the products as superior and that plaintiffs failed to allege any details regarding the price premium that waterproof sunscreen apparently commands over non-waterproof or partially waterproof sunscreen. The court stated that it “cannot make the inferential leap from misrepresentation to economic injury based on mere speculation.”

    Bui v. Able C&C US, Inc., No. 24-1157, 2026 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 221771 (D.N.J. Sept. 29, 2026)

    NAD Focus

    Market Leader and #1 Claims

    In a challenge brought by competitor Owlet Baby Care, Inc., NAD recommended that baby monitor manufacturer Udisense, Inc. (Nanit) discontinue or modify claims that its product was the “most loved,” “internet’s favorite,” “most awarded,” and the “smartest” baby monitor, as well as other health and safety, and parental sleep claims for its Nanit Smart Video Baby Monitor. As to claims that Nanit products are the “most loved,” “#1 most loved,” and “internet’s favorite” baby monitors, NAD determined that Nanit did not provide reliable evidence that was representative of the marketplace as a whole and recommended that the claims be discontinued. NAD also recommended that Nanit’s “most awarded” baby monitor claims should be discontinued because it is unclear what kind of “awards” are being referenced and because Nanit relied on third-party awards with potentially varying standards and rigor. After assessing whether Nanit’s proprietary tracking capabilities, algorithmic insights, and AI features justified a comparative superiority message over competing smart monitors, NAD recommended that Nanit discontinue its “smartest baby monitor on the market” claims because Nanit failed to provide adequate substantiation. As to claims promising quantified sleep benefits for parents, NAD found that the evidence was not a good fit for specific and quantified parental sleep claims. Thus, NAD recommended that Nanit discontinue the claims that Nanit parents get an extra “36 nights of sleep per year” and “may get more sleep.”

    Udisense, Inc. (Nanit Smart Video Baby Monitor), Report #7558, NAD/CARU Case Reports (Aug. 2026)

    In a challenge brought by competitor Sonova USA Inc., NAD recommended that Starkey Laboratories, Inc. modify or discontinue certain claims for its Omega AI prescription hearing aid, including certain claims concerning speech intelligibility, spatial awareness, competitive performance, and “better hearing all around.” As to Starkey’s “the leader in hearing healthcare” claim, NAD determined that the evidence submitted may support a claim that Starkey is “a” leader in hearing healthcare but did not support the broader claim that Starkey is “the” leader. In support of its claim that Omega AI “delivers better hearing all around,” Starkey’s study found that, among participants who expressed a preference, 94% preferred Omega AI for directionality and 96% preferred Omega AI for speech clarity, but 52% and 42% of participants, respectively, expressed no preference. However, noting its precedent that unqualified preference claims should not be made when 20% or more of respondents express no preference, NAD recommended that Starkey discontinue the claim or modify it to clearly and conspicuously disclose that the 94% or 96% results are limited to “those who expressed a preference” and that the preference was as compared to Starkey’s prior technology. Notably, NAD also determined that AI testing to support advertising claims is an emerging area with potential benefits but emphasized that testing must be properly validated for the specific claims being supported, particularly when claims convey real-world consumer benefits.

    Starkey Laboratories, Inc. (Omega AI Hearing Aid), Report #7566, NAD/CARU Case Reports (Sept. 2026)

    In a challenge brought by competitor eosera, inc., NAD recommended that Lipo Flavonoid LLC discontinue or modify certain express and implied claims for its Earwax Cleansing Kit & Aid Drops regarding product efficacy, safety, and physician recommendations. As to the challenged “#1 ENT Doctor Recommended” claim appearing on packaging and Amazon, eosera argued that the recommendations were for a different Lipo product and that Lipo’s Kit did not exist in 2024 when Lipo’s otolaryngologist survey was conducted. NAD determined that, in the context of Lipo’s packaging, the claim communicates that this specific product is #1 recommended. NAD, therefore, recommended that Lipo modify its “#1 ENT Doctor Recommended” claim to avoid conveying that the claim applies to the Earwax Cleansing Kit & Aid Drops. As to Lipo’s advertising that its solution “dissolves earwax in as little as three minutes” and other efficacy claims, NAD found that Lipo’s in vitro tests, showing substantial dissolution by three minutes, were not conducted under consumer-relevant conditions and recommended that Lipo discontinue the challenged speed-to-dissolution claims and related visualization. NAD also recommended that Lipo discontinue its “clinically tested formula” claim because, in context, consumers would reasonably understand “clinically tested” to refer to efficacy, not safety, as the claims appear alongside claims about dissolving earwax, speed, and effective ear cleaning.

    Lipo Flavonoid LLC (Earwax Cleansing Kit & Aid Drops), Report #7581, NAD/CARU Case Reports (Sept. 2026)


    Internet Service Claims

    In a competitor challenge brought by home internet provider Charter Communications, NAD determined that T-Mobile US, Inc. provided support for certain comparative claims regarding its T-Mobile Fiber (“T-Fiber”). As to T-Mobile’s ads encouraging consumers to “Break free from big cable contracts” and offering to pay early termination fees, NAD determined that the headline, viewed together with the comparison to cable internet, reasonably conveys that major cable internet providers generally, and Spectrum in particular, require contracts from which consumers need to be freed and impose early termination fees, a message it found was not supported. NAD recommended that T-Mobile modify the claim. As to the claims that T-Fiber provides “up to gigabit upload and download speeds,” while cable internet has “uploads slower than downloads,” and that “cable internet often has slower upload speeds,” and “with fiber internet, you get significantly more uploading power than with most cable internet options,” NAD determined that the speed comparison claims are supported as qualified descriptions of traditional cable internet generally and that the claim that fiber provides “significantly more uploading power than most cable internet options” is supported by the evidence. NAD determined the advertising with claims that T-Fiber experiences “no slow down during peak hours,” while cable internet “can slow down during peak hours due to shared bandwidth” reasonably conveys the message that users of Spectrum’s traditional cable internet service can experience some reduction in performance during peak periods but does not convey the message that Spectrum customers will always experience a material slowdown or that Spectrum Internet becomes unreliable during peak periods. Thus, NAD determined the qualified statement that cable internet “can” slow down during peak hours is supported and found the claim that T-Fiber experiences “no slow down during peak hours” was supported.

    T-Mobile US, Inc. (T-Mobile Fiber Internet Service), Report #7565, NAD/CARU Case Reports (Aug. 2026)


    Health Claims

    In a monitoring inquiry, NAD recommended that consumer genetics company Nucleus Genomics, Inc. modify or discontinue certain express and implied claims for its Nucleus IVF+ service. At issue was an Instagram video and a slideshow on the Nucleus website, which opens with, “Now you can see your future child’s health, traits, and potential—before pregnancy even begins,” and presents five embryos that “all look the same,” leaving viewers “guessing” until a doctor taps a button and “the uncertainty lifts,” allowing them to choose a path “with that clarity.” The slideshow includes a “Compare your embryos” chart that assigns each of the five embryos specific values for cancer, type 2 diabetes, and autism spectrum disorder risk, eye and hair color, height, and IQ. The Instagram video features Nucleus’s founder asking a woman whether she would want her baby to be “taller” or “smarter,” and, referencing “six embryos, one of them is the smartest,” asking whether she would pick that one. NAD recommended that Nucleus modify its advertising to avoid conveying the unsupported message that IVF+ enables future parents to accurately compare the relative likelihood that each embryo will develop various conditions such as breast cancer, type 2 diabetes, and autism spectrum disorder. NAD found that Nucleus’s evidence (polygenic risk models showing average benefits from selecting lower-risk embryos) did not establish how accurately IVF+ could rank a full group of five embryos or validate the percentage-point differences displayed in its advertising. NAD also recommended that Nucleus discontinue the claim that clients “can see which embryo has the lowest risk for cancer” or modify it to avoid conveying that Nucleus IVF+ enables clients to accurately predict which embryo has the lowest overall risk of developing cancer finding that Nucleus’s evidence concerning specific cancer models was not a good fit for the claim and did not explain how separate cancer-specific results are combined into a single overall cancer-risk ranking. NAD also recommended that Nucleus modify its advertising to avoid conveying that IVF+ can accurately determine each embryo’s hair and eye color, which embryo will be tallest, and which embryo will have the highest IQ, finding that Nucleus’s evidence failed to establish its ability to accurately identify these features. Nucleus appealed the decision.

    Nucleus Genomics, Inc. (Nucleus IVF+), Report #7559, NAD/CARU Case Reports (Aug. 2026)

    During an NAD inquiry examining Alice Mushrooms, LLC’s support for claims about its mushroom-containing chocolate products, Alice Mushrooms informed NAD that it voluntarily permanently discontinued all of the challenged claims for the Brainstorm product (such as “Clinician-approved chocolate”), and all but one of the claims for its Zen-X product. The remaining claim for Zen-X product was “What you’ll notice: calm, collected, clear-headed” and Alice Mushrooms modified it to “cool, calm and collected is one delicious bite away.” Reviewing the modified claim, NAD recommended that it be further modified to make clear that it is limited to saffron. NAD determined that one of the clinical studies on saffron included many indicia of reliability and found statistically significant results on measures, including tension, stress, and vigor. However, NAD determined that Alice Mushrooms’ evidence (studies of three key ingredients: L-theanine, kanna, and saffron) was not a good fit to demonstrate the impact of L-theanine and kanna extract to confer the claimed cool, calm and collected, and clear headed benefits. NAD noted that nothing prevents Alice Mushrooms from making a qualified claim as to kanna’s safety and tolerability.

    Alice Mushrooms, LLC (Brainstorm and Zen-X), Report #7563, NAD/CARU Case Reports (Sept. 2026)


    Incentivized Review Program Challenge

    In a challenge brought by competitor The Procter & Gamble Company (P&G), consumer products company Zuru Edge Limited voluntarily discontinued practices to comply with the FTC’s Endorsement Guides for future incentivized review programs. P&G alleged that Zuru has been running an incentivized review program through a private Facebook group with 5,000+ members, and that Zuru has solicited consumers to write reviews in exchange for full product price reimbursement and has not instructed reviewers to disclose their material connection. During the inquiry, Zuru stated that it has discontinued the group and modified its practices to instruct consumers to include a clear and conspicuous disclosure that the purchase price of the reviewed product was being reimbursed. As to reviews already posted, NAD recommended that Zuru make reasonable efforts to have any recent reviews of current products revised to include any necessary disclosures or to notify third-party retail channels that these reviews were incentivized.

    Zuru Edge Limited (Incentivized Review Program), Report #7585, NAD/CARU Case Reports (Sept. 2026)


    Savings Claims and Strikethrough Pricing

    Following a routine NAD inquiry, bike manufacturer Syscend, Inc. d/b/a Guardian Bikes modified certain advertising claims and practices concerning its children’s and adult bikes, including savings claims, strike-through pricing, limited-time sale language, and consecutive countdown timers. At issue was whether advertising used in social media, promotional emails, website product and checkout pages, and third-party search advertising, that paired “40% off” claims with limited-time sale language and a free-accessory offer conveyed an unsupported message that consumers would receive both a temporary 40% discount from Guardian’s ordinary prices and free accessories. During the inquiry, Guardian stated that it would modify its advertising to make clear that the savings reflect everyday competitor comparisons, clarify that limited-time accessory bundles are separate from comp-value savings, and ensure sale indicators clearly state what is included. NAD further recommended that clarifying language appear in the main claim or in a clear and conspicuous, noncontradictory disclosure that is repeated where necessary. During the inquiry into Guardian’s strikethrough pricing, which included reference prices that did not clearly disclose that the comparison was based on comparable value rather than Guardian’s own former price for the same product, Guardian stated that it would modify its advertising to provide conspicuous comparative-value disclosures. Guardian also stated that it worked with Google and Meta to remove or revise ads that displayed comparison pricing without the required disclosures and stated that it would monitor its advertising and remove comparison pricing that lacked the disclosures. NAD further recommended that any qualifying language clearly identify the strikethrough price as the comparable value of competitors’ bikes and appear in the main claim or in a clear and conspicuous disclosure that does not contradict the main claim and is repeated where necessary.

    Syscend, Inc. d/b/a Guardian Bikes (Bikes), Report #7592, NAD/CARU Case Reports (Sept. 2026)


    Pressure Washer Claims

    Following a reopened inquiry, NAD determined that Westinghouse Outdoor Power Equipment provided a reasonable basis for its maximum pressure and flow rate claims for certain electric pressure washers under the conditions tested and recommended that it clearly and conspicuously disclose the specific operating conditions to achieve maximum PSI and GPM claims. By way of background, pressure washer performance is generally measured by two metrics: pressure (measured in pounds per square inch or “PSI”) and flow rate (measured in gallons per minute or “GPM”). In the original competitor challenge, TTi Outdoor Power Equipment, Inc. alleged that Westinghouse’s ads inflated the pressure and flow rate of its pressure washers. In that challenge, NAD recommended that Westinghouse discontinue its express claims and, because Westinghouse declined to comply, NAD referred the matter to relevant government authorities. Subsequently, Westinghouse petitioned to reopen the proceeding and provided new testing to support its express claims. NAD found that Westinghouse makes max PSI and max GPM claims without any qualification or disclosure that the maximum PSI and GPM values can only be achieved under a very particular set of conditions. NAD, therefore, concluded that Westinghouse’s unqualified max PSI and max GPM claims did not sufficiently inform consumers of the material limitations of the claims. Accordingly, NAD recommended that Westinghouse clearly and conspicuously disclose the circumstances under which its claimed maximum PSI and GPM are obtainable, including that maximum pressure is measured through three-second trigger cycles.

    Westinghouse Outdoor Power Equipment (Electric Pressure Washers), Report #7496RO, NAD/CARU Case Reports (Sept. 2026)


    NAD to Refer Genspark to FTC for AI Claims

    Following a routine monitoring inquiry concerning certain express claims made by Genspark, Inc. on its website and in the New York City subway about its Genspark.ai agents, NAD will refer Genspark to the FTC and other appropriate agencies for review and possible enforcement action due to its failure to respond and to substantiate its claims.

    Genspark, Inc. (Genspark.ai agents), Report #7584, NAD/CARU Case Reports (Aug. 2026)


    Voluntarily Discontinued Claims

    In a challenge brought by competitor VeSync US Corporation, d/b/a Levoit, household fan manufacturer DREO Incorporated voluntarily discontinued the challenged claims for its pedestal and tower fan products. During the proceeding, DREO informed NAD that it would permanently discontinue all challenged express and implied claims regarding the noise levels, comparative performance, sleep benefits, and value of its pedestal and tower fan products. NAD will treat the discontinued claims as though it recommended they be discontinued.

    DREO Incorporated (DREO Pedestal and Tower Fans), Report #7608, NAD/CARU Case Reports (Aug. 2026)

    Following a Fast-Track SWIFT challenge by competitor Project Applecart LLC, Rational 360, Inc. voluntarily discontinued claims that it has a patent on its Pinpoint Targeting technology. Applecart, which also offers services that help clients target ads and communications to key decision-makers, challenged the express claim that Rational 360 has a patent on its Pinpoint Targeting technology along with an implied claim that it is a novel, sophisticated technology that Rational 360 developed, and for which a patent was issued by the USPTO. NAD will treat the discontinued claims as though it recommended they be discontinued.

    Rational 360, Inc. (Pinpoint Targeting), Report #7612, NAD/CARU Case Reports (Aug. 2026


    Visit Our False Advertising Litigation Practice Page» 

    Subscribe to receive The Ad Standard»

    Read previous editions of The Ad Standard»

  • SEC Issues Innovation Exemption for Tokenized Securities Venues: A New Framework for Onchain Trading of Tokenized NMS Stocks

    I. Introduction

    On September 17, 2026, the Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”) issued an order designed to facilitate onchain trading of tokenized National Market System (“NMS”) stocks through a new category of trading venue, a Tokenized Securities Venue (“TSV”).[1] The so-called “Innovation Exemption” permits TSVs that meet certain specified conditions to trade tokenized NMS stock using permissioned automated market makers and liquidity pools[2] (together, “AMM Liquidity Pools”) and grants a five-year, conditional exemption to TSVs from the definition of “exchange” under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (the “Exchange Act”). The Innovation Exemption also grants a five-year, conditional exemption from the definition of “dealer” under the Exchange Act to liquidity providers in an AMM Liquidity Pool used by a TSV.

    The Innovation Exemption is the latest in a series of actions taken by the SEC under Chairman Paul S. Atkins and his “Project Crypto” initiative, which is aimed at providing regulatory clarity for crypto asset markets. The Order was released just two days after the CLARITY Act—which proposed a legislative framework to establish comprehensive regulations for the digital asset market—failed to advance in the Senate. The Order was issued pursuant to the SEC’s existing exemptive authority, with Chairman Atkins stating that it is an interim measure that “must be followed by durable rulemaking.” This alert summarizes the key provisions of the Innovation Exemption and identifies several important open questions for market participants.

    II. The Exemptions

    The Innovation Exemption grants two distinct exemptions under the Exchange Act. The first exemption, the “TSV Exemption,” exempts TSVs from the definition of “exchange” in Section 3(a)(1) of the Exchange Act, permitting TSVs to operate without registering as national securities exchanges or operating as an alternative trading system under Regulation ATS. The second exemption, the “Covered Firm Exemption,” exempts certain liquidity providers in AMM Liquidity Pools from the definition of “dealer” in Section 3(a)(5) of the Exchange Act. Both exemptions are temporary, expiring on September 17, 2031 (five years from issuance), and are subject to extensive conditions, as explained below.

        1. The TSV Exemption

        a. Definitions

    Definition of TSV. The Innovation Exemption defines a TSV as an organization, association, or group of persons that brings together buyers and sellers of Tokenized NMS Stock by: (1) providing one or more AMM Liquidity Pools for permissioned participants to interact and agree to terms of a trade, and (2) setting standards for persons to access trading on such AMM Liquidity Pools.

    Because TSVs are exempt from the “exchange” definition, they are not required to register as national securities exchanges or comply with Regulation ATS, which otherwise provides an exemption from exchange registration for alternative trading systems.[3] According to the SEC’s release, TSVs offer potential benefits to investors by enabling investor self-custody, around-the-clock trading, fractional ownership of shares, and near-instantaneous settlement.

    Definition of Tokenized NMS Stock. “Tokenized NMS Stock” means an NMS stock[4] that is: (1) a security tokenized by, or on behalf of, the issuer of the underlying NMS stock; or (2) a security tokenized by a third party that is unaffiliated with the issuer of the underlying NMS stock. Tokenized NMS Stock does not include securities where a third party issues a crypto asset representing its own security that provides synthetic exposure to an underlying security, such as a tokenized linked security or a tokenized security-based swap.

        b. Conditions

    The TSV Exemption imposes a comprehensive set of conditions on TSVs, which, if met, will not subject the TSV to the same exchange regulatory framework applicable to national securities exchanges and ATSs. The following summarizes the conditions of the TSV Exemption.

        1. Smart contract transparency. All distributed ledger applications (i.e., smart contracts) used by a TSV must be auditable, public, and deployed on a public, permissionless distributed ledger.
        2. U.S. person requirement. The TSV must be a U.S. person, which subjects it to sanctions compliance obligations administered by the Office of Foreign Assets Control (“OFAC”).
        3. Public notice. At least 30 calendar days before beginning operations, a TSV must publish a detailed public notice prominently on its website. The information to be included in the public notice is extensive, and the Innovation Exemption lists 30 separate categories of requirements, covering topics such as: a disclaimer that the TSV is not registered with the SEC; the TSV’s structure, ownership, and governance; permissioning criteria and access eligibility; the distributed ledger technology and smart contracts used; AMM Liquidity Pool trading procedures and pricing models; fees and compensation; systems safeguards and security audits; clearance and settlement arrangements; material risks; trading oversight and surveillance; and stoppage of trading procedures. These disclosures cover some of the topics that would otherwise be covered in Form ATS-N.
        4. Issuer notice and objection. Before making available for trading a Tokenized NMS Stock that is tokenized by a third party unaffiliated with the issuer, a TSV must provide written notice to the issuer of the underlying NMS stock. Trading may not commence until at least 30 calendar days after the issuer receives such notice. If the issuer objects within that period, the TSV cannot make such Tokenized NMS Stock available for trading.
        5. No primary issuance. No primary issuance or initial offerings of securities are permitted on a TSV; it is limited to secondary market trading. A TSV must verify that any Tokenized NMS Stock made available for trading provides holders with the same rights and privileges as traditional NMS stock of an equivalent class. A Tokenized NMS Stock would be deemed to provide the same rights and privileges as a traditional NMS stock, if, among other things, it conveys the same economic interest, right to receive dividends, voting rights, and residual claim on assets upon liquidation. In addition, Tokenized NMS Stock must trade in a pair with another Tokenized NMS Stock, a non-security crypto asset (e.g., a payment stablecoin), or a tokenized money market fund, as required under the TSV definition in the Order.
        6. Volume and symbol limitations. Tokenized NMS Stock traded on a TSV under the TSV Exemption is subject to limitations on the number of symbols and volumes traded and divided into two tiers:
          • Tier 1 (S&P 500, Russell 1000, and certain exchange-traded products) is limited to 75 symbols traded and 0.25% of average daily share volume during the prior month.
          • Tier 2 (all other NMS stocks, excluding rights and warrants) is limited to 250 symbols traded and 2.5% of average daily share volume during the prior month.

          Under a stepped compliance approach, the first volume threshold breach in a given stock requires no action other than ensuring future compliance; each subsequent breach triggers a mandatory three-month trading pause in the applicable Tokenized NMS Stock.

        7. Transaction data transparency. Transaction data (denominated in U.S. dollars) must be freely and publicly available, machine-readable, and updated within 10 minutes of execution.
        8. Trading halt compliance. A TSV must stop trading in a Tokenized NMS Stock concurrently with any halt or suspension in the underlying NMS stock on the primary listing exchange.
        9. Significant operational event reporting. TSVs must immediately notify participants and promptly notify the SEC of events that have a significant impact on the operation of the TSV or on its participants, including system disruptions and intrusions.
        10. No leverage. A TSV cannot engage in financing activities and therefore may not borrow securities or non-security crypto assets, hypothecate assets, or extend credit to TSV participants for the purpose of purchasing Tokenized NMS Stock on the TSV.
        11. No misrepresentations. A TSV must not misrepresent its registration status and cannot make any statements to the effect that it is registered with the SEC, or that the TSV’s activities have been “approved” or “endorsed” by the SEC.
        12. Books and records. TSVs must maintain current trading records, including, but not limited to, records of trading interest; transactions; participant verification methods; fees, rebates, and discounts; stoppages; trading volume; significant operational events; and all notices submitted to the public, SEC, issuers, and TSV participants in connection with the TSV Exemption. All such books and records must be maintained in the United States and preserved for the duration of the exemption plus three years thereafter.
        1. The Covered Firm Exemption

        a. Scope of Exemption

    The Covered Firm Exemption addresses the regulatory status of liquidity providers that are necessary for the functioning of AMM Liquidity Pools. AMM Liquidity Pools operate by having liquidity providers commit assets to a pool, and liquidity providers normally earn a fee as an incentive for depositing assets in the liquidity pool.

    In the release, the SEC acknowledges that liquidity provision alone does not constitute dealer activity and that persons acting as liquidity providers in an AMM Liquidity Pool would typically qualify as “traders” rather than “dealers” under the Exchange Act.[5] However, because certain liquidity providers may also engage in additional activities carrying indicia of dealing activity, such as quoting prices to customers or asserting control over pricing and inventory of committed liquidity pursuant to agreements or other arrangements, the SEC has provided a temporary, conditional exemption from the definition of “dealer” for these “Covered Firms” to provide greater legal certainty while it evaluates the scope of the term “dealer” more broadly. The Covered Firm Exemption is limited to securities activities related to AMM Liquidity Pools operating under the TSV Exemption.

        b. Conditions

    Similar to the TSV Exemption, the Covered Firm Exemption is subject to certain specified conditions, summarized below.

        1. TSV-provided AMM Liquidity Pool. A Covered Firm’s securities activities must be limited to activities related to trading Tokenized NMS Stock in an AMM Liquidity Pool operating pursuant to the TSV Exemption. A Covered Firm may engage in trading on more than one TSV, and the exemption does not limit a Covered Firm’s non-securities activities (such as activity related to payment stablecoins).
        2. Proprietary accounts only. A Covered Firm must provide liquidity through a TSV and engage in such trading activity solely for its own account. A Covered Firm must not hold or custody customer assets.
        3. Maintenance of records. A Covered Firm must make and retain records relating to its ability to maintain sufficient liquid assets to cover potential losses associated with trading activity (e.g., financial statements); any liquidity supplied in an AMM Liquidity Pool; any agreement, arrangement, or understanding with a TSV to provide liquidity services to an AMM Liquidity Pool; and any incentives, fees, rebates, or other form of compensation received for liquidity provision, including for achieving certain volume thresholds.
        4. Public disclosures. A Covered Firm must prominently disclose on any public-facing website, if applicable: (1) that it is not registered as a broker-dealer; (2) that it may enter into liquidity provision (including market making) agreements or arrangements with a TSV to provide liquidity to an AMM Liquidity Pool; and (3) that it may receive fees, tokens, or other incentives for providing liquidity or achieving certain volume thresholds from a TSV-provided AMM Liquidity Pool.
        5. SEC notification. A Covered Firm must notify the SEC in writing of its role as a Covered Firm, including certain specific information.
        6. No statutory disqualification. The Covered Firm Exemption cannot be relied upon if the Covered Firm or any of its affiliates is subject to statutory disqualification as defined in Section 3(a)(39) of the Exchange Act, unless such person has been permitted by the SEC or relevant self-regulatory organization, by rule, order, or otherwise, to continue its membership or participation notwithstanding the disqualification.

        3. Request for Comment

      The Order solicits public comment on all aspects of the exemptions, including, among other topics: whether the exemptions should be modified or made permanent; the adequacy of the volume and symbol limitations; the broader impact of TSV trading on the liquidity, pricing, or trading of the underlying NMS stocks; whether broker-dealers need additional relief from Regulation NMS or other requirements to participate on TSVs; and whether the exemptive framework should be expanded to cover securities other than NMS stocks.

      III. Open Questions

      While the Innovation Exemption is a significant step forward for onchain trading of tokenized securities, several important questions remain unanswered. Market participants seeking to establish or trade on TSVs should carefully consider the following areas of uncertainty.

          1. Parameters Around the Tokenization Process

      The Order defines “Tokenized NMS Stock” as NMS stock tokenized by or on behalf of the issuer, or by an unaffiliated third party, but provides limited guidance on the mechanics of the tokenization process itself. Further, the Order is silent regarding any custody arrangements required for the underlying security.

      Separately, the Order does not discuss or otherwise reference the ongoing Depository Trust Company (“DTC”) Tokenization Service initiative (the “DTC Pilot Program”),[6] which separately contemplates the tokenization of security entitlements associated with securities held through DTC. Notably, the Order does not explain how the SEC views the relationship between Tokenized NMS Stock under the TSV Exemption and DTC’s tokenized entitlement model.

          1. Verification Requirement Without Guidance on What Constitutes Adequate Verification

      The Order requires a TSV to “verify” that Tokenized NMS Stock made available for trading provides holders the same rights and privileges as traditional NMS stock of an equivalent class. In addition, as a condition of the exemption, the TSV operator’s public notice must describe “the steps (e.g., audits, certifications, attestations) the TSV has taken” to verify that each Tokenized NMS Stock has the same rights and privileges as the underlying NMS stock. However, the Order does not establish minimum standards or specify what methods of verification are sufficient.

          1. Price Discovery and Market Data Dissemination

      The Order acknowledges the possibility of price dislocation between the tokenized market and the traditional market for the underlying security. However, the Order provides limited guidance regarding how market data for Tokenized NMS Stock is expected to be disseminated or integrated into the broader U.S. equity market structure.

      The Order also does not discuss how a TSV should address price dislocation or volatility. Instead, the Order notes that the trading volume limitations[7] imposed as a condition of the TSV Exemption are designed to help limit the potential impact of any price dislocations between the Tokenized NMS Stock and the NMS stock in traditional format and any adverse effects on market quality for NMS stocks.

          1. Written Policies and Procedures

      Although the Order imposes a number of operational obligations, including participant screening, issuer-notification processes, disclosure controls, transaction reporting, and volume monitoring, it does not establish a comprehensive written policies and procedures framework comparable to those applicable to registered broker-dealers, ATSs, or national securities exchanges.

      While the Order indicates that prospective TSV operators should establish policies and procedures reasonably designed to ensure compliance with the express conditions of the Order, the Order provides little guidance as to whether additional supervisory, surveillance, or compliance controls would be expected by the SEC in connection with a review or examination of TSV operations.

          1. MEV

      The Order requires TSVs to disclose their policies and procedures, if any, for addressing Maximal Extractable Value (“MEV”).[8] However, the Order does not mandate that TSVs adopt any specific protections or provide any guidance on how TSVs may protect against potential abuse of MEV or other forms of transaction ordering manipulation. A TSV is merely required to state in its public notice if it does not have such policies and procedures. This disclosure-only approach means that TSV participants may be exposed to front-running and other MEV-related risks and must rely on each TSV’s voluntary measures and their own due diligence to assess the risks.

          1. No Clearance and Settlement Framework

      The Order requires a TSV to describe in its public notice any “procedures or material arrangements undertaken to facilitate clearance and settlement of transactions on the TSV,” but does not prescribe any specific clearance and settlement framework. As noted above, the DTC Pilot Program not only contemplates a similar tokenization process as the Order but also includes a mechanism for the settlement of the underlying NMS stock represented by the tokenized entitlements associated with securities held through DTC.

      The Order, however, neither requires TSVs to utilize a DTC-based settlement model nor expressly states that a DTC tokenization framework would satisfy the settlement expectations of the exemption. For TSV operators, this gap creates uncertainty about how to design settlement procedures that will satisfy both the conditions of the Order and the expectations of participants and regulators, particularly for a security tokenized by a third party, which would likely need to interact with traditional clearing infrastructure.

          1. Absence of AML Framework

      The Order does not establish a comprehensive framework addressing the applicability of the Bank Secrecy Act (“BSA”) or its implementing regulations to TSV operators, liquidity providers, or other TSV participants. Although the Order requires TSVs to disclose participant verification procedures and sanctions-screening controls, it does not address whether, or under what circumstances, a TSV operator’s activities may constitute money transmission or otherwise trigger obligations under the BSA. Existing guidance issued by the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (“FinCEN”) provides that certain digital asset businesses may be deemed money transmitters and therefore required to register as money transmitters, maintain AML compliance programs, satisfy recordkeeping and reporting obligations, and comply with other requirements under the BSA and applicable regulations. The Order does not discuss how these existing obligations apply in the context of TSV operations or how compliance with the Order’s conditions interacts with any independent obligations arising under the BSA.

          1. LP Tokens

      The Order expressly contemplates that liquidity providers will receive liquidity pool tokens (“LP tokens”) representing their proportional interest in an AMM Liquidity Pool and notes that such tokens may include governance rights. However, the Order provides little guidance regarding the treatment of LP tokens under the federal securities laws. Specifically, the Order does not address whether certain LP token features, including governance rights or other economic benefits, could result in the LP token being treated as a separate security.

      IV. What’s Next?

      The Innovation Exemption takes effect immediately, and the SEC is soliciting public comment on the Order’s provisions and potential modifications. The five-year sunset period (expiring September 17, 2031) provides the SEC with a defined window to assess the impact of TSV trading, and the SEC expects to use the experience gained during the exemptive period, together with public comment, to inform permanent rules governing onchain securities trading. Market participants should carefully monitor the comment process and engage with the SEC to help shape the contours of any future rulemaking.


      [1] See Order Granting Conditional Exemptive Relief, Pursuant to Section 36(a)(1) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, from the Definition of “Exchange” in Section 3(a)(1) of the Exchange Act for the Use of Certain Distributed Ledger Trading Venues for Tokenized NMS Stocks and from the Definition of “Dealer” in Section 3(a)(5) of the Exchange Act for Certain Liquidity Providers for Tokenized NMS Stock, and Request for Comment, Release No. 34-106402 (Sept. 17, 2026) (the “Order”).

      [2] A liquidity pool is a portfolio of crypto assets that is algorithmically bound and traded based on the terms of the smart contracts that compose the AMM Liquidity Pool.

      [3] See 15 U.S.C. § 78c; 17 CFR §§ 242.301-304.

      [4] “NMS stock” means any NMS security other than an option and “NMS security” means any security or class of securities for which transaction reports are collected, processed, and made available pursuant to an effective transaction reporting plan, or an effective national market system plan for reporting transactions in listed options. See 17 CFR § 242.600(b)(64)-(65).

      [5] Absent an exception or an exemption, Section 15(a)(1) of the Exchange Act makes it unlawful for a “dealer” to effect any transactions in, or to induce or attempt to induce the purchase or sale of, any security unless registered with the SEC in accordance with Section 15(b) of the Exchange Act. See 15 U.S.C. § 78o. Section 3(a)(5) of the Exchange Act defines the term “dealer” as “any person engaged in the business of buying and selling securities…for such person’s own account through a broker or otherwise” but excludes “a person that buys or sells securities…for such person’s own account, either individually or in a fiduciary capacity, but not as a part of a regular business.” See 15 U.S.C. § 78c. The so-called “trader” exception, which is a statutory exclusion from the definition of “dealer,” is meant to exclude members of the public who buy and sell securities for their own account.

      [6] See Division of Trading and Markets, SEC, Re: No-Action Letter Request Related to The Depository Trust Company’s Development of the DTCC Tokenization Services (Dec. 11, 2025), available here.

      [7] For Tier 1 securities (limited to 75 symbols), TSV trading volume may not exceed 0.25% of the underlying security’s average daily trading volume during the prior month. For Tier 2 securities (limited to 250 symbols), TSV trading volume may not exceed 2.5% of the underlying security’s average daily trading volume during the prior month. Repeated exceedances may result in a three-month trading suspension for the affected Tokenized NMS Stock.

      [8] Sequencing transactions on a blockchain involves multiple actors ultimately aimed at creating a block with the highest fees to the validators or “MEV.” While this process typically leads to both the most efficient use of block space and the highest fees to the validators, the sequencing of transactions can be abused in attacks against users (such as front-running) or leveraged to protect users with price-stabilizing actions (such as back-running).

  • Simpson Thacher Authors Article on Navigating Leverage Limits and EU Regulation

    Securitisation Partner Richard Hanson and Funds Partner Owen Lysak authored an article in International Comparative Legal Guides titled “Back-Leverage and AIFMD II: Navigating Leverage Limits & EU Regulation.” The piece focuses on how the new Alternative Investment Fund Managers Directive II (AIFMD II) leverage limits for loan-originating alternative investment funds interact with back leverage, including non-recourse special purpose vehicle borrowing and a range of structuring approaches increasingly being implemented. The piece also considers the tension between AIFMD II concepts of loan origination and the separate originator analysis under the EU Securitisation Regulation.

    To read the full article, please click here.

     

  • FDIC Proposes Modernized Bank Merger Review Framework

    Interagency Uncertainty Remains

    On September 17, 2026, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (“FDIC”) published a notice of proposed rulemaking that would substantially revise its review processes for transactions requiring prior approval under the Bank Merger Act (the “Bank Merger Act” or “BMA”). If finalized, the proposed rule (the “Proposed Rule”) would introduce materially shorter processing timelines and new transaction categories with expedited processing and modernize the competitive effects analysis for bank merger transactions. Although the Proposed Rule would mark a significant shift in the FDIC’s approach, its practical impact may depend in large part on whether the Department of Justice (“DOJ”), Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (“Federal Reserve”) and Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (“OCC”) move toward a consistent approach to timing and competition analysis, among other statutory factors.

    The Proposed Rule is the latest reversal of FDIC bank merger policy. In 2024, the FDIC finalized a Statement of Policy (the “2024 SOP”) that took a skeptical view of bank mergers, imposed heightened evidentiary and administrative burdens, and contemplated broader antitrust review aligned with the DOJ’s 2023 Merger Guidelines.[1] In 2025, the FDIC rescinded its 2024 SOP and reverted to prior guidance from the 1990s. The Proposed Rule would now go further, replacing the pre-2024 guidance with a more structured and comparatively transaction-friendly framework for application processing, competitive effects analysis and financial stability review.

    Key Takeaways

    • The Proposed Rule would meaningfully recalibrate the FDIC’s bank merger review framework, replacing the more skeptical posture reflected in the 2024 SOP with a more structured and, in several respects, more transaction-facilitative approach.
    • The most significant substantive changes are in the competitive effects analysis, including standardized full thrift weighting, credit union inclusion and the reallocation of centrally booked deposits.
    • New processing categories, shorter timelines and a codified and expanded financial stability safe harbor could materially improve predictability for routine transactions, internal reorganizations and smaller acquisitions.

    Competitive Effects: Reform for Banks of All Sizes

    The competitive effects provisions of the Proposed Rule represent a significant attempt to modernize the traditional local deposit-based bank merger antitrust analysis. While there is broad consensus that the current methodology for calculating HHI thresholds should be updated, there remains a significant divide over how that methodology should be modified.

    During the Biden Administration, the DOJ adopted updated 2023 Merger Guidelines that reflected a more expansive and aggressive antitrust agenda, including consideration of factors well beyond local branch deposit data. The DOJ’s intention was for the 2023 Merger Guidelines to apply across all industries, including banking, and replace the interagency 1995 Bank Merger Guidelines. Although the DOJ’s 2023 Merger Guidelines remain in effect, none of the banking agencies formally withdrew the 1995 Bank Merger Guidelines. This inconsistency has left uncertainty about potentially diverging results between banking agency and DOJ antitrust reviews of bank merger transactions.

    In addition, although the bank regulatory agencies have continued to use the traditional 1995 Bank Merger Guidelines, the methodology has well-known limitations reflecting its origins in a banking market that predates online banking, fintechs and other deposit competitors. As the market for banking products has modernized, the current methodology may overstate local deposit-market concentration, which can impede otherwise attractive merger transactions. The Proposed Rule attempts to address these well-known gaps.

    • Full Thrift Weighting: Thrift deposits would be counted at 100%, regardless of the thrift’s level of commercial lending, rather than the historical presumption of 50% weighting.
    • Credit Union Inclusion: The Proposed Rule would automatically incorporate credit union deposit shares into the HHI calculation. Currently, the Federal Reserve may include credit union deposits at a 50% (or theoretically more) weight if the credit union has a broad field of membership, street-level branches and products and services that compete with those of a bank. Under the Proposed Rule, if all of a credit union’s branches are located within the relevant banking market, the FDIC would count 100% of that credit union’s shares. If only some branches are in the market, the FDIC’s calculation would include a representative portion based on branch count, rather than actual deposit distribution by branch, because that data is not available to the public or to regulators. For community banks operating in rural or concentrated markets where credit unions are major competitors, this change could materially reduce measured HHI and allow some transactions that do not qualify under the current methodology to fall within the traditional safe harbor. For larger banks, including credit unions across their multi-market footprints may lower measured concentration in many markets.
    • Centrally Booked Deposits: The Proposed Rule would distribute centrally booked deposits across markets based on market population as a percentage of total U.S. population, rather than solely in the market in which the deposits are booked for FDIC data purposes. The Proposed Rule does not provide detail about exactly which parties would be included in this expanded methodology or how parties outside the regulatory agencies could replicate the calculation effectively. Although the Proposed Rule is sparse on details, Chairman Hill’s public statement accompanying the rulemaking suggested that this provision “would generally include, for example, deposits placed at banks by fintech companies and various other third parties.” This would represent a material departure from current practice. For large banks with significant online banking, treasury management, or institutional deposit platforms, this approach would distribute deposits previously concentrated at a single headquarters location across the national footprint, diluting concentration in any single market. For community banks competing against large institutions with substantial centrally booked deposits, including those deposits in the denominator in each local market should also reduce the total market HHI concentrations.

    Importantly, the FDIC’s proposed changes to the competitive analysis would not bind the DOJ (which in theory continues to follow the 2023 Merger Guidelines) or the Federal Reserve (which continues to follow the 1995 Bank Merger Guidelines) where Bank Holding Company Act approval is required. Parties to larger or competitively sensitive transactions therefore may still need to manage parallel review processes and potential divergence among federal banking agencies and the DOJ.

    New Categories and Timelines for Application Processing

    The Proposed Rule would establish several new application processing categories, shorter processing periods and truncated publication requirements. If finalized, the FDIC would introduce a new Rapid application processing period for de minimis merger transactions that would be deemed approved after a five-day prior notice process. A separate expedited category would provide a 30-day period for qualifying corporate reorganizations. Qualifying mergers involving eligible depository institutions would receive a 45-day period. Each pathway would be subject to transaction size, structural, and supervisory status conditions summarized in the Appendix.

    Similar to the FDIC’s current process, under the Proposed Rule, all time periods would begin when an application is “deemed substantially complete,” except for the new Rapid processing category. The time period between filing and the point at which an application is deemed substantially complete has historically been a major source of delay in application processing at the FDIC. The FDIC uses this period to request additional information from applicants, and there have been no limits on the amount of time taken or number of additional information requests. Under the Proposed Rule, the FDIC must notify the applicant within 21 days of filing if the application is not substantially complete. If no such notice is provided, the filing is deemed substantially complete, and all processing timelines run from that date. If a deficiency notice is provided, the applicant then has 30 days to cure any identified deficiencies, or the FDIC may return the application as incomplete.

    The Rapid and Expedited categories could provide meaningful relief for many routine transactions and reorganizations. Applicants would need to pre-position review by the Federal Reserve in connection with any related bank holding company approval or Regulation W waiver, as well as by the DOJ with respect to any required competitive review (if possible), to take full advantage of the faster timing. For more traditional bank merger transactions that fall outside the Rapid or Expedited categories, however, these changes will require substantial agency discipline in practice and may do little to limit extended processing periods where agency leadership or staff determine that additional information is necessary. In practice, review periods may be extended through pre-filing engagement, completeness determinations, supplemental information requests, or coordination with other regulators. In 2024, to encourage additional discipline in application processing, the FDIC adopted a resolution proposed by now-Chairman Travis Hill requiring staff to brief the FDIC Board on any application pending 270 days after receipt. To our knowledge, this requirement remains in place and is an important backstop for extended processing periods.

    Financial Stability Safe Harbor

    For some time, the federal banking agencies have applied a presumption that an acquisition of less than $10 billion in assets, or a transaction that results in an organization with less than $100 billion in assets, does not raise material financial stability concerns. The Proposed Rule would codify this presumption but would double the acquisition threshold to less than $20 billion in assets acquired. Notably, under the Proposed Rule, a GSIB or Category II–IV institution could acquire a target with less than $20 billion in total assets without enhanced financial stability analysis. This framework represents a significant departure from the 2024 SOP, under which any merger resulting in a bank with more than $100 billion in total assets received enhanced financial stability scrutiny.

    For transactions outside the safe harbor, the FDIC will apply a balancing test consistent with the banking agencies’ current practice that considers: (1) systemic importance indicators (size, substitutability, interconnectedness, complexity, and cross-border activity); (2) a before-and-after comparison—where a modest incremental increase weighs in favor of approval, and the FDIC notes that two regional banks of equal size merging would not “necessarily by itself raise financial stability concerns”; and (3) whether the merger supports financial stability (rescue and stabilizing mergers receive credit, and the absence of a stability benefit is not held against the applicant).

    Other Significant Provisions

    • “Merger in Substance”: The Proposed Rule would codify the concept of a “merger in substance.” If an insured depository institution acquires 80% or more of another institution’s assets within a 12-month period, the transaction will be treated as a merger requiring a full application. This replaces the informal “de facto merger” doctrine, which lacked a clear threshold and created uncertainty for banks structuring asset acquisitions from non-insured entities.
    • “Significant Asset Transfers”: The Proposed Rule would create a new application obligation for acquisitions of 25% or more of another institution’s assets, whether or not deposit-related. This new requirement is similar to the OCC’s existing prior approval requirement for “substantial asset changes.” Significant asset transfers would require a 30-day notice-and-non-objection process rather than a full merger application. The FDIC may extend the 30-day period for an additional 60 days. In reviewing the notice, the FDIC would consider the capital level of the resulting institution, the purpose of the transaction, the impact on safety and soundness and conformity with applicable laws, regulations and guidance.
    • Convenience and Needs: The Proposed Rule would take a more balanced approach to the convenience and needs factor, focusing on changes to branches, products, and services that would result from the transaction, as compared to the 2024 SOP. For resulting institutions with more than $50 billion in assets, the FDIC, consistent with Executive Order 14331, will also consider fair banking practices, including whether customers are treated less favorably based on political, social, cultural, or religious considerations in connection with reviewing BMA applications. Notably, the Proposed Rule drops the 2024 SOP’s requirement that applicants demonstrate the combined institution would “better” meet community needs with “specific and forward-looking information,” and does not require three-year branch plans or three-year retail banking commitments. The Proposed Rule also confirms that the FDIC does not expect to remove an applicant from an Expedited Category solely as a result of receiving a public comment.
    • Expanded Financial and Managerial Requirements: The Proposed Rule would include a materially expanded financial adequacy factor that would evaluate the capital adequacy and liquidity of the pro forma bank on a stand-alone and consolidated basis, including any revised business plans, at multiple time points under various scenarios. The FDIC noted that it would take into consideration additional key financial metrics, including net interest margin, return on assets and Z-Score (a formula that measures an entity’s risk of insolvency). In its discussion of both the financial and managerial factors, the FDIC emphasized the importance of integration planning under a range of scenarios.

    Conclusion

    The Proposed Rule would represent a meaningful recalibration of the FDIC’s bank merger review framework, moving away from the more skeptical posture reflected in the 2024 SOP toward a more structured and, in several respects, more transaction-facilitative approach. Its proposed timelines, new processing categories, revised competitive effects methodology and financial stability safe harbor could improve predictability for many transactions, particularly routine combinations, internal reorganizations and smaller acquisitions. At the same time, this proposal would only be applicable to transactions reviewed by the FDIC. The proposal does not resolve the broader interagency uncertainty that has long complicated bank merger review.

     

    Appendix

    Summary of Proposed FDIC Application Processing Categories

     

    Processing Category

    Transaction Type

    Timeline

    Key Criteria

    Public Comment

    Rapid

    De minimis merger transactions

    5 business days (deemed approved)

    • All institutions must be “eligible depository institutions”:
    1. Composite CAMELS rating 1–3,
    2. Satisfactory CRA,
    3. Compliance rating 1–3,
    4. Well-capitalized,
    5. No enforcement actions; AND
    6. Resulting institution well-capitalized
    • Receipt of DOJ competitive factors report and expiration of required waiting period (if required)

    AND

    • Assets acquired below HSR threshold (~$111.4M) AND <5% of acquirer’s assets 

    OR

    • Corporate reorganization of operating subsidiary with substantially identical risk profile

    None

    Expedited Corporate Reorgs

    Corporate reorganizations (solely IDI + affiliates) not qualifying as de minimis

    30 days

    • Resulting institution well-capitalized

    AND

    • All parties composite CAMELS rating 1–3

    OR

    • Acquirer is “eligible depository institution” AND assets acquired ≤25% of acquirer’s assets

    15 days (one newspaper publication)

    Expedited Eligible DIs

    Non-corp.-reorg. mergers by eligible depository institutions

    45 days

    • Resulting institution well-capitalized

    AND

    • All parties are “eligible depository institutions” OR acquirer is eligible and assets acquired ≤25% of acquirer’s assets

    30 days (two newspaper publications)

    Standard
    (Tier 1)

    Non-expedited mergers; resulting institution <$50B

    90 days (one 90-day extension; 180 days max)

    • Does not qualify for Rapid or Expedited processing categories
    •  Resulting institution <$50B
    • Not reserved to FDIC Board for determination
    • Consummation not dependent on action by another federal regulator

    30 days (two newspaper publications)

    Standard
    (Tier 2)

    All other mergers ($50B+ or Board-reserved)

    150 days (one 120-day extension; 270 days max)

    • All other filings not qualifying for Rapid, Expedited, or Tier 1 Standard Processing

    30 days (two newspaper publications)

    Standard (Savings Associations)

    All mergers involving state savings associations

    60 days (one 30-day extension) or timing under Rapid or Expedited

    • All filings involving a state savings association

    30 days (two newspaper publications)

     


    [1] Our previous Client Alert discussing the 2024 SOP, a similar proposal by the OCC, and the DOJ’s 2023 Merger Guidelines can be found here.

  • Simpson Thacher Attorneys Author Article Analyzing Public Comments on the DOL’s Proposed 401(k) Alternative Assets Rule

    Partners Erica Rozow, Rajib Chanda and Ryan Brizek, and Associate Isaac Schwarz authored an article titled, “Private Markets, Public Comments: An Overview of the Public Comments Submitted on the DOL’s Proposed Rule on Alternative Assets in 401(k) Plans,” which was published by The Investment Lawyer. The article provided a detailed analysis of the public comments the U.S. Department of Labor received on its proposed rule on alternative assets in 401(k) plans. It also discussed key themes that emerged from the comments and summarized the top areas in which commenters suggested the proposed rule could be refined to provide greater clarity and effectiveness.

    To read the full article, please click here.

  • SEC Joint Statement on Valuation of Private Assets

    I. Introduction

    The SEC’s Office of the Chief Accountant and the Division of Investment Management jointly published a staff statement on September 28, 2026, addressing fair value measurement and disclosure considerations for private assets held by registered funds, business development companies (“BDCs”), and other similar registrants (for purposes of this Alert, “regulated funds”).[1] The joint statement, framed as a “reminder,” focuses on private credit valuation practices, secondaries, and the role of auditors. Advisers to regulated funds should consider benchmarking their valuation processes and investor-facing disclosures against this guidance.

    II. Industry Background

    The staff statement is best understood against the backdrop of extraordinary growth in private credit and secondary market activity in regulated fund structures. Looking first at private credit, the Investment Company Institute recently found that global private credit assets under management grew from $357 billion in 2010 to over $1.7 trillion as of June 2025.[2] The composition of private credit has also shifted markedly: direct lending grew from just 13% of all private credit in 2010 to 56% by mid-2025.[3] Turning to the secondary market, the secondary market for private fund interests continues to grow.[4] Secondary market volume grew from approximately $156 billion in 2024 to approximately $220 billion in 2025 and secondaries funds represented 15% of private equity fundraising in Q1–Q3 2025, nearly double the five-year average.[5]

    Regulated funds and their investors continue to seek exposure to private-market assets, which are often less liquid and do not have readily available market quotations. At year-end 2025, 54% of interval fund assets and 44% of tender offer fund assets were classified as Level 3 under the Accounting Standards Codification (“ASC”) Topic 820 fair value hierarchy (assets for which no observable market inputs exist and that must be valued using significant unobservable inputs and management judgment).[6] An additional 21% of interval fund assets and 42% of tender offer fund assets were held in private funds that are not assigned a level in the fair value hierarchy, investments typically valued using the investee fund’s NAV as a practical expedient.[7] The increasing exposure of investors to Level 3 assets through regulated fund structures, and the popularity of these structures in the asset management marketplace, has led to increased scrutiny of valuation practices.

    III. Private Credit

    The statement emphasizes that fair value measurements for private credit assets must reflect a market participant’s perspective; management should look beyond borrower-specific information from its direct lending relationships and consider the broader market environment, including prevailing credit spreads, liquidity conditions, and the compensation a market participant would demand for bearing the risks associated with the investment. The statement also highlights the importance of robust calibration practices, noting that periodic reassessment of whether valuation model outputs remain consistent with available market information—such as comparable transactions, public market equivalents, secondary market indications, and relevant credit indices—is an important element of a well-functioning valuation process. On the disclosure side, the statement reminds registrants that boilerplate or “overly aggregated” disclosures are insufficient and that ASC Topic 820 requires disclosure of the valuation technique(s), inputs that are significant to measurement, and how changes to those inputs might result in a significantly different fair value. The Staff references “best practices” for the disclosure of portfolio risk characteristics, including the potential materiality of non-accrual status, non-performing investment classifications, and payment-in-kind (“PIK”) interest, especially where PIK represents a growing portion of reported income and may signal increased credit risk or a divergence between reported income and cash returns.

    IV. Secondary Market Activity and the NAV Practical Expedient

    With respect to secondary investments in fund interests, the statement notes that utilizing an underlying fund’s NAV as a practical expedient for the valuation of investments in the fund may result in a measurement that differs from the fair value that might be realized in a transaction between market participants on the measurement date.[8]

    Under U.S. GAAP, a registrant may estimate the fair value of an investment in another entity using the NAV reported by that investee as a practical expedient, provided certain conditions are met.[9] In particular, to apply the practical expedient without adjustment, the investee’s reported NAV must be as of the measurement date and must be calculated in a manner consistent with the measurement principles of FASB ASC Topic 946.[10] Those principles generally require an investment company to measure its investments, including debt and equity securities and other investments, at fair value, determined in accordance with ASC Topic 820 as an exit price from the perspective of market participants at the measurement date.[11] Management is also not permitted to apply the practical expedient if, as of the measurement date, it is probable that the registrant will sell the investment for an amount different from NAV.[12]

    The statement reminds registrants that the practical expedient is optional on an investment-by-investment basis, and that management retains ultimate responsibility for concluding that an investment meets the required criteria. When assessing that an underlying fund’s reported NAV is calculated consistently with ASC Topic 946 measurement principles, registrants should consider all reasonably available information, which may evolve as the secondary market for private fund interests continues to grow. Assessing whether an investee fund’s reported NAV is calculated in a manner consistent with the measurement principles in FASB ASC Topic 946 requires professional judgment, and all reasonably available information should be considered in performing this assessment. If the practical expedient is not appropriate for a particular investment, then the sponsor should follow its valuation procedures with respect to Level 2 or Level 3 assets, as applicable.

    Notably, the statement encourages management to treat the assessment as to the continued appropriateness of the practical expedient as an iterative, evidence-based process, identifying relevant information (including secondary market data and changes in market conditions), evaluating its implications for the conditions required to apply the practical expedient, and documenting the basis for management’s conclusions.

    V. Auditor Considerations

    The statement reinforces that the complexity and judgmental nature of private credit fair value estimates heighten the importance for auditors to exercise “professional skepticism” in gathering and evaluating audit evidence. The statement advises that auditors should perform robust risk assessment procedures that account for external factors, including industry and market conditions, and should recognize that risk assessment is an iterative process requiring modification of audit responses as circumstances change.

    Critically, the statement reminds auditors that they should evaluate the totality of audit evidence, both information that supports and information that contradicts management’s assertions, and should not accept management’s less-than-persuasive evidence regarding fair value conclusions.

    VI. SEC Enforcement Actions

    Although the statement does not create new legal obligations, it articulates baseline expectations against which the SEC will likely measure conduct. Similar expectations are reflected in a series of enforcement actions over the past two decades targeting valuation failures involving illiquid and hard-to-value assets held by registered funds, BDCs, and private fund advisers. These actions reveal several key themes:

    • Calibration is mandatory. Carrying assets at cost or stale marks without reference to available market data is a recurring basis for enforcement action. The SEC has emphasized that carrying illiquid assets at cost without periodic calibration against available market information can constitute a violation of applicable accounting standards.[13]
    • BDC valuation model failures. A fund sponsor should conduct quality-control reviews of quarterly valuation models to avoid the misvaluation of portfolio companies and associated financial misstatements.[14]
    • Compliance infrastructure must match portfolio complexity. Inadequate valuation policies for Level 3 assets can themselves be violations, even absent evidence of intentional manipulation.[15]

    VII. SEC Comment Letter Trends

    The themes in the statement are also reflected in the Staff’s review of regulated fund disclosures. A review of recent comment letters directed at regulated fund registrants reveals recurring areas of focus that reinforce the expectations outlined in the statement:

    • Level 3 transparency. The Staff has pressed registrants to enhance quantitative disclosure of Level 3 inputs, including requiring tabular quantitative presentation and weighted-average methodology explanations, disclosure of reasons for transfers between Level 2 and Level 3, and identification of omitted Level 3 investments.
    • Rejection of boilerplate narratives. The Staff has required more tailored analysis when disclosure of unobservable inputs is vague. This directly mirrors the statement’s warning that disclosures using “boilerplate” language or presenting information on an “overly aggregated basis may not provide sufficient context” to investors.
    • Valuation methodology, process, and frequency. The Staff has questioned whether the frequency of valuation for Level 3 investments is appropriate given the fund’s redemption and share offering practices.

    VIII. Conclusion

    The statement is a clear reminder that robust valuation policies and procedures, paired with accurate disclosure, are essential. As a practical matter, we expect that the Staff will point to the statement as part of the disclosure review process and in exam and enforcement processes; sponsors should therefore consider benchmarking their internal processes and investor-facing disclosures against this guidance.


    [1] Kurt Hohl & Brian Daly, Statement on Fair Value Measurement and Disclosure Considerations for Private Assets, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (Sept. 28, 2026) (“Staff Statement”).

    [2] Investment Company Institute, Valuation Governance Considerations for Private Credit Assets in Regulated Funds (Apr. 2026) (“ICI Report”).

    [3] Id.

    [4] William Blair, 2026 Secondary Market Report, https://www.williamblair.com/-/media/downloads/ib/2026/williamblair-pca-secondary-market-report-survey-2026.pdf.

    [5] Preqin, Preqin’s Latest Global Reports Spotlight Key Private Markets Trends From 2025 And Beyond (Dec. 17, 2025), https://www.preqin.com/about/press-release/preqins-latest-global-reports-spotlight-key-private-markets-trends-from-2025.

    [6] ICI Report at 5.

    [7] ICI Report, Figure 2 at 4.

    [8] See FASB ASU 2009-12 (“The amendments in this update create a practical expedient to measure the fair value of an investment in the scope of the amendments in this Update on the basis of the net asset value per share of the investment (or its equivalent) determined as of the reporting entity’s measurement date. Therefore, certain attributes of the investment (such as restrictions on redemption) and transaction prices from principal-to-principal or brokered transactions will not be considered in measuring the fair value of the investment if the practical expedient is used.”).

    [9] See FASB ASC 820-10-15-4 through 15-5; see also ASC 820-10-35-59.

    [10] See FASB ASC 820-10-15-4 through 15-5; see also ASC 820-10-35-59 (addressing conditions necessary for applying the NAV practical expedient).

    [11] See ASC 946-320-35-1 and ASC 946-325-35-1.

    [12] See FASB ASC 820-10-35-62 (addressing the probable sale criteria related to applying the NAV practical expedient).

    [13] In re KCAP Financial, Inc., SEC Release No. 34-68307 (Nov. 28, 2012). See also In re Deer Park Road Management Co. LP, SEC Release No. IA-5245 (June 4, 2019).

    [14] In re Fifth Street Mgmt. LLC, SEC AP Release No. 3-18909 (Dec. 3, 2018).

    [15] In re Sciens Diversified Managers, SEC AP File No. 3-21445 (May 24, 2023).